Open AmyMagdalena opened 2 weeks ago
Maybe we need configurable subtitle settings instead.
Lets say user UI is in Hindi but configures subtitle to be set to English by default.
We could configure the fallback in this order.
English provided by the creator of the video -> Auto generated English -> UI language translated from English.
English provided by the creator of the video -> Auto generated English -> UI language translated from English.
the last one in this list would never get used
Im sorry im not sure i understand you correctly. Could you elaborate some more on this?
In a situation where the 3rd entry "UI language translated from English" occurs, one of the first 2 entries have already occured and thus it would not occur. I think perhaps you meant to say "UI language translated from non-english" where it could then occur.
Lets take the following example. This would be the fallback strategy when my UI is set to Dansk/Danish and i configured subtitle to be set to English by default.
If English is not provided by creator of video then fallback to English Auto generated. If English Auto generated is not available fallback to Danish (Translated from "English")
3 could fire if it was Danish (translated from "German"), it couldn't fire if it was Danish (translated from "English") if English is the default subtitle language
this is just an example...
Could you elaborate some more on the flaw you are seeing in this fallback strategy
Guidelines
Problem Description
Hi, I have FreeTube's UI set to Catalan and subtitles defaulting to on, and this is great, however I watch a lot of English language content and as a native speaker of English, google translated Catalan being the default isn't very desirable. However I also have audio processing disorder as a symptom of my ADHD and so I like having English subtitles.
Proposed Solution
Allow subtitle language to be set to Original Language
Alternatives Considered
Allow a default language or priority list for languages to be set
Issue Labels
new feature, new optional setting
Additional Information