GetDKAN / dkan

DKAN Open Data Portal

https://dkan.readthedocs.io/en/latest/index.html

GNU General Public License v2.0

361 stars 171 forks source link

DKAN supporting DCAT-AP.de #2595

Open eGovCologne opened 5 years ago

eGovCologne commented 5 years ago

As a german national data-catalogue harverster (govdata.de) , I want to access a municipal dcat-ap catalogue, so that I can pull data from cities that use dkan.

All german municipal data providers are obliged to provide a data catalog following a new european/national standard called DCAT-AP.de. When comparing the example file (see this gist) with the dkan dcat-catalogue there seem to be some differences. Could you please take a look at the specification and provide some guidance on how to adapt/expand/configure the DKAN api to provide a national endpoint following the standard? Thanks!

akuckartz commented 5 years ago

A few hints:

RDF/XML is the RDF serialisation which is probably the most ugly and least liked by the Semantic Web community. There are others like Turtle or JSON-LD which generally should be prefered. RDF serialisations can be converted into other RDF serialisations. You can contact me offline.
DCAN supports the European DCAT application profile DCAT-AP but I do not know how well. See #868. DCAT-AP.de has a few additional restrictions.

dafeder commented 5 years ago

Thanks @akuckartz! We've found it challenging to understand exactly how to comply with the DCAT-AP standard, as there are many different implementations, country-specific standards, conflicting examples and different validators. The DCAT-AP endpoint that ships with DKAN was passing a generic European Commission-supported validator when it was released. It looks like this validator now lives at http://dcat-ap.semic.eu/dcat-ap_validator.html but is broken :\

Most people were requesting XML/RDF so that's what we focused on providing. If you have a current version of DKAN you should have a /catalog.xml that conforms to DCAT-AP.

akuckartz commented 4 years ago

The source code of that validator is available here: https://github.com/SEMICeu/dcat-ap_validator but it does not seem to be maintained. @dafeder These are newer: https://github.com/SEMICeu/dcat-ap_shacl https://github.com/tenforce/vodap-dcatap-validation

erogray commented 4 years ago

DKAN 2 release will be coming up before long, and will probably be where we'll want to address this sort of enhancement.

akuckartz commented 3 years ago

868 unfortunately was closed without resolving it.

susisiman commented 3 years ago

We have reopened #868 and will work on the user story for it.