Grabli66 / simple-translate

A simple translation app for Ubuntu and other Linux distributions
http://orschiro.github.io/simple-translate
GNU General Public License v3.0
5 stars 2 forks source link

Compliance #7

Open JerryCasiano opened 8 years ago

JerryCasiano commented 8 years ago

I hate to point this out, but unfortunately it's something that will need to be addressed.

The reason I hate to point it out is two fold.

For one, the app is young.

For two, it's pretty onerous, at least in my opinion. Yandex requires in license that they be credited in several areas of the application, including the main window. They also require that the font be the same size and color as the rest of the content.

Now, personally I think it's probably not worth worrying about at this point and believe it's better for both parties to wait till the app matures a little.

But definitely need to start thinking about this since it could cause issues for the project. Need to find a tasteful way of complying. Maybe even request that they relax the requirement a bit. Not sure how receptive to that such a large company would be but there's no harm in asking, if for example a lighter font color would be acceptable in the main interface.

Anyway, thoughts?

Grabli66 commented 8 years ago

I understand your concern. I thought about this problem year ago. But i don't have any solution of that. I think there are no good free translating service. Sometimes i thought about my own translating service, but it's too difficult, and need a lot of work and money. If your have any thoughts how to solve this problem, please tell us.

orschiro commented 8 years ago

Dear @JerryCasiano,

Need to find a tasteful way of complying. Maybe even request that they relax the requirement a bit. Not sure how receptive to that such a large company would be but there's no harm in asking, if for example a lighter font color would be acceptable in the main interface.

Thanks for raising this concern!

I would propose to continue developing and maturing the app and openly approach Yandex in the near future to be transparent about the issues we see and the hope for finding ways to find a solution for mutual benefits.

Warmly,

~Robert

JerryCasiano commented 8 years ago

Agreed, I think it's important for both parties that it be a polished experience.

I think I'll start by adding an about dialog crediting them. It's a start.

orschiro commented 8 years ago

I think I'll start by adding an about dialog crediting them. It's a start.

Great! Do you want some input from @Grabli66 or me?

~Robert

JerryCasiano commented 8 years ago

Sure.

It'll be just the standard GTK+ about dialog. However, it would be good to know anyone who should be credited such as authors, translators, artists, etc.

orschiro commented 8 years ago

For now I can just think of you and @Grabli66 for the programming.

Anyone else @Grabli66 you can think of?