search

GPUOpen-LibrariesAndSDKs / RadeonRays_SDK

Radeon Rays is ray intersection acceleration library for hardware and software multiplatforms using CPU and GPU
MIT License
1.07k stars 192 forks source link

Optimize Raycasting when OpenCL 2.0 is present #197

Open devshgraphicsprogramming opened 6 years ago

devshgraphicsprogramming commented 6 years ago

Pipes and Device-side Enqueue could eliminate the need to save intersections to intermediate buffers and the whole global read-write loop for every batch of rays dependant on the previous intersections.

I dont know if implementing recursive ray-tracing is possible in the context of the above OpenCL 2.0 functionality, but I'd like to get the discussion started.

Are there any plans for a TraceRay DXR equivalent function?

manhnt9 commented 6 years ago

Seems like there is an on-going development of new version at https://github.com/yozhijk/radeonrays-next/commits/master

devshgraphicsprogramming commented 6 years ago

The last commit on any of the branches is in 2017?

manhnt9 commented 6 years ago

End of 2017 actually, that's newer than this repo anyways, recent commits here are mostly PR.

scschaefer commented 6 years ago

Last I heard from Dmitry they were working on the Vulkan backend at the moment. And concerning pull requests: IIRC in the past, significant new features and changes were often introduced via pull requests from a team members account. But I'm unsure what's up at the moment, as one of my pull requests is currently stuck with no replies. I'm guessing that AMD is probably focusing their effort on DXR at the moment after Nvidia's RTX release. But that's just a hunch, so until we get a response from one of the repo maintainers we can only wait I guess.

devshgraphicsprogramming commented 6 years ago

So will we get a VK_EXT_raytracing or VK_AMD_raytracing in Vulkan?

scschaefer commented 6 years ago

AFAIK they were completely reworking the current RadeonRays Vulkan backend (which is deprecated at this point). Thus nothing GPU driver related. I don't know if AMD is planning on releasing a counterpart to NVIDIA's VK_NVX_raytracing Vulkan extension. (I don't work for AMD so what I wrote earlier was just a guess)

ivalylo commented 6 years ago

VK_NVX_raytracing is required to wrap the proprietary RTX technology and Optix. I'm not sure what to think about RTX, but I would prefer general GPU improvements and avoiding the need of so specialized hardware and back box programming. If AMD can do this, i.e. use only general unified computing architecture, and still achieve competitive ray tracing, this will be a big win for them. These RTX cores are taking chip space, and when you don't use them, it's total waste. You also can have only limited amount of them, so how much to put on the chip? It become clear that 2070 can't really handle ray tracing... At least my guess is that AMD will go with unified architecture, and will release standard Vulkan library, avoiding the need for extension. At least this is what I'm hoping for, but we probably have another 6 months to wait until their new video cards are released and more things go public...

Degerz commented 4 years ago

OpenCL has been officially dropped in the newest release!