search

FreshRSS / FreshRSS

A free, self-hostable news aggregator…
https://freshrss.org
GNU Affero General Public License v3.0
9.06k stars 797 forks source link

[BUG] Using keyboard shortcut j makes feed jump #5551

Open poblabs opened 1 year ago

poblabs commented 1 year ago

Describe the bug I am new to FreshRSS so I am checking it out. When I am browsing the main stream and use hotkey j to go to the next article, the whole stream jumps up and goes out of view. I then have to use my mouse to bring it back to view - which defeats the purpose of the hotkeys.

To Reproduce Steps to reproduce the behavior:

  1. Go to Main Stream
  2. Press j
  3. Wait a second
  4. Stream jumps

Expected behavior Stream to not jump and stay on the current article - top aligned.

Screenshots Start of the main stream:

image

After pressing j, it goes to the next article but then it jumps and results in not being top-aligned. You can see how this comic is cut off at the top.

image

The full article should have looked like this (not cut off after a weird jump):

image

Environment information (please complete the following information):

Frenzie commented 1 year ago

Can't confirm (whether on that exact same version of Chrome except on Linux or in Firefox 115.0.2). But that was to be expected; I'd have noticed long ago if I could.

Do you have any extensions that could be involved?

Alkarex commented 1 year ago

Try also the following option:

image

poblabs commented 1 year ago

I downloaded firefox with no extensions to give this a try and the jumping behavior is happening again.

I've disabled lazy load of images, and have that option selected @Alkarex . Not sure what else to look for.

One thing I've noticed is that it seems to happen if I press j faster than the article is marked as read. Maybe that's something? Is there a way to mark the article read instantly?

There are some feeds I have from twitter that are mostly retweets or something, so I fly through those pretty fast.

image

Frenzie commented 1 year ago

Pardon, by extensions I meant FreshRSS extensions, though nothing wrong with ruling out browser extensions too.

One thing I've noticed is that it seems to happen if I press j faster than the article is marked as read. Maybe that's something? Is there a way to mark the article read instantly?

That's normal and done separately on the side. That isn't to say there couldn't be something to what you're saying about doing it very quickly but it shouldn't be related to the articles being marked as read. (That being said I regularly press J and K very quickly.)

poblabs commented 1 year ago

Got it, and nope - no FreshRSS extensions. I did a little screen recording to try and show what I mean. It didn't capture my key presses, but there were about 1 second apart. You can see the articles start jumping around.

Not sure what else to do

https://github.com/FreshRSS/FreshRSS/assets/3484775/d1a909f9-105e-48a0-9046-c56e91f5a904

poblabs commented 1 year ago

Update, found this utility that can show my keyboard presses on screen. Hope this helps?

https://github.com/FreshRSS/FreshRSS/assets/3484775/751b8df5-28e6-48dc-95bc-958c917673aa

Frenzie commented 1 year ago

Yeah, keypress-wise I'm not seeing anything I don't do. It's possible I have fewer images in my feeds which potentially comes back to the lazyloading but I also have plenty that do.

Maybe something less typical like embeds?

Alkarex commented 1 year ago

Can you remember having changed any settings, for instance Number of articles per page:

image

In any case, can you try with a higher value such as 30?

poblabs commented 1 year ago

Can you remember having changed any settings, for instance Number of articles per page:

In any case, can you try with a higher value such as 30?

No change in behavior. Setting to 30, and unchecking "Load more articles at the bottom of the page" still result in the article jumping