HabitRPG / habitica

A habit tracker app which treats your goals like a Role Playing Game.
https://habitica.com
Other
11.97k stars 4.09k forks source link

Numbered tasks #306

Closed racuna closed 11 years ago

racuna commented 11 years ago

Some task have different value depending of a certain number: take stairs 2 floor (my work) is not the same than 14 floors (my apartment). So, add an option to have a number as a complement to the organic value would be nice.

Some examples where Numbered tasks (needs a better name):

The rule of XP gained can be based on the media for each task, so if one day i walk for 60 minutes, and tomorrow i walk 30, im just gained 0.5*XP

wc8 commented 11 years ago

Considering the examples given, is this a suggestion for an enhancement of habits and/or daily tasks? (For example, something similar to https://github.com/lefnire/habitrpg/issues/142#issuecomment-12519651) Or for a new kind of task as the #195 skill-item proposal is?

racuna commented 11 years ago

None of those. Is not about how many times I do something nor learning some skill.

I'm thinking in the effort to walk upstairs 2 floors is not the same than walk upstairs 14 floors. So, based in a formula maybe would be nice earn more points for the additional effort.

Im thinking in two ways to think in this kind of tasks:

I create a new numbered daily task: N pushups

Pandoro commented 11 years ago

I get your idea, but I think there is also more pressing stuff at hand right now. :x For similar behaviour, I simply click the plus button more often on a habit if I really want this. You could keep track of your goal in the note field. Of course this is not the same, but at least you can achieve this suggestion like that and I guess at some point this sounds pretty realistic.

horusofoz commented 11 years ago

@Racuna I keep "Bonus Productivity" and "Bonus Exercise" habits available to provide the productivty you're looking for. Whenever I exceed my prescribed reps or do a job not on my list, I give myself a + on the relevant habit.

This helps you keep everything neat. Only problem is it will make you want to do Bones work every day to get it green/blue :)

Would this workaround suffice?

Pandoro commented 11 years ago

I certainly don't want to forget about this one though. It's just that the trello board is piling up so much stuff. If we keep adding everything, I think it soon looses it's value and we will start to make a trello board for the selected ideas from the trello board, which were selected on here :x

If there are more people interested though, we can add it I guess.

On Tue, Feb 5, 2013 at 10:03 PM, horusofoz notifications@github.com wrote:

@Racuna https://github.com/Racuna I keep "Bonus Productivity" and "Bonus Exercise" habits available to provide the productivty you're looking for. Whenever I exceed my prescribed reps or do a job not on my list, I give myself a + on the relevant habit.

This helps you keep everything neat. Only problem is it will make you want to do Bones work every day to get it green/blue :)

Would this workaround suffice?

— Reply to this email directly or view it on GitHubhttps://github.com/lefnire/habitrpg/issues/306#issuecomment-13151673.

StanLindsey commented 11 years ago

We need to start consolidating the trello cards together, e.g. one which has all the organising/tagiging/numbered things. One for data display that has everything pertaining to graphs etc.

wc8 commented 11 years ago

The difficulty is voting. Perhaps there would be a way of grouping cards together by topic instead of by vote, since you can still see the number of votes? Or perhaps a few more lists? If something's not ready to be voted on but relates to a card already on trello, it could work to list it as a checklist item. Later it can be converted to a card.

horusofoz commented 11 years ago

How about we preen Trello a bit? If a card has received no votes after a month or whatever specified time we archive it. If someone else requests the feature we restore the car, direct the user to it and give them the opportunity to vote for it. Won't make a big dent but will reduce to active requests and probably a good practice going forward.

horusofoz commented 11 years ago

Closing ticket as no response from user after 17 days.