search

FreeRTOS / FreeRTOS-Cellular-Interface

FreeRTOS Cellular Interface implementation of the 3GPP TS v27.007 standard.
MIT License
85 stars 59 forks source link

URC frame not handled correctly #179

Open rickou opened 1 month ago

rickou commented 1 month ago

Hi there,

I started to port the driver to ME310G1 modem inspired from SARA-R4 driver. Connexion is now working and I'm currently porting the socket layer. I'm facing the lib do not handle URC correctly.

Once socket is opened, the ME310 send URC "SRING: x" (with x=socket ID) to inform data are available. but this URC is not handled by the lib. instead i get

DEBUG [ME310 ] 12 bytes received (..SRING: 1..) DEBUG [CELLULAR ] AT Read 12 bytes, data[200080c6] INFO [CELLULAR ] AT_UNDEFINED message received SRING: 1 ERROR [CELLULAR ] No undefined callback for AT_UNDEFINED type message SRING: 1 received. ERROR [CELLULAR ] recvdMsgType is AT_UNDEFINED for Message: SRING: 1, cmd NULL DEBUG [CELLULAR ] _handleMsgType failed 11

If i right understood the lib source, URC message can't be without prefix.. but it is the case here..

kstribrnAmzn commented 1 month ago

It looks like the SRING: x is being treated as an undefined message rather than a unsolicited message. What does your pCellularUrcTokenWoPrefixTable look like?

chinglee-iot commented 1 month ago

@rickou We would like to use the issue only for bug or feature tracking and move the question to the FreeRTOS forum. I saw you have another thread in the forum. I would suggest we keep a single source of discussion in the FreeRTOS forum and close the issue here.

rickou commented 1 month ago

@chinglee-iot , you're right ! in fact i 1st post here because in my mind, the lib should not take care about the leading char of frames... that's could make it more generic.. but after this i remembered there is a forum, and i asked there because maybe it was only a misunderstood of the lib api at my side.. Again, for me, maybe it could be good to make enhancements to the lib to be more generic. if there is no way for this, please be free to close this ticket ! i will not be offended.. 😉