GrapheneOS / os-issue-tracker

Issue tracker for GrapheneOS Android Open Source Project hardening work. Standalone projects like Auditor, AttestationServer and hardened_malloc have their own dedicated trackers.
https://grapheneos.org/
354 stars 20 forks source link

Lock Screen Half Swipes #2543

Open seniorm0ment opened 1 year ago

seniorm0ment commented 1 year ago

This is actually an issue I've had for months now, so not specific to Android 14. The issue is, here and there, the lockscreen doesn't seem to want to fully accept my press/swipe to open into the numpad for the pin.

So if you click the power button to turn on the lock sceen, you see the locm icon. You can swipe on this screen, or hold your finger on the lock. Both of these should open the numpad so you can type in the pin.

The issue is with the first part, the animation to see the numpad. It does not always open when you press or swipe. It goes a little then resets. It gets finicky, and the animation starts and then it stops. Acting as if you took your finger off the screen, or swiped not enough.

My finger was more than well on there, and it takes me a few tries before it actually works. It acts as if my fingers are slightly wet, is another way to describe it. They are completely dry, no grease, sweat, nothing. No water on the screen, clean screen. It should have zero issues.

I have even tried enabling increased screen sensitivity in developer options to see if it was a sensitivity issue, and it did not resolve it.

This is not every time, but it happens often enough.

Pixel 6 Pro, Version: 2023101100

brxken128 commented 1 year ago

Do you have a screen protector on? Film/glass or anything at all? I don't really think this is a gOS issue, more of an Android design choice that was poorly thought out because it's happened to me on both stock and gOS on my Pixel 6, and stock on my Pixel 8 Pro a couple of times. It also happens on a stock Pixel 7 (not mine, but the issue isn't isolated to gOS).

It could also be a hardware issue as what you describe is a fair bit more severe than what I've ever experienced, even with a Spigen tempered glass screen protector and no increased sensitivity.

seniorm0ment commented 1 year ago

I do not have any screen protector on. Interesting, it could be the screen, or stock android. I have no way of testing it with stock android to confirm but you seem confident about that. Hmm

thestinger commented 1 year ago

Try turning off developer options again as a starting point. Try using standard display size if you have that changed. If there's any accessibility service, disable that temporarily.

seniorm0ment commented 1 year ago

Yeah I disabled it seeing it didn't resolve it. I was on standard display size for a while and still encountered that at the time. And not using any accessibility services

irelativism commented 1 year ago

Duplicated with #2553, sorry only found this issue later. Cheers Irelativism

seniorm0ment commented 1 year ago

I don't think that issue is related? Maybe? I don't notice any issues with that power popup menu

irelativism commented 1 year ago

@seniorm0ment the issue is not the power popup menu, but the fact that you can use both interfaces can indicate there is some bug that allows grapheneOS to go back to default android one UI. And this seems to cause unresponsive touchscreen, something alike half swipes or like touchscreen cannot identify when you remove finger.

seniorm0ment commented 1 year ago

I have not experienced any other UI besides graphene on the lock screen, however that doesn't mean the bug isn't there which could cause this issue maybe.

irelativism commented 1 year ago

OK if you have a few minutes to test I would try to long press power button to reach menu and do it upwards of 10 times and see if you reproduce

seniorm0ment commented 1 year ago

I was unable to replicate your issue, unless I am misunderstanding the issue or process to reproduce it. I run into the half swipe issue still, but see no other UI pop up, or alternative UI to the power menu

nick16 commented 8 months ago

I have been encountering this issue for almost a year now. I reproduce it almost daily.

Im happy to produce logs or a video to help this issue get fixed, because it is really annoying.

I don't use a screen protector and am running the latest Graphene version on my Pixel 6a.

seniorm0ment commented 8 months ago

I notice it here and there on my Pixel 8 Pro, however less than on my 6 Pro

brxken128 commented 8 months ago

I started noticing this on my Pixel 6 not too long after my initial response, and have been somewhat frequently (every couple of days) on my Pixel 8 Pro. Turning the screen off/on fixes the issue. My brother (on a Pixel 6 Pro) has also reported the issue.

I do use a Spigen AlignMaster (or whatever they're called) screen protector. However, given the amount of people that don't use one, I doubt that it's related at all.

I don't have developer options on, I don't have improved touch sensibility on, my screen is perfectly fine (across both phones), and I use no accessibility stuff. I do use the fingerprint sensor to unlock my profile. It definitely seems like a software thing.

I've also noticed it with the notification bar, where it just refuses to slide down fully no matter: how many times I try to drag it down, how far I drag it down, how long I try to drag it down for. It's as though the animation succeeds but doesn't trigger the next step (displaying the unlock screen or the quick settings menu). Again, turning the display off and then on again resolves the problem.

thestinger commented 8 months ago

There's a high chance that it's tied to a screen protector or a case touching the screen.

seniorm0ment commented 8 months ago

I have not had a screen protector on either of my devices. On the 6 Pro maybe the case potentially because the rounded edges, however on the 8 Pro there is a visible black space between the screen and the case so it is not touching

thestinger commented 8 months ago

Try without the case for a bit anyway.

thestinger commented 8 months ago

Also, clean the screen with some soapy water on a cloth.

brxken128 commented 7 months ago

I removed the case and screen protector a few days ago, and I keep my screen clean with distilled water and a microfiber cloth - it just happened again on my P8 Pro.

nick16 commented 7 months ago

I noticed it occurs when I swipe up starting from right beneath the lock icon. When I swipe up from anywhere else on the screen but near the lock icon, it would not bug out.

brxken128 commented 7 months ago

I've used the phone bare (no case, screen protector, etc) for just under 2 weeks now, and still experience this issue. I keep the screen clean with distilled water and a microfiber cloth pretty often and I'm certain it's not hardware related.