Dirt cheap villagers

[bashduude]

Which modpack version are you using?

2030 #

If in multiplayer; On which server does this happen?

#

What did you try to do, and what did you expect to happen?

#

What happend instead? (Attach screenshots if needed)

#

What do you suggest instead/what changes do you propose?

Take a look at villagers trade tables. Some of them need to be tweaked, For example 24 wood => apiary

[draknyte1]

Unless you can spawn villagers, it's not abusable. At that point, it doesn't matter~

They'll only sell a few then you need to find another one.. then give him the correct wood.. rinse and repeat, rather slow based on villager rng.

[Dream-Master]

yea but use them a special forestry wood are better than vanilla wood planks. Will see what I can do.

[draknyte1]

Pretty sure they ask for any plank type that exists.. vanilla planks count but more often then not I'm pretty sure the want forestry logs. Maybe I'm wrong but I don't see why they wouldn't use forestry planks when it's added by forestry.

[richardhendricks]

That's been a pretty standard trade since forever. I'd be real hesitant to change it much. They can accept any wood in my experience.

If any, I would change the trade to be more wood and also some honeycombs. Or maybe honey drops if you want players to actually work for it.

[Dream-Master]

idk if I can change it

[draknyte1]

You can't unless you fork forestry. (Or can you Minetweak villager recipes?) I'm under the assumption we will anyway to fix butterflies, so just do it then.

[Dream-Master]

I fork bop now for sapling recipes but we can fork forestry aswell

[0lafe]

Unless you can spawn villagers, it's not abusable. At that point, it doesn't matter~

You can spawn them in more than one way

[draknyte1]

Spawn eggs? They cost. Villager farm? You're still relying on slow RNG.

Only a spawner is practical to abuse this on any level called abuse.

[0lafe]

There are villager spawners you can craft around MV

[draknyte1]

Regardless, let's say there's 10 villager types, then for each type there's 10-15 trades. That's like a 1% chance to get the correct villager, which then only sells you 3-4 apiaries. After that, you need another one.

[0lafe]

By MV they aren't too hard to craft anyway so it's not a big deal

[draknyte1]

Basically my point is that the effort required to spawn villagers to exploit this at any decent speed is still slower than just making them. :)

[bartimaeusnek]

imo this should stay in as a "feature"

[richardhendricks]

I'd like to see more useful trades across the board for villagers. But would encourage hoarding and farming them. Which would mean more zombie sieges. So maybe a good thing! 👍

[0lafe]

I too am in favor of some new trades if that's possible, That could be cool

[Dream-Master]

look for a mod can control it @0lafe

[draknyte1]

We can do it via DreamCore if you want?

Just make up a list of trades and I'll PR them in a week :)

[0lafe]

https://minecraft.curseforge.com/projects/custom-trades-mod/files if not this might work

[draknyte1]

Why add more mods when we could do it ourselves? Allows more flexibility and new villager options too.

[bartimaeusnek]

yeah i agree with @draknyte1 here, also the mod @0lafe posted has this license: "This work is dedicated to the public domain." Which means we can do whatever we want to it. IMO we should merge this: https://github.com/GTNewHorizons/NewHorizons/issues/2874 and the mod from above or @draknyte1 into the coremod as fixes.

[Dream-Master]

sure this works too. but we need to be able to add and remove trades

[github-actions[bot]]

This issue is stale because it has been open 90 days with no activity. Remove stale label or comment or this will be closed in 3 days