VP compare card for reduced and bsm only reports

[comane]

This PR implements the following things:

• comparefits with bsm only: vp-comparefits --bsmonly ...

• reduced comparefits: vp-comparefits --reduced ...

• added new SMEFT operators to comparecard

• Allows for comparisons between fits performed with a different number of WC (still both have to be done with new code #18 , #20 )

• added a script that does not compare but only plots for one fit (see validphys2.examples.bsm_only_report.yaml)

Examples:

• example of bsm only report (-bsm, --bsmonly ): https://vp.nnpdf.science/8Y__Qu4pSzq3DxUgLco1fQ==
• example of bsm only with 2 histograms report (-bsm2d, --bsmonly_2d): https://vp.nnpdf.science/zdtAWB4dTEqKijG1TKGEYw==
• example of reduced report (-red, --reduced ): https://vp.nnpdf.science/tjWPM9SVQ1S00yr1gS9UcQ==/
• example of bsm only report for single fit: https://vp.nnpdf.science/nFAJ0nkaSSyGJqI0qucSsA==/
• example fit top only vs fit all data: https://vp.nnpdf.science/vq81leecR7eqcTvE_prRQg==/#simunet-analysis

[comane]

• [ ] add script that does not compare but only plots for one fit

@LucaMantani , @J-M-Moore , @manuel-morales-a is there already a yaml card doing this?

[LucaMantani]

• [ ] add script that does not compare but only plots for one fit

@LucaMantani , @J-M-Moore , @manuel-morales-a is there already a yaml card doing this?

I have this one:

meta:
  title: BSM results
  author: LM
  keywords: [simunet, plots, validphys]
fit: 230127-lm-ttbar-fixedpdf-nlo-lin
fits: 
  - 230127-lm-ttbar-fixedpdf-nlo-lin

use_cuts: fromfit
pdfs:
 - {id: “230127-lm-ttbar-fixedpdf-nlo-lin”, label: “230127-lm-ttbar-fixedpdf-nlo-lin”}
Q: 100
flavours:
 - 2 # up
 - 21 # gluon

bsm_fac_data:
- {name: 'OtG', plot_scale: 1, latex: '$c_{tG}$'}
- {name: 'Opt', plot_scale: 1, latex: '$c_{\varphi t}$'}
- {name: 'OtZ', plot_scale: 1, latex: '$c_{tZ}$'}
- {name: 'OtW', plot_scale: 1, latex: '$c_{tW}$'}
- {name: 'O3pQ3', plot_scale: 1, latex: '$c_{\varphi Q}^{(3)}$'}
- {name: 'OpQM', plot_scale: 1, latex: '$c_{\varphi Q}^{(-)}$'}
- {name: 'O1qd', plot_scale: 1, latex: '$c_{Qd}^{1}$'}
- {name: 'O1qu', plot_scale: 1, latex: '$c_{Qu}^{1}$'}
- {name: 'O1dt', plot_scale: 1, latex: '$c_{dt}^{1}$'} 
- {name: 'O1qt', plot_scale: 1, latex: '$c_{qt}^{1}$'} 
- {name: 'O1ut', plot_scale: 1, latex: '$c_{ut}^{1}$'} 
- {name: 'O11qq', plot_scale: 1, latex: '$c_{Qq}^{1,1}$'} 
- {name: 'O13qq', plot_scale: 1, latex: '$c_{Qq}^{1,3}$'} 
- {name: 'O8qd', plot_scale: 1, latex: '$c_{Qd}^{8}$'}
- {name: 'O8qu', plot_scale: 1, latex: '$c_{Qu}^{8}$'}
- {name: 'O8dt', plot_scale: 1, latex: '$c_{dt}^{8}$'} 
- {name: 'O8qt', plot_scale: 1, latex: '$c_{qt}^{8}$'} 
- {name: 'O8ut', plot_scale: 1, latex: '$c_{ut}^{8}$'} 
- {name: 'O81qq', plot_scale: 1, latex: '$c_{Qq}^{8,1}$'} 
- {name: 'O83qq', plot_scale: 1, latex: '$c_{Qq}^{8,3}$'}
- {name: 'OQt8', plot_scale: 1, latex: '$c_{Qt}^{8}$'}
- {name: 'OQQ1', plot_scale: 1, latex: '$c_{QQ}^{1}$'}
- {name: 'OQQ8', plot_scale: 1, latex: '$c_{QQ}^{8}$'}
- {name: 'OQt1', plot_scale: 1, latex: '$c_{Qt}^{1}$'}
- {name: 'Ott1', plot_scale: 1, latex: '$c_{tt}^{1}$'}

# Posterior distribution binnings
posterior_plots_settings:
  same_bins: True
  n_bins: 15
  rangex: [-0.5, 0.6]
  rangey: [0, 5]

template_text: |
 # Histograms of BSM factors
 {@plot_nd_bsm_facs@}
 # KDE of BSM factors
 {@plot_kde_bsm_facs@}
 # 2D correlations of BSM factors
 {@plot_bsm_2d_combs@}
 # BSM factor statistics
 {@bsm_facs_bounds@}
 # 95% CL bounds
 {@plot_bsm_facs_bounds@}
 # BSM 68% Residuals
 {@plot_bsm_facs_68res@}
 # Plot Chi2
 {@plot_fits_datasets_chi2@}
 # BSM correlation matrix
 {@plot_bsm_corr@}
 # PDF-BSM factor correlations
 {@fits plot_bsm_pdf_corr@}

actions_:
  - report(main=True)

[LucaMantani]

@comane I have been using these things and they seem to be working fine, merge?

[LucaMantani]

I added a couple of review comments

[comane]

Hi @LucaMantani, yes I am happy to merge this branch. Which comments did you add? I don't see any.

[LucaMantani]

I started a review @comane

[comane]

Ok @LucaMantani, the feature (as well as plot scales ) has now been added. See https://vp.nnpdf.science/zdtAWB4dTEqKijG1TKGEYw==

Feel free to have a look at it and once you approve it we can merge it

[LucaMantani]

Yes, it looks good to me! I am merging it