GeneralMagicio / pw-frontend

Pairwise frontend implementation
https://pairwise-frontend.vercel.app
GNU General Public License v3.0
15 stars 0 forks source link

Reduce number of clicks it takes to edit a category #205

Closed GriffGreen closed 11 months ago

GriffGreen commented 11 months ago

Kind of related to #202, there is a design choice to make only one place where you can edit manually... I disagree with this choice after doing user testing... people can't figure out how to edit.

When clicking this edit button on this page:

Screenshot 2023-11-12 at 8 12 36 PM

you go to this state:

Screenshot 2023-11-12 at 8 15 22 PM

But the state we want them to be in is:

Screenshot 2023-11-12 at 8 18 09 PM

Honestly I don't see a great argument for EVER showing that first state, we just need to some how prompt them to save whenever they make edits....

Also... I think these options to edit or continue

Screenshot 2023-11-12 at 4 38 45 PM

should be in this 3 dot drop down too:

Screenshot 2023-11-12 at 5 35 01 PM

AND!

I think this needs more of a Warning: Like is should use big caution signs and stuff like that, cause no one reads text

Screenshot 2023-11-12 at 6 17 20 PM
kristoferlund commented 11 months ago

@GriffGreen

Straight forward solution to this one would be to show a warning directly when clicking on the Edit button in the "Well done" dialog.

image

When user clicks Edit manually they are taken to the ranking edit page with category ready to be edited.

kristoferlund commented 11 months ago

Summary:

krisjpi commented 11 months ago

Came to check here instead of starting a new issue - I think the fix suggested above will work well. It seems like the change in flow of a category to "Finished" makes this a little weird.

edit: found the "manually edit" button on the Rankings page, feels a little bit hidden though. Personally prefer giving the warning when clicking edit in the Well Done area.

Giving a warning and an option to manually finish ranking to be able to edit should deal with this.

Attached a short clip finishing ranking (but not creating the list) and wanting to edit.

https://github.com/GeneralMagicio/pw-frontend/assets/41163644/00a345b2-28e7-41f0-8622-7a08cd7b74ce