GenomicsStandardsConsortium / mixs

Minimum Information about any (X) Sequence” (MIxS) specification
https://w3id.org/mixs
Creative Commons Zero v1.0 Universal
36 stars 21 forks source link

Ag package term suggestion strain NEW #227

Closed only1chunts closed 2 years ago

only1chunts commented 3 years ago

New term details

Term name - organism strain
Term ID - 
Structured comment name - strain
Definition - A strain is a genetic variant or kind of microorganism
Expected value - microbial or eukaryotic strain name
Value syntax - 
Example - 
Package(s) - Agriculture

Additional context Suggested as part of the Ag package

Points for discussion

why not use the existing term "host_subspecf_genlin" MIXS:0001318

pyilmaz commented 3 years ago

Does this term refer to the organism being sequenced? Also suggest change expected value to bacteria, archaea or eukaryotic strain name, since eukaryotic microorganisms is also a thing

ramonawalls commented 3 years ago
  1. Subspecific genetic lineage is for any lineage that is below what is listed in NCBI taxonomy (i.e. below subspecies). Is "strain" referring to something equivalent to a subspecies or is it referring to sub-subspecies? Either way, the package should reuse one of the existing terms.

  2. Is this specific to the organism being sequenced, or could it refer to a microorganism whose microbiome is being sequenced?

jpdundorearias commented 3 years ago

This term was incorporated from the Farm Food package. In this context, strain refers to a variant of a given organism which have been further characterized based on serotyping or functional traits (despite taxonomic identity/match). We are OK reusing any existing term and incorporating changes already addressed in the farm food package

ramonawalls commented 2 years ago

On call we agreed that the ag package should reuse subspecific genetic lineage for times when the "strain" is below subspecies. If it is at the subspecies level, then NCBI taxon ID should be used.

only1chunts commented 2 years ago

The Ag package already includes the term "host_subspecf_genlin" MIXS:0001318 (row 97). I have deleted the row for "strain" from the Ag package.