hiya - is this project actually open source?

ladyada commented 2 years ago

hi there, on the kickstarter page and hackaday page (https://hackaday.io/project/164934/logs) describing this product is the text

"Since its origins, the FunKey S has proudly been Open Hardware & Open Source."

with the open source hardware logo and OSI logo:

which is awesome! the open source hardware association, whose 'gear' logo is used on that page https://www.oshwa.org/open-source-hardware-logo/ says "This logo may be used if your hardware complies with the Open Source Hardware Definition." The definition at https://www.oshwa.org/definition/ specifies that you cannot have 'non commercial' as a restriction on the license.

This repository has a "Non Commercial" license tag.

please clarify:

if this is open hardware and if so, please update the license so it matches the requirements of using the open hardware logo and description.
or if it not open hardware, you cannot use the logo and must update the hackaday, kickstarter page, etc.

thank you :)

ladyada commented 2 years ago

hiya @squonk42 @Michel-FK @Vincent-FK please look at this issue and reply!

ladyada commented 2 years ago

also found on the wiki, another place that is not correct:

https://wiki.funkey-project.com/wiki/FunKey_Wiki_Knowledge_Center#What_is_the_FunKey_S?

Where can I find FunKey S device schematics and 3D files?

The FunKey Team has FunKey S schematics, STL files, and a project STEP file for the device's shell components available on [Grabcad](https://grabcad.com/library/funkey-s-1). Schematics for the device's electrical components are available on the FunKey Team's [GitHub page](https://github.com/FunKey-Project/FunKey-S-Hardware). As the device's hardware is open source, users are free to download, modify, and redistribute the listed files.

Vincent-FK commented 2 years ago

Hi @ladyada,

Since it's our first product I must admit we're still tiptoeing around all the legal details so thanks a lot for your input, it's been corrected.

Oh and btw, it goes without saying but still: thanks for Adafruit! Without it Keymu would never have been prototyped, which by extension means the FunKey S would not be there either.

ladyada commented 2 years ago

thats wonderful - thank you so much for updating the license. im really enjoying my funkey now EVEN MORE SO! :)

FunKey-Project / FunKey-S-Hardware

hiya - is this project actually open source? #3