onTagEdited not firing?

[m-ghaoui]

I'm submitting a ... (check one with "x")

[x] bug report => search github for a similar issue or PR before submitting
[ ] support request/question

Notice: feature requests will be ignored, submit a PR if you'd like

Current behavior I have a tag-input with (onTagEdited)="onTagEdited($event)". I double click on a tag, make changes, and the tag automatically reverts back to the old value.

Expected behavior I expect the onTagEdited event to fire and the tag to be renamed.

Minimal reproduction of the problem with instructions (if applicable)

What do you use to build your app?. Please specify the version "@angular/cli": "^1.7.3"

Angular version:

    "@angular/animations": "^5.2.9",
    "@angular/cdk": "^5.2.4",
    "@angular/common": "^5.2.9",
    "@angular/compiler": "^5.2.9",
    "@angular/core": "^5.2.9",
    "@angular/forms": "^5.2.9",
    "@angular/http": "^5.2.9",
    "@angular/material": "^5.2.4",
    "@angular/material-moment-adapter": "^5.2.4",
    "@angular/platform-browser": "^5.2.9",
    "@angular/platform-browser-dynamic": "^5.2.9",
    "@angular/router": "^5.2.9",

ngx-chips version: "ngx-chips": "^1.7.7"

Browser: [all | Chrome XX | Firefox XX | IE XX | Safari XX | Mobile Chrome XX | Android X.X Web Browser | iOS XX Safari | iOS XX UIWebView | iOS XX WKWebView ] Chrome 67.0.3389.0 (Official build) canary (64-bits) Firefox Quantum 59.0.2 (64-bits)

[m-ghaoui]

I reverted back to the version I used when I first wrote the code:

"ngx-chips": "1.6.2",

and the event does fire.

[Gbuomprisco]

Hi are you using a validator? Please post some code.

[m-ghaoui]

Sure,

Here is the relevant tag:

</form> <!-- Note, the form is above the tag-input -->

<tag-input [(ngModel)]="trainingTagsInTrainingList" [identifyBy]="'Guid'" [displayBy]="'Name'" [addOnBlur]="true" [clearOnBlur]="true"
    (onAdd)="onTagAdd($event)" (onRemove)="onTagRemove($event)" (onTagEdited)="onTagEdited($event)" placeholder="+Tag"
    secondaryPlaceholder="Voeg tag toe" [editable]="true">
    <tag-input-dropdown #tagInputDropDownTags [autocompleteItems]="trainingTagsList" [identifyBy]="'Guid'" [displayBy]="'Name'"
    [showDropdownIfEmpty]="true" [focusFirstElement]="false">
    </tag-input-dropdown>
</tag-input>

I do have a FormBuilder and a bunch of form fields with the formControlName tag.

But the <tag-input> is below the <form> element and uses [(ngModel)]. As far as I know, I am not using a validator in the <tag-input>.

The trainingsInTagList and trainingTagsList looks like this:

trainingTagsInTrainingList: GuidName[]; // The model
trainingTagsList: GuidName[]; // The values for the tag-input-dropdown

Event handlers:

public onTagAdd(item: GuidName) {
    this.addTag(item); 
}

public onTagRemove(item: GuidName) {
    this.removeTag(item);
}

public async onTagEdited(item: GuidName) {
    await this.renameTag(item); // <-- This line does not get hit in version 1.7.7, but it does get hit in version 1.6.2
}

GuidName class:

export class GuidName {
  Guid: string | undefined;
  Name: string | undefined;
  Selected: boolean;

  constructor(guid: string | undefined, name: string | undefined) {
    this.Guid = guid;
    this.Name = name;
    this.Selected = false;
  }
}

The onTagEdited() handler does not even get hit on version 1.7.7, but it does with 1.6.2.

Could it be because onTagEdited is async? It works in 1.6.2.

[Gbuomprisco]

I don't think being async is the problem (I tried this too). I introduced a feature to validate the tag when it gets edited: the behavior you see is exactly what happens when the validator detects an invalid tag, so for some reason the editing is not passing the validation.

I don't see problems in your code though and can't reproduce using a similar configuration to yours. Just to make sure, can you try v1.7.8? Also, it may seem silly, but the tag won't be added if the same one is already in the list, so make sure you're adding a new item

[m-ghaoui]

It does no seem to work. The line does not get hit.

"ngx-chips": "1.7.8",

Incidentally, this version does not work either,

"ngx-chips": "1.8.0",

[m-ghaoui]

Also, it may seem silly, but the tag won't be added if the same one is already in the list, so make sure you're adding a new item

I'm renaming it to a unique item. For example:

one two three ---> one, twooooooooooooooo, three. It jumps back to one, two, three

[m-ghaoui]

Here is the line being hit with version 1.6.2

[Gbuomprisco]

Can you upload an online reproduction of the issue? I haven't been able to reproduce

[m-ghaoui]

Ok. I'll try. You need to give me some time.

[Gbuomprisco]

Use stackblitz as in my demo, it's really quick :) you can fork the demo and start from there

[renanmoraes]

I think I'm having the same problem, I try to return the value to be put in the field but it does not work.

   <tag-input [onAdding]="transform"
            [validators]="validatorsTag"
            [errorMessages]="errorMessages"
            (onTagEdited)="onTagEdited($event)"
             (onSelect)="onSelect($event)"
             (onBlur)="onBlur()"
              [editable]="true"
              [identifyBy]="'hour'"
              [displayBy]="'hour'"
              formControlName="timesheet"
              theme="dark"
              placeholder="+ Horários"
              [secondaryPlaceholder]="'Adicione horários'"></tag-input>

onTagEdited(value): Observable<any> {
    const index = value.hour.indexOf(':');
    const reg = new RegExp('^[0-9]*$');
    console.log('tag', value)
    if (value.hour.length < 4 || !reg.test(value.hour)) {
      console.log(this.hourSelectedBeforeAlter)
      return Observable.of(this.hourSelectedBeforeAlter);
    }

    if (index === -1) {
      const val = value.hour.split('');
      const formated = {
        _id: (value._id) ? value._id : null,
        hour: val[0] + val[1] + ':' + val[2] + val[3]
      };
      return Observable.of(formated);
    } else {
      const val = value.split('');
      const formated = {
        _id: (value._id) ? value._id : null,
        hour: val[0] + val[1] + ':' + val[3] + val[4]
      };
      return Observable.of(formated);
    }
  }

You can observe that I select the item and change it, however according to my code it needs to return to the value that was previously in the code, I put consoles logs to make sure it would arrive correctly and it is, however at the moment of returning it does not work.

The behavior that I expect pe when put for example 22dd: 00 it returns to 22:00 because it is not a valid value.

[ThalesMatoso]

Some news on this case, but still with problems on this subject. Please ask for an opinion, I know it is not for you but it would be very interesting to do.

[Gbuomprisco]

@renanmoraes you're not going to be able to edit the tag using that hook. You will need onAdding

[jsalvata]

I've been suffering a bug which I believe is this same one: when using identifiers (different from the display strings) and a tag is edited, it is always found to be a duplicate of itself and the edit is undone.

One solution would be to skip duplicate checking when editing tags, since allowDupes is defined to "tags with the same value" -- so tags with the same display string should always be allowed.

The right solution for me, however, is to just check for duplicate display strings -- since that's what I want to avoid duplicating.

[jsalvata]

Just in case it helps anyone, I've worked around the issue by adding this to my component (apologies for the crudeness):

 ...
  @ViewChild('tagInput') private tagInput: TagInputComponent;
 ...
  ngOnInit() {
    (this.tagInput as any).findDupe= (function (this: any, tag: any): CustomerEmail | undefined {
      return this.items.find((item: any) => item.display === tag.display && item.value !== tag.value);
    }).bind(this.tagInput);
 ...

[gelevanog]

Any updates?

[michgerts]

Any updates?

[designcouch]

Would also love any updates on this. I can get the event to fire partially, but it seems to fire before the edit is complete, so the visible text in the tag changes, but the updated value returned does not.

Example: Tag "Ewok" is edited. The text now reads "Blue Ewok." When I include onTagEdited, the text changes to "Blue Ewok" but all other data in the html, and the value returned are still "Ewok"

[andn99]

any updates for this issue. I'm still having it on ngx-chips: 2.0.2

[michgerts]

I would love to hear about updates or workarounds here.

[anmolio]

If you are using different values for [identifyBy] & [displayBy] ; once you edited the tag and enter the changes will be undone; using the same display and identify values will make it work!

[truongtokiet]

If you are using different values for [identifyBy] & [displayBy] ; once you edited the tag and enter the changes will be undone; using the same display and identify values will make it work!

I tried and it works. Many thank.