search

FreeRADIUS / pam_radius

This is the PAM to RADIUS authentication module. It allows any Linux, OSX or Solaris machine to become a RADIUS client for authentication and password change requests.
GNU General Public License v2.0
103 stars 90 forks source link

Support for TCP #102

Open jake-scott opened 1 month ago

jake-scott commented 1 month ago

It would be useful for pam_radius to support TCP. In particular, using UDP it is difficult for pam_radius to know if a server is down or just taking a while to respond and that makes it difficult to tune timeouts to support failover properly.

In my use case, the RADIUS server can take a long time to respond when it prompts the user over a separate channel like a mobile push request. There doesn 't seem to be a sensible response it can send back to the client to tell it that the auth is underway. So the client has to decide when to give up and move on to another server. When it does that there will be another push sent to the user.

Using TCP would help here as the client could be configured to move on to other servers if it can't connect and have a separate request timeout once it has connected to a server.

I would be willing to work on this and provide a patch if people think this is a useful feature.

alandekok commented 1 month ago

RADIUS doesn't support a "still working on it" packet notification, so that can't be done.

If you need to support both fail-over and long timeouts, then TCP is a reasonable choice. I think the patches should be small. Please send them over and I'll take a look.