Giveth / Communication

Where we decentralize Giveth Communication
GNU General Public License v3.0
4 stars 0 forks source link

Funding post - anonymous donor #124

Closed krrisis closed 5 years ago

krrisis commented 5 years ago

Content:

Tone of voice:

Notes

krrisis commented 5 years ago

@GriffGreen add any comments here :)

@elietzioni this should definitely also go in here - a reference on how we decided in our decentralized way what to do with the funds! https://www.loomio.org/d/Sbn1FeT7/285-eth-what-am-i-gonna-do-

GriffGreen commented 5 years ago

Yep! We did the loomio and then we talked about it in the Community meeting but sadly it had a recording issue :-P so it didnt really record anything useful :-(

the final verdict was what was said in the loomio, but its interesting... at least i think its interesting.... that we had to do a whole process around "what do we do with this donation" because it was sent to the multisig... but if the donor would have sent it into the dapp there wouldn't have been any governance needed because that is handled by the dapp :-D If they would have just donated to a specific campaign, or to a DAC, then it would have been clear who decides what to do with those funds...

In our case, we decided to send it 50/50 to the Giveth DApp to cover some larger expenses and the rest to the Unicorn DAC to support our decentralized

link to the Unicorn DAC and talk about how it works a little bit.. basically, Giveth Unicorns that have gone thru the onboarding process get to use their share of the donation to steer the direction of the Giveth Galaxy

Relevant links https://wiki.giveth.io/dac/Unicorn-DAC/ https://wiki.giveth.io/dac/Unicorn-DAC-getfunded/ https://wiki.giveth.io/policy/Unicorn-onboarding/

geleeroyale commented 5 years ago

I think this is a good opportunity to inform people about these choices! We should change our official policy in a way that everything donated to Giveth DAC will be routed according to our community's decision, but if donors want to support something specific within Giveth, it will be that campaigns/community's decision - We should communicate this loudly and clearly, as I think we are the only body that accepts donations in this way currently!

So to summarize - we should be more clear on giveth-io/donate about possibilities and who decides on routing donations, as well as take the change of this donation to explain with lots of pictures how donations in Giveth (with or without DApp) work!

krrisis commented 5 years ago

Good feedback Kay! Have added a paragraph specifically on this.

@GriffGreen and @mroberts10 Eli has already spent quite some time on this, but this is ofc an important one, as it is a first ask for funding: could you briefly check if the current version is clear to you and is good to go? thx! https://docs.google.com/document/d/1lhE8D58GiowlJwQUNFOuOpgengxDuYOtSN-IQmQ88rw/edit?usp=sharing