Critical throttle cut and throttle hold issue

[azaz44]

Ethos 1.5.7

I don't know if this problem existed before (in 1.4.x) because I didn't use built-in throttle mix up to now. Now in 1.5 throttle mix was improved and looks great so I use it.

Problem is:

• releasing throttle-cut outputs normal throttle value for a short time even when throttle-hold is engaded. Then after a short time it comes to a proper value which is set for throttle-hold

To reproduce I made a clean model ('other' type) and just added one throttle mix. Setup like this:

(sorry for photos quality, I make tthis report while at the field)

And this is what happens when I flip throttle cut, while throttle hold is enabled all the time

https://youtu.be/Egdh166_Up0?si=NxE51a4uMInujmQH

I marked it as critical, because it caused an unwanted spoolup in one of my helicopters.

[bsongis-frsky]

I think it is already fixed in 1.5.8 nightlies, would you please confirm?

[azaz44]

I think it is already fixed in 1.5.8 nightlies, would you please confirm?

I tested and problem still exists in todays (2024.05.13) 1.5.8 nightly.

[spoke2570]

It is somewhat intermittent on my X20S in todays (2024.05.13) 1.5.8 nightly. Takes many flips to make the error happen, then happens for several flips, takes several flips to make it happen, etc.

[github-actions[bot]]

This issue is stale because it has been open 90 days with no activity. Remove stale label or comment or this will be closed in 30 days.

[azaz44]

Issue is still there in 1.5.12.

[github-actions[bot]]

This issue is stale because it has been open 90 days with no activity. Remove stale label or comment or this will be closed in 30 days.

[azaz44]

Issues still there in 1.5.18, this is really an issue for helicopters with governors, as throttle not low for even this flash of a seconds starts spoolup procedure for a short time and will spil blades.