search

HEGSRR / OR-Replicability-in-Geography-Survey

BSD 3-Clause "New" or "Revised" License
0 stars 0 forks source link

Reviewing first manuscript draft #12

Closed Peter-Kedron closed 6 months ago

Peter-Kedron commented 12 months ago

Hello @josephholler and @SarahBardin,

I have basically completed a first rough draft of the replicability survey manuscript. It certainly remains rough in spots, and is in need of some numerical updates from Sarah (see Issue - Analytical Plan), but I think is in a place where review can begin. Here is my proposed work plan.

1) @josephholler give the draft a read and edit/add as we did with the last survey. 2) In parallel, @SarahBardin can pull together the figures and numbers in the Analytical Plan issue. 3) Those two tasks completed, I can then incorporate Sarah's work and read/respond to Joe's changes. 4) I pass to Sarah for an review and edit 5) Joe and I, do a line edit to essentially finalize 6) Sarah does a quick quality check and any last minute additions 7) Out the door for review

Let me know if that plan work for you both. Thanks

Peter-Kedron commented 11 months ago

@josephholler I updated all the figures other than Fig 4 (past Fig 3). That figure needs to be updated because I led Sarah down the wrong path in that issues exchange. Ready for your review and edits. Please just write into the manuscript no need to track changes. I am Labelled as first draft in Overleaf, so we can always return.

Peter-Kedron commented 11 months ago

@josephholler Fig 4 is corrected now. Sarah sent me the updated bar chart and I updated the illustrator file.

Peter-Kedron commented 9 months ago

@josephholler and @SarahBardin I went through the replication survey draft today and resolved all the open issues above.

There is now a refined draft ready for you review. I think this paper is also basically ready for submission. Could you please try to give this manuscript a read/edit before you both come to SB? I'm not sure we will be able to, but I would like to find an hour to talk about it when we are all here, so I can then finalize and submit.

Thanks