search

GeyserMC / Geyser

A bridge/proxy allowing you to connect to Minecraft: Java Edition servers with Minecraft: Bedrock Edition.
https://geysermc.org
MIT License
4.73k stars 680 forks source link

Custom smithing ingredients don't work #4706

Closed animation-is-always-taken closed 5 months ago

animation-is-always-taken commented 5 months ago

Describe the bug

I added this to my server and it works perfectly fine on java, but bedrock players aren't able to place the custom ingredient on the smithing table

To Reproduce

Add the datapack to a server running on 1.20.5/1.20.6 get a copper block, chainmail armor piece and any trim material try using them on the smithing table see how it doesn't work

Expected behaviour

Custom trim to be peaceable (making the recipe craftable)

Screenshots / Videos

No response

Server Version and Plugins

Fabric 1.20.6 loader version: 0.15.11

used mods: adventure-platform-fabric (adventure-platform-fabric) v5.13.0 AntiXray (antixray) v1.3.3 Architectury (architectury) v12.1.2 cloth-basic-math (cloth-basic-math) v0.6.1 Cloth Config v14 (cloth-config) v14.0.126 Cloud (cloud) v2.0.0-beta.6 Config to Brigadier (config2brigadier) v1.2.3 EntityCulling (entityculling) v1.6.5 Fabric API (fabric-api) v0.99.0+1.20.6 (35 child mods) Fabric Language Kotlin (fabric-language-kotlin) v1.11.0+kotlin.2.0.0 fabric-permissions-api (fabric-permissions-api-v0) v0.3.1 Fabric TPS (fabric_tps) v1.20.4-1.4.2 Fabric Loader (fabricloader) v0.15.11 Fabric Tailor (fabrictailor) v2.4.1 FerriteCore (ferritecore) v6.1.1 Floodgate-Fabric (floodgate) v2.2.3-SNAPSHOT Geyser-Fabric (geyser-fabric) v2.3.1-SNAPSHOT Krypton (krypton) v0.2.7 Lithium (lithium) v0.12.3 Loom Generated (loom-generated) (65 child mods) Minecraft (minecraft) v1.20.6 MixinExtras (mixinextras) v0.3.5 ModernFix (modernfix) v5.17.3+mc1.20.6 Mods Command (mods-command) v1.1.6 No Chat Reports (nochatreports) v1.20.6-v2.7.0 Not Enough Crashes (notenoughcrashes) v4.4.7+1.20.6 Placeholder API (placeholder-api) v2.4.0-pre.1+1.20.5 Player Data API (player-data-api) v0.4.0+1.20.3 Predicate API (predicate-api) v0.4.0+1.20.5 Styled Player List (styledplayerlist) v3.4.0+1.20.5 ThreadTweak (threadtweak) v1.20.6-0.1.3 Very Many Players (vmp) v0.2.0+beta.7.155+1.20.6 WorldEdit (worldedit) v7.3.2+6779-3aca580

Geyser Dump

https://dump.geysermc.org/GZEtZMYxkiY6hlAAoCY4jKmYo6UrEyCO

Geyser Version

2.3.1-SNAPSHOT (git-master-66f30a2)

Minecraft: Bedrock Edition Device/Version

1.20.81 windows 10/1.20.81 PE

Additional Context

This doesn't work with geyser spigot either, i'm pretty sure no custom smithing recipes work on any capacity (i could be wrong)

onebeastchris commented 5 months ago

This is unfortunately a can't fix as Bedrock doesn't allow adding custom trim patterns/materials as of now.

Bedrock does support adding vanilla trim patterns to custom armor, but that's unfortunately it.

animation-is-always-taken commented 5 months ago

are there any work arounds?

onebeastchris commented 5 months ago

unfortunately, there aren't

onebeastchris commented 5 months ago

Closing this issue in favor of it being documented on our current limitations page: https://wiki.geysermc.org/geyser/current-limitations/

MrBsng commented 5 months ago

are there any work arounds?

yes, you can develop a plugin that makes bedrock players use a custom gui and container slots for the smithing table.