FunkinCrew / Funkin

A rhythm game made with HaxeFlixel
https://www.newgrounds.com/portal/view/770371
Other
2.97k stars 2.29k forks source link

Bug Report: Charting errors in several songs #2648

Closed afreetoplaynoob closed 2 weeks ago

afreetoplaynoob commented 5 months ago

Please check for duplicates or similar issues, as well performing simple troubleshooting steps (such as clearing cookies, clearing AppData, trying another browser) before submitting an issue.

If you are playing the game in a browser, what site are you playing it from?

If you are playing the game in a browser, what browser are you using?

What version of the game are you using? Look in the bottom left corner of the main menu. (ex: 0.2.7, 0.2.1, shit like that)

0.3.3

Have you identified any steps to reproduce the bug? If so, please describe them below in as much detail as possible. Use images if possible.

Play or check the chart data/metadata of any of the songs mentioned.

Please describe your issue. Provide extensive detail and images if possible.

Some songs have errors in their charts, some more noticable than others: Screenshot 2024-06-03 12 08 06 Screenshot 2024-06-03 12 18 25 Screenshot 2024-06-03 15 06 51 Screenshot 2024-06-03 14 59 44 M.I.L.F. (Easy) and Lit Up (Hard) both have notes stacked on each other, making them impossible to hit with one key press. (Also it would be nice if the note in the fourth picture, present in all difficulties, was properly synced with the singing.)

Screenshot 2024-06-03 12 09 03 Monster has its BPM changes all messed up; the camera zooming and health icon bopping are completely off-beat.

Screenshot 2024-06-03 12 09 26 Winter Horrorland has the scroll speed for all of its difficulties set to 0.

NotHyper-474 commented 5 months ago

Some of these were already reported in https://github.com/FunkinCrew/Funkin/issues/2525 and #2350 but this does add some more info.

afreetoplaynoob commented 5 months ago

Yep, was planning to add that detail in the issue, guess I forgot... Regardless, there might be even more charting errors, beyond the ones others have mentioned already, that no one has noticed or brought up yet, and I'm pointing out the ones I've seen, even if I end up repeating some of the known ones.

Hundrec commented 2 weeks ago

As of 0.5.2, all of these issues (except the UI bop desync in Monster) are resolved! We might want to create an updated issue focusing only on Monster's BPM changes for the sake of clarity