Appending multiple sources simultaneously does not respect order

[achilleas-k]

While working on the Matlab bindings, @mpsonntag found the following issue.

When appending multiple sources to an EntityWithSources (tested with Group), they are either not appended in order, or the retrieval does not happen in order.

The following code demonstrates the issue:

#include <nix.hpp>

int main(){
    nix::File file = nix::File::open("extendorder.h5", nix::FileMode::Overwrite);
    nix::Block b = file.createBlock("blk", "blk");
    nix::Group g = b.createGroup("group", "grp");

    for (int idx = 0; idx < 10; idx++) {
        b.createSource(std::to_string(idx), "src");
    }

    g.sources(b.sources());
    for (auto src : g.sources()) {
        std::cout << src.name() << std::endl;
    }
    file.close();

    return 0;
}

(output is random).

Replacing g.sources(b.sources()) with a loop that appends sources in order works as expected however.

[jgrewe]

actually it works as specified :)

The order changes due to the linking mechanism. The link is done using the id, not the name. If you print out the id it is in perfect order.

[achilleas-k]

Interesting. Is this the intended behaviour? Should we be sorting by supplied order (as it appears in the vector)?

[jgrewe]

ok ok, I have to correct myself. When we create the group we specify that the oder should be by creation oder. HErr res = H5Pset_link_creation_order(gcpl.h5id(), H5P_CRT_ORDER_TRACKED | H5P_CRT_ORDER_INDEXED);

In the vector setter we order the passed entities by name, create the differences with the already present once, remove and add according to name.

The other thing I wonder: Do we really want to go long ends to maintain the order (any order)?

[jgrewe]

should we leave this issue open until we implement the util function for custom ordering?

[gicmo]

@jgrewe I'd say we open a new one for the util, and close this.

[achilleas-k]

Agreed