search

Frogging-Family / linux-tkg

linux-tkg custom kernels
GNU General Public License v2.0
1.32k stars 163 forks source link

Missing CPU schedulers for 6.0.2 #631

Closed italoghost closed 1 year ago

italoghost commented 1 year ago

Describe the bug

image

robson-66 commented 1 year ago

You need to edit the prepare file in line 300, delete _avail_cpu_scheds = ("cfs" "tt" "bore") and add _avail_cpu_scheds = ("cfs" "pds" "bmq" "cacule" "tt" "bore")

italoghost commented 1 year ago

@robson-66 thanks!

Tk-Glitch commented 1 year ago

They were disabled due to bugs. The project C developer haven't updated the patchset for 6.0 just yet, so we were shipping a user's rebase which he wasn't too sure about. Since PDS and BMQ are among the most popular CPU schedulers we offer, offering buggy versions of them didn't feel too good.

italoghost commented 1 year ago

@Tk-Glitch So is it better to wait to the updated patchset? I am asking this because there is a pds and a bmq version on the releases page.

Tk-Glitch commented 1 year ago

The release was already building when I disabled them. See https://github.com/Frogging-Family/linux-tkg/commit/d60046d9fb565bb70992c821905aff18a18d43f9

I couldn't reproduce the stability issues reported on my own machine, so you might be fine. But in case you face hangs or random reboots, that would most likely be it.

robson-66 commented 1 year ago

For me, the bmq was built without any problems and also works properly.

italoghost commented 1 year ago

Thank you, guys!

I am experiencing some strange behavior since the kernel 6.0.0 pds: my computer seems to lose the input signal from the screen and from the mouse and keyboard, as they stop working. But the computer is still working, as I can hear the sounds just fine (the first time this happened I was on call with friends).

Is this behavior related to the stability issues that were reported?

Tk-Glitch commented 1 year ago

Thank you, guys!

I am experiencing some strange behavior since the kernel 6.0.0 pds: my computer seems to lose the input signal from the screen and from the mouse and keyboard, as they stop working. But the computer is still working, as I can hear the sounds just fine (the first time this happened I was on call with friends).

Is this behavior related to the stability issues that were reported?

Very likely. Test CFS out and see I guess 😅

Melechtna commented 1 year ago

thing is, even with cfs I get the "blank screen" issue any time I wake from sleep, so I don't think it's PDS. The wake from sleep issue isn't even a problem, as simply hot plugging one of my 3 monitors will wake all of them back up.

seankhl commented 1 year ago

I am also getting some issues with PDS on 6.0.0. I faced some black screen issues and lockups, not frequent but definitely present.

I also have separate issues of waking from sleep on all kernels and schedulers since changing to an RX 6600, so I just don't put my computer to sleep for the time being until the issue is resolved.

Melechtna commented 1 year ago

I am also getting some issues with PDS on 6.0.0. I faced some black screen issues and lockups, not frequent but definitely present.

I also have separate issues of waking from sleep on all kernels and schedulers since changing to an RX 6600, so I just don't put my computer to sleep for the time being until the issue is resolved.

I've honestly never had a lock up that wasn't self inflicted with any scheduler, only exception being bmq and tts, which I haven't tested, which includes pds, which I'm currently using without issue aside from the sleep thing

Everest10 commented 1 year ago

You need to edit the prepare file in line 300, delete _avail_cpu_scheds = ("cfs" "tt" "bore") and add _avail_cpu_scheds = ("cfs" "pds" "bmq" "cacule" "tt" "bore")

Are you serious ? lol. Delete this comment. There is still time.

Melechtna commented 1 year ago

You need to edit the prepare file in line 300, delete _avail_cpu_scheds = ("cfs" "tt" "bore") and add _avail_cpu_scheds = ("cfs" "pds" "bmq" "cacule" "tt" "bore")

Are you serious ? lol. Delete this comment. There is still time.

That's how I'm on Kernel 6.0 with PDS currently.

robson-66 commented 1 year ago

Are you serious ? lol. Delete this comment. There is still time.

I am not trying to persuade anyone to edit the prepare. But I only gave a way to be able to build bmq and pds, because on some machines it works fine.

Everest10 commented 1 year ago

Are you serious ? lol. Delete this comment. There is still time.

I am not trying to persuade anyone to edit the prepare. But I only gave a way to be able to build bmq and pds, because on some machines it works fine.

I'm waiting for pds and bmq too, but your comment to just change one line in the installation code to create a bypass like is not the proper solution.