GDQuest / blender-power-sequencer

Add-on for video editing in Blender 3D: edit videos faster! Included in Blender 2.81+
https://gdquest.com/blender/power-sequencer/
GNU General Public License v3.0
708 stars 58 forks source link

Multiple Playback Speed settings and hotkeys are Gone? #472

Open EroAxe opened 1 year ago

EroAxe commented 1 year ago

I'm submitting a...

Bug report

What is the current behavior?

What is the expected behavior?

Tell us the steps to reproduce the bug, and if possible share a minimal demo of the problem.

Feature request

I'm making this to request/find some information about why the 1.3x and 1.6x playback speed options, as well as the hotkeys for changing the speed disappeared from the addon awhile ago. I used them quite heavily since 2x speed is generally waaay faster than I need or want, most of the time.

Describe the problem you're trying to solve.

The ability to playback footage at a higher or lower speed to streamline the editing process without needing to repeatedly move backwards on the timeline.

Tell us which solutions you've explored, the solution you would pick, and why you think it would be the best for everyone.

I've attempted to bind the existing options from the addon in Blender to get back the hotkeys, but unfortunately that only lets me bind to one specifically. Not just an "increase" or "decrease".

As for the other options I've checked other addons to see if it's a supported feature and it's not. There are some great options for those addons, but nothing for playback speed.

When it comes to a solution I would pick, the simplest would probably just be, what we had before. Where there were the hotkeys, you could bind them, and you had more fine control over playback speed. If possible I'd hope for more options that are a bit more granular, maybe going up by 100s, ex. 1.1, 1.2 but that's just hoping.

Other

Other information

The hotkeys and the extra options are even still listed on the documentation for context, so I'm a little confused as to where they went.

NathanLovato commented 1 year ago

The shortcuts are still working for me, Ctrl+1/2/3.

i invite you to ensure you have the version of power sequencer included in Blender active. Otherwise, to add shortcuts manually, create a new shortcut in SequencerCommon -> Sequencer -> Sequencer (global) with the command power_sequencer.playback_speed_set

image

EroAxe commented 1 year ago

Can confirm my Power Sequencer is enabled and they still don't work image They are also set just to clarify. I also double checked and made sure that the other addons I had for the VSE were disabled to make sure. image

Besides that though, apologies for not being specific enough, but those are not the hotkeys I was referring to, specifically I am talking about these hotkeys for specifically increasing or decreasing the playback speed incrementally and are still listed in the documentation: image But seem to have disappeared in the last few versions version, even in the keymap. Along with the other options I mentioned of 1.33x and 1.66x mentioned in the documentation there. As I said, I relied relatively heavily on them and they've just been, gone for a bit.

NathanLovato commented 1 year ago

Okay then it's just that it's not possible to make this work in recent blender versions, this feature relies on a hack whose support was removed. Now this code just makes playback much slower. So indeed the docs should be updated, it's just not possible to support right now, unfortunately. Only 2x, 3x, etc. can work (skipping 1, 2, 3, ... frames for each frame played on the timeline).

EroAxe commented 1 year ago

Welp, that's unfortunate. Is there any way to at least get the increase/decrease hotkeys back for the current 1x/2x/3x options?

NathanLovato commented 1 year ago

No, as basically you'll only toggle between 1x and 2x speed typically, the shortcuts for increasing vs decreasing speed are gone.