GTNewHorizons / GT-New-Horizons-Modpack

A big progressive questing modpack for Minecraft 1.7.10 balanced around the mod GregTech.
https://www.gtnewhorizons.com/
Other
1.03k stars 315 forks source link

Fuses and breakers to protect power lines. #17161

Open Diamantino-Op opened 3 months ago

Diamantino-Op commented 3 months ago

Your GTNH Discord Username

diamantinoop

Your Pack Version

Nigtly 614

Your Proposal

Add fuses and breakers to prevent accidental explosions from connecting a higher voltage output to a power line and overcurrent protection.

Your Goal

Players won't be punished from making the error of connecting a high voltage source to lower voltage wires / machines, and won't accidentally burn wires if requesting too much current.

Your Vision

Players won't lose half of their base when making this error.

Final Checklist

ExileWeirdo commented 3 months ago

Rebuilding half your base is fun tho! Idk i feel like explosions etc are a part of gtnh and has been since the start. Learning from mistakes and being super careful is why gtnh is what it is today. I think it wouldn't be a good idea to implement this because i like that gtnh is realistic with how things work to a certain point. If you send too much power into smt it should explode if u cant handle this.

Either way most players already have a fix to this and thats disabling explosions in Server Utilities or other mods you have so ig this would be cool but i dont think its really nessecary (i cant spell this word)

FourIsTheNumber commented 3 months ago

Rebuilding half your base is fun tho! Idk i feel like explosions etc are a part of gtnh and has been since the start. Learning from mistakes and being super careful is why gtnh is what it is today. I think it wouldn't be a good idea to implement this because i like that gtnh is realistic with how things work to a certain point. If you send too much power into smt it should explode if u cant handle this.

Either way most players already have a fix to this and thats disabling explosions in Server Utilities or other mods you have so ig this would be cool but i dont think its really nessecary (i cant spell this word)

It's not realistic at all, fwiw. What they're proposing is being able to optionally build safety measures, which imo is potentially interesting - if player can optionally choose to invest in and use safety tools.

Diamantino-Op commented 3 months ago

Yep, that's exactly what i was proposing, if a player likes the risk he can just not build safety measures, but if you don't want to lose machines because of an error, you can use those to protect them.

ExileWeirdo commented 3 months ago

thats true, ig if people dont wanna be "cheaty" by using server utilities its a cool concept. depends on how cool the fuses could be n stuff. How would it integrate with all different tectech stuff and so? would it just delete the explosion or? Would be cool if it was tiered, like t1 fuse would minimize 50% of the explosion, t2 70% etc

OmdaCZ commented 3 months ago

Don't diodes have this function already? They should blow up before any machines due to being before them and they limit amperage to not burn down cables.

Diamantino-Op commented 3 months ago

for fuses i was thinking of cables, like if the cable is transferring more than the max allowed, the fuse would burn before all the other cables.

Diamantino-Op commented 3 months ago

Don't diodes have this function already? They should blow up before any machines due to being before them and they limit amperage to not burn down cables.

well, that's true, but what if it is in the main powerline or a line without diodes?

Diamantino-Op commented 3 months ago

like a line with a flow of 16+ amps of power