search

FunkinCrew / Funkin

A rhythm game made with HaxeFlixel
https://www.newgrounds.com/portal/view/770371
Other
2.81k stars 2.23k forks source link

Enhancement: BG Music stays playing if music is muted. #2878

Open Average-FNF-Modder opened 1 week ago

Average-FNF-Modder commented 1 week ago

What is your suggestion, and why should it be implemented?

Pretty simple, if all audio tracks that were added to the chart are muted, than the BG music should keep playing in the background if spacebar is hit to play the song.

Hundrec commented 1 week ago

This suggestion sounds intuitive, but I'm having trouble thinking of cases where someone would want this to happen.

If I've muted all the tracks in the chart, then I might be seeing how the chart's note patterns flow. In this case, I would rather have Artistic Expression muted so I can focus on the rhythms of the chart rather than the BGM.

Of course, the theme could easily be toggled from the context menu, but it seems like an unfavorable compromise to have to turn off the theme globally just to focus on the chart.

Average-FNF-Modder commented 6 days ago

This suggestion sounds intuitive, but I'm having trouble thinking of cases where someone would want this to happen.

If I've muted all the tracks in the chart, then I might be seeing how the chart's note patterns flow. In this case, I would rather have Artistic Expression muted so I can focus on the rhythms of the chart rather than the BGM.

Of course, the theme could easily be toggled from the context menu, but it seems like an unfavorable compromise to have to turn off the theme globally just to focus on the chart.

I just don't think it would really bother me at all to have it in the background. Maybe it would bother some people, so it could be an option or something to have my idea on or not.