search

GridMod / RTS-GMLC

Reliability Test System - Grid Modernization Lab Consortium
154 stars 82 forks source link

the "start heat warm" of 121_Nuclear_1 #119

Closed nnhjy closed 4 years ago

nnhjy commented 4 years ago

I found the value 0. It seems weird as being between "start heat cold" and "start heat hot".\ https://eu-prod.asyncgw.teams.microsoft.com/v1/objects/0-weu-d6-ab88f564a952de7e847bf165d8cac627/views/imgo

claytonpbarrows commented 4 years ago

@nnhjy, the startup data for the nuclear unit is not really valid. The startup times from cold and hot are all 9999 (meaning invalid data note that I hate this convention). Also, the startup heat values should be interpreted as "heat required to start from x state", where x is cold, and hot.

As @danielolsen mentioned in an email, which was not properly addressed in #93, the warm start time data is mis labeled here. According to table 10 in the RTS-96 dataset, warm start times refer to the time it takes to transition from hot to cold after a shutdown. So, looking through my records, I believe that the creation of the "start heat warm" column was erroneous and it should be removed. In addition, the label applied to the "start time warm" column should be changed to "The transition time between hot and cold statuses after a shutdown".

nnhjy commented 4 years ago

It's been well addressed. Thank you @claytonpbarrows

nnhjy commented 4 years ago

Perhaps we should wait @danielolsen to reply.

danielolsen commented 4 years ago

@claytonpbarrows's recollection of our conversation (from two years ago!) tracks with mine, and I support the changes that he proposes.

claytonpbarrows commented 4 years ago

@danielolsen I had help from the gods of searchable email.