GTNewHorizons / GT-New-Horizons-Modpack

New Modpack with Gregtech, Thaumcraft and Witchery
https://www.gtnewhorizons.com/
Other
992 stars 301 forks source link

Make some efforts to get away from cell chemistry #17641

Closed Wyrmlet closed 6 days ago

Wyrmlet commented 1 week ago

Your GTNH Discord Username

No response

Your Pack Version

2.6.1

Your Proposal

Replace cell + fluid recipes in chemical reactors, electrolyzers, etc. with fluid only recipes by adding extra input and output slots for fluids

Your Goal

Having to move cells around and empty or fill them unnecessarily inflates the amount of infrastructure needed in the early game, hindering automation of stuff like early petrochem

Your Vision

Fluids and chemistry can be handled easier by only using pipes instead of having to place canners and uncanners every other step, along with not needing to recycle and move empty cells back to their starting positions

Final Checklist

Wyrmlet commented 1 week ago

Mind you, I am unsure if this is even feasible to do, as it might require some rather extensive modifications to pretty much all existing recipes.

Reflex18 commented 1 week ago

It would be great and put gtnh further towards the standard of gtceu which has zero cell chemistry.

ogdae commented 1 week ago

While I think everyone can agree cell chemistry is a little tedious, I believe it plays a pretty important role in early game. While potentially frustrating for the new player, there's a lot of rewarding ways you can learn to automate cell chemistry and early petrochem that work quite flawlessly and efficiently. Additionally, it makes unlocking the LCR all the more rewarding imo.

You could probably argue that the electrolyzer mb feels a lot more restrictive, since you're stuck with cell outputs until you unlock it, but aside from that the system as a whole feels fine to me. Realistically, the LCR isn't that far away from LV anyway...

Side note as well, you don't need to use a ton of canners for setups, ULV tanks and conduits handle it more than fine.

My two cents

Wyrmlet commented 1 week ago

This might be just a skill issue on my end, but this still contributes quite significantly to the whiplash of coming to gtnh from modern versions. The cell juggling always felt entirely unnecessary to me.

Also, I've never thought of using ULV tanks for this! Did I skip a mention of this somewhere in the questbook?

ogdae commented 1 week ago

I mean, we all start somewhere :p so not I'm not just gonna call it a skill issue, however GTNH has a noticeable difficulty/learning curve associated to it, and yes, at lots of points you require decent infrastructure to support your base, especially in regards to petrochemical processing.

chochem commented 6 days ago

we have no intention of doing that. This is indeed a challenge to overcome.

A theme you will find often in GTNH is that you have to overcome all kinds of difficulties, and only ~2 tiers later or when you are required to do it a lot will you get an easier more streamlined hightech version (LCR in this case).

Wyrmlet commented 6 days ago

Yeah, that's the theme with gregtech in general, I guess that for some reason cell chemistry felt like unintentional old minecraft jank. But yeah, fair enough!