search

FuelLabs / fuel-bridge

The canonical Fuel bridge mono repo.
https://app.fuel.network/portal/bridge
Apache License 2.0
168 stars 71 forks source link

Bridge tx debited but not credited in my Metamask wallet #131

Closed HoTandy closed 6 months ago

HoTandy commented 6 months ago

Yesterday I made a Bridge transaction from my Fuel wallet to a a Sepolia Wallet I set up in Metamask.

Fuel wallet version: Version: 0.15.2

image

I clicked away from the bridge when it was in the state in screenshot above.

The transaction ID is: https://app.fuel.network/tx/0xcae664b7a7f8f4cd19ed3c4232b3a1d52fcdf798b36e99e9a29ff0f7235e7c0c/simple

I see that the transaction has taken place in my Fuel wallet:

image

from: fuel1dedeagaksypljjga2yy95dkxl2lk555dkujmu8qmrgerpxypvdvqxsl2ut (copied from fuel wallet) to: 0x000000000000000000000000940aa7516018d954736c2ab1628337666f302fd8 (copied from fuel wallet) and: 0x940AA7516018D954736C2ab1628337666F302fd8 (copied from Metamask wallet)

image

Only when I click to History do I see that I have to confirm the transaction.

image image

When I click confirm Metamask pops up as if the Bridge is asking Metamask to sign the transaction.

image

but it cannot as there's not enough ETH in the wallet to do this.

but should this be happening at all? Surely the receiving wallet should not need to sign a transaction, or confirm an incoming transaction or have to pay a fee for an incoming transaction.

Is this a bug? Please let me know if I'm doing something wrong. Maybe the Bridge is opening Metamask when it should be opening the Fuel wallet extension. Or is this how it works with this kind of smart contract?

LuizAsFight commented 6 months ago

this is how it works. the last step of withdraw is relay the message on ETH side to complete the transaction. that can only be done by you using your signature.

After you complete this transaction, you will see the balance in your metamask. Did you try to complete? you can faucet some Sepolia ETH to your metamask wallet here: https://www.alchemy.com/faucets/ethereum-sepolia

HoTandy commented 6 months ago

Excellent, thanks for the additional information, I'll some Sepolia ETH and see if the transaction completes, if it does, ....we should be able to close this bug.

LuizAsFight commented 6 months ago

also, in the bridge screen while starting a WITHDRAW ERC-20 operation, you will see an alert saying:

You don't have any ETH on Fuel to pay for gas. We recommend you bridge some ETH before you bridge any other assets.

On this way we prevent users of starting the operation not having the necessary funds to finish it in ETH side.

The same alert could be added to prevent withdrawing ETH with not having funds on eth side also

HoTandy commented 6 months ago

Hi Luiz, 3 days ago there was some kind of network error with the Alchemy faucet, but today I finally managed to get a hold of some Sepolia ETH on my (Sepolia) Metamask. Then I was able to confirm the transaction with Metamask. So apart from Fuel TS (or JS) consuming a lot of Chrome resources and the fans lightning up on my machine https://github.com/FuelLabs/fuel-explorer/issues/221, the whole process was smooth in the end.

Thanks a lot for your support! I'll close this (non-)"bug" :-)