search

FunkinCrew / Funkin

A rhythm game made with HaxeFlixel
https://www.newgrounds.com/portal/view/770371
Other
2.95k stars 2.29k forks source link

Bug Report: Note Pressing Keybinds Override Eachother When Bound, Preventing Multiple Keybinds #2780

Open Average-FNF-Modder opened 4 months ago

Average-FNF-Modder commented 4 months ago

Describe the bug

      When changing the 2 keybinds sets for game play, upon entering a song, one of the 2 sets will take over the other and the over written one will not be functional. Upon exiting said song and going back to settings, both keybind sets will read the same bindings. This makes it impossible to have to keybinds for each key as intended.

To Reproduce

      Go into settings, change you note hit keybinds, enter a song, one set of keys will not work. You can exit the song and then also see the bug in settings with the keybinds.

Expected behavior

      It should let me have to keybinds per note. I only end up getting one binding. Very sad.

Screenshots/Video

      It's not really need here. You get the idea. Both keybind slots say the same thing, the end.

Desktop

Hundrec commented 1 week ago

I tested both sets of arrow inputs in a song on 0.5.1 and it worked fine. I think this is resolved!

Average-FNF-Modder commented 1 week ago

I tested both sets of arrow inputs in a song on 0.5.1 and it worked fine. I think this is resolved!

I just tested it myself once again, and the bug still occurred for me; maybe the bug varies by device, but it's definitely still present.

Hundrec commented 1 week ago

Can you provide a video? I'm really curious to know more about this issue

Average-FNF-Modder commented 1 week ago

Sure thing bro.

https://github.com/user-attachments/assets/bd0da08c-09b4-4f96-a279-6f36531276f5

I try to go play Pico 2-handed, one side doesn't work, and I'm fucked. It's annoying for me especially cause I like to switch between one handed arrow keys only and 2 handed a s up right.

Hundrec commented 1 week ago

So if you try to bind WASD to either the first or the second column, it resets into the arrow keys?

Average-FNF-Modder commented 1 week ago

So if you try to bind WASD to either the first or the second column, it resets into the arrow keys?

It's happened the other way around as well. I haven't tested enough to see if there is something specific that decides which side will override the other.

Hundrec commented 1 week ago

That's really strange. I thought arrow keys and WASD were bound as the default pair of controls

Average-FNF-Modder commented 1 week ago

That's really strange. I thought arrow keys and WASD were bound as the default pair of controls

They actually are, and work fine that way. Something interesting about the bug is that it doesn't happen until you mess with the keybinds once to start. If you never change them, you'll get arrow keys and wasd working as intended. But as soon as you touch them once, like when I changed to dfjk one time, the bug starts, and then will keep happening forever onwards.