search

GregTechCE / GregTech

GregTech rewrite for modern versions of Minecraft
GNU Lesser General Public License v3.0
271 stars 150 forks source link

[BUG] High pressure steam machines have no speed benefits #1324

Open Akiraca opened 3 years ago

Akiraca commented 3 years ago

Describe the bug Re-raise of the unsolved issue #332. I tested with macerators and the OP tested with furnances.

Versions Forge: 14.23.5.2854 GTCE: 1.10.5.582 Addons: Gregicality

Setup Playing Solo

Steps To Reproduce 1) Put down a steam macerator and a high pressure steam macerator. 2) Supply them with steam. 3) Put in ores for pulverization. 4) No speed difference observed.

Expected behavior High pressure steam machines being faster than regular ones.

galyfray commented 3 years ago

This is not a bug hight pressure machines are overclocked low pressure ones. This means that when you use recipes that are close to the lv voltage you won't see any clear difference try with a forge hammer with a 8Eu/t recipe and you should see a speed increase . However I agree whith the fact that hight pressure machines should allways beeing faster than low pressure ones.

LAGIdiot commented 3 years ago

Thank you for bring in it up. I can confirm that high pressure steam machines are quite under buffed but I don't consider it bug. As already mentioned they can overclock recipe (but I am not sure how many of them will trigger on this). Of course we could look in buffing them in some meaningful way.

galyfray commented 3 years ago

maybe buffing the overcloking behavior of the steam machines could help ? If I remember well multiplying the EU/t per 4 only double the speed of the recipes maybe we can switch to a 4 to 3 ratio instead of the actual 4 to 2 ? (I fear that 4 to 4 will make high pressure machines faster than LV machines).

LAGIdiot commented 3 years ago

No, touching overclocking is suicide as it is fragile, unstable and intertwined in everything recipe related.

leagris commented 3 years ago

Also High-pressure steam machines are able to process MV+ recipes I could process darkwood, ghostwood in the HP extractor but the Recipe is 120 EU/t

galyfray commented 3 years ago

Also High-pressure steam machines are able to process MV+ recipes I could process darkwood, ghostwood in the HP extractor but the Recipe is 120 EU/t

mm strange steam machines are noted as Lv machines in terms of tier. This kind of things should not append.

No, touching overclocking is suicide as it is fragile, unstable and intertwined in everything recipe related.

Really ? I mean overloading the calculate overclock doesn't seems to be this dangerous.

Akiraca commented 3 years ago

This means that when you use recipes that are close to the lv voltage you won't see any clear difference try with a forge hammer with a 8Eu/t recipe and you should see a speed increase .

Most ore pulverization recipes have 12Eu/t. Should they be overclocked or not?

galyfray commented 3 years ago

In theory they should get overclocked in practice due to the strange implementation of the overcloking it does not. I don't know what implementation choice lead to this but I feal like this way isn't the right way to overclok as it is hard top understand and in practice complicated to predict.