Mapping assumes XKB scancodes, but is supposed to use evdev scancodes

picuber commented 1 year ago

OS: Arch Linux x86_64 Kernel: 6.0.5-arch1-1 locale: en_US.UTF-8 Keyboard layout: UK Dvorak (setxkbmap gb dvorak caps:escape ) X.Org version: 21.1.4

It seems to produce the wrong mapping on my system. I've also tried it with other keyboard layouts, and setting the X11 Layout with localectl, but it still generates a (albeit a different) wrong mapping.

Output of localectl status:

System Locale: LANG=en_US.UTF-8
    VC Keymap: dvorak-uk
   X11 Layout: (unset)

Output of cargo run --example all_keys:

    Finished dev [unoptimized + debuginfo] target(s) in 0.04s
     Running `target/debug/examples/all_keys`
                         Abort -> "Abort"
                         Again -> "KP_Decimal"
                       AltLeft -> "X"
                      AltRight -> "Henkan_Mode"
                     ArrowDown -> "ISO_Level3_Shift"
                     ArrowLeft -> "Control_R"
                    ArrowRight -> "KP_Divide"
                       ArrowUp -> "NoSymbol"
               AudioVolumeDown -> "Right"
               AudioVolumeMute -> "Left"
                 AudioVolumeUp -> "End"
                     Backquote -> "U"
                     Backslash -> "D"
                     Backspace -> "5"
                   BracketLeft -> "period"
                  BracketRight -> "P"
                BrightnessDown -> "XF86Messenger"
                  BrightnessUp -> "XF86Search"
                   BrowserBack -> "XF86WWW"
              BrowserFavorites -> "XF86Launch1"
                BrowserForward -> "XF86DOS"
                   BrowserHome -> "XF86AudioPlay"
                BrowserRefresh -> "XF86AudioPrev"
                 BrowserSearch -> "NoSymbol"
                   BrowserStop -> "XF86LaunchA"
                      CapsLock -> "M"
                         Comma -> "numbersign"
                   ContextMenu -> "Pause"
                   ControlLeft -> "F"
                  ControlRight -> "NoSymbol"
                       Convert -> "ISO_Level3_Shift"
                          Copy -> "Super_L"
                           Cut -> "Redo"
                        Delete -> "Up"
                        Digit0 -> "2"
                        Digit1 -> "NoSymbol"
                        Digit2 -> "NoSymbol"
                        Digit3 -> "NoSymbol"
                        Digit4 -> "NoSymbol"
                        Digit5 -> "NoSymbol"
                        Digit6 -> "NoSymbol"
                        Digit7 -> "NoSymbol"
                        Digit8 -> "Escape"
                        Digit9 -> "1"
           DisplayToggleIntExt -> "XF86Finance"
                         Eject -> "XF86RotateWindows"
                           End -> "Multi_key"
                         Enter -> "Y"
                         Equal -> "4"
                        Escape -> "NoSymbol"
                            F1 -> "W"
                           F10 -> "F2"
                           F11 -> "KP_End"
                           F12 -> "KP_Down"
                           F13 -> "NoSymbol"
                           F14 -> "NoSymbol"
                           F15 -> "XF86ScrollUp"
                           F16 -> "XF86ScrollDown"
                           F17 -> "parenleft"
                           F18 -> "parenright"
                           F19 -> "XF86New"
                            F2 -> "V"
                           F20 -> "Redo"
                           F21 -> "XF86Tools"
                           F22 -> "XF86Launch5"
                           F23 -> "XF86Launch6"
                           F24 -> "XF86Launch7"
                            F3 -> "Z"
                            F4 -> "Shift_R"
                            F5 -> "KP_Multiply"
                            F6 -> "Alt_L"
                            F7 -> "space"
                            F8 -> "Escape"
                            F9 -> "F1"
                          Find -> "Cancel"
                            Fn -> "Fn"
                        FnLock -> "FnLock"
                          Help -> "SunProps"
                          Home -> "Muhenkan"
                         Hyper -> "Hyper"
                        Insert -> "Home"
                 IntlBackslash -> "KP_Add"
                      IntlHash -> "IntlHash"
                        IntlRo -> "KP_Next"
                       IntlYen -> "XF86PowerOff"
                      KanaMode -> "NoSymbol"
                          KeyA -> "G"
                          KeyB -> "minus"
                          KeyC -> "N"
                          KeyD -> "R"
                          KeyE -> "9"
                          KeyF -> "L"
                          KeyG -> "slash"
                          KeyH -> "equal"
                          KeyI -> "Tab"
                          KeyJ -> "Return"
                          KeyK -> "Control_L"
                          KeyL -> "A"
                          KeyM -> "Shift_L"
                          KeyN -> "grave"
                          KeyO -> "apostrophe"
                          KeyP -> "comma"
                          KeyQ -> "7"
                          KeyR -> "0"
                          KeyS -> "C"
                          KeyT -> "bracketleft"
                          KeyU -> "BackSpace"
                          KeyV -> "S"
                          KeyW -> "8"
                          KeyX -> "T"
                          KeyY -> "bracketright"
                          KeyZ -> "H"
          KeyboardLayoutSelect -> "NoSymbol"
                         Lang1 -> "XF86AudioLowerVolume"
                         Lang2 -> "XF86AudioRaiseVolume"
                         Lang3 -> "KP_Insert"
                         Lang4 -> "KP_Delete"
                         Lang5 -> "KP_Right"
                    LaunchApp1 -> "Find"
                    LaunchApp2 -> "SunFront"
               LaunchAssistant -> "NoSymbol"
            LaunchControlPanel -> "NoSymbol"
                    LaunchMail -> "XF86Xfer"
             LaunchScreenSaver -> "NoSymbol"
                   MailForward -> "XF86MonBrightnessUp"
                     MailReply -> "XF86MonBrightnessDown"
                      MailSend -> "Cancel"
              MediaFastForward -> "XF86AudioPlay"
                     MediaPlay -> "NoSymbol"
                MediaPlayPause -> "XF86Favorites"
                   MediaRecord -> "XF86Forward"
                   MediaRewind -> "NoSymbol"
                   MediaSelect -> "XF86AudioNext"
                     MediaStop -> "XF86Back"
                MediaTrackNext -> "XF86Mail"
            MediaTrackPrevious -> "XF86MyComputer"
                      MetaLeft -> "KP_Equal"
                     MetaRight -> "plusminus"
                         Minus -> "3"
                    NonConvert -> "backslash"
                       NumLock -> "F3"
                       Numpad0 -> "KP_Subtract"
                       Numpad1 -> "KP_Home"
                       Numpad2 -> "KP_Up"
                       Numpad3 -> "KP_Prior"
                       Numpad4 -> "F9"
                       Numpad5 -> "F10"
                       Numpad6 -> "Num_Lock"
                       Numpad7 -> "F5"
                       Numpad8 -> "F6"
                       Numpad9 -> "F7"
                     NumpadAdd -> "Scroll_Lock"
               NumpadBackspace -> "NumpadBackspace"
                   NumpadClear -> "NumpadClear"
              NumpadClearEntry -> "NumpadClearEntry"
                   NumpadComma -> "XF86AudioMute"
                 NumpadDecimal -> "KP_Left"
                  NumpadDivide -> "Katakana"
                   NumpadEnter -> "F12"
                   NumpadEqual -> "Next"
               NumpadMemoryAdd -> "NumpadMemoryAdd"
             NumpadMemoryClear -> "NumpadMemoryClear"
            NumpadMemoryRecall -> "NumpadMemoryRecall"
             NumpadMemoryStore -> "NumpadMemoryStore"
          NumpadMemorySubtract -> "NumpadMemorySubtract"
                NumpadMultiply -> "K"
               NumpadParenLeft -> "XF86Tools"
              NumpadParenRight -> "XF86HomePage"
                NumpadSubtract -> "F8"
                          Open -> "Super_R"
                      PageDown -> "Linefeed"
                        PageUp -> "KP_Enter"
                         Paste -> "Menu"
                         Pause -> "Delete"
                        Period -> "semicolon"
                         Power -> "Down"
                   PrintScreen -> "Hiragana"
                         Props -> "Props"
                         Quote -> "E"
                        Resume -> "Resume"
                    ScrollLock -> "F4"
                        Select -> "NoSymbol"
                    SelectTask -> "NoSymbol"
                     Semicolon -> "O"
                     ShiftLeft -> "I"
                    ShiftRight -> "J"
                ShowAllWindows -> "NoSymbol"
                         Slash -> "Q"
                         Sleep -> "XF86Open"
                         Space -> "B"
                         Super -> "Super"
                       Suspend -> "Suspend"
                           Tab -> "6"
                         Turbo -> "Turbo"
                          Undo -> "Hangul_Hanja"
                        WakeUp -> "XF86Paste"
                    ZoomToggle -> "NoSymbol"

Modifiers: Ctrl + Shift + Alt + Super + <key>

HactarCE commented 1 year ago

Oh geez, that output is a mess. Thank you for reporting! I'm curious whenever v1.2.0 produces the correct output?

picuber commented 1 year ago

(sry for the late reply, I couldn't get to my mashine for a bit)

I've tried it out with v1.2.0, and it seems to work. It's still garbled, but it's consistent with dvorak <-> querty (which I assume is the intented functionality)

With dvorak layout

``` Compiling key-names v1.2.0 (/home/picuber/opt/key-names) Finished dev [unoptimized + debuginfo] target(s) in 2.09s Running `target/debug/examples/all_keys` Abort -> "Abort" Again -> "Redo" AltLeft -> "Alt_L" AltRight -> "ISO_Level3_Shift" ArrowDown -> "Down" ArrowLeft -> "Left" ArrowRight -> "Right" ArrowUp -> "Up" AudioVolumeDown -> "XF86AudioLowerVolume" AudioVolumeMute -> "XF86AudioMute" AudioVolumeUp -> "XF86AudioRaiseVolume" Backquote -> "grave" Backslash -> "numbersign" Backspace -> "BackSpace" BracketLeft -> "slash" BracketRight -> "equal" BrightnessDown -> "XF86MonBrightnessDown" BrightnessUp -> "XF86MonBrightnessUp" BrowserBack -> "XF86Back" BrowserFavorites -> "XF86Favorites" BrowserForward -> "XF86Forward" BrowserHome -> "XF86HomePage" BrowserRefresh -> "XF86Reload" BrowserSearch -> "XF86Search" BrowserStop -> "Cancel" CapsLock -> "Escape" Comma -> "W" ContextMenu -> "Menu" ControlLeft -> "Control_L" ControlRight -> "Control_R" Convert -> "Henkan_Mode" Copy -> "XF86Copy" Cut -> "XF86Cut" Delete -> "Delete" Digit0 -> "0" Digit1 -> "1" Digit2 -> "2" Digit3 -> "3" Digit4 -> "4" Digit5 -> "5" Digit6 -> "6" Digit7 -> "7" Digit8 -> "8" Digit9 -> "9" DisplayToggleIntExt -> "XF86Display" Eject -> "XF86Eject" End -> "End" Enter -> "Return" Equal -> "bracketright" Escape -> "Escape" F1 -> "F1" F10 -> "F10" F11 -> "F11" F12 -> "F12" F13 -> "XF86Tools" F14 -> "XF86Launch5" F15 -> "XF86Launch6" F16 -> "XF86Launch7" F17 -> "XF86Launch8" F18 -> "XF86Launch9" F19 -> "NoSymbol" F2 -> "F2" F20 -> "XF86AudioMicMute" F21 -> "XF86TouchpadToggle" F22 -> "XF86TouchpadOn" F23 -> "XF86TouchpadOff" F24 -> "NoSymbol" F3 -> "F3" F4 -> "F4" F5 -> "F5" F6 -> "F6" F7 -> "F7" F8 -> "F8" F9 -> "F9" Find -> "Find" Fn -> "Fn" FnLock -> "FnLock" Help -> "Help" Home -> "Home" Hyper -> "Hyper" Insert -> "Insert" IntlBackslash -> "backslash" IntlHash -> "IntlHash" IntlRo -> "NoSymbol" IntlYen -> "NoSymbol" KanaMode -> "Hiragana_Katakana" KeyA -> "A" KeyB -> "X" KeyC -> "J" KeyD -> "E" KeyE -> "period" KeyF -> "U" KeyG -> "I" KeyH -> "D" KeyI -> "C" KeyJ -> "H" KeyK -> "T" KeyL -> "N" KeyM -> "M" KeyN -> "B" KeyO -> "R" KeyP -> "L" KeyQ -> "apostrophe" KeyR -> "P" KeyS -> "O" KeyT -> "Y" KeyU -> "G" KeyV -> "K" KeyW -> "comma" KeyX -> "Q" KeyY -> "F" KeyZ -> "semicolon" KeyboardLayoutSelect -> "NoSymbol" Lang1 -> "Hangul" Lang2 -> "Hangul_Hanja" Lang3 -> "Katakana" Lang4 -> "Hiragana" Lang5 -> "NoSymbol" LaunchApp1 -> "XF86Explorer" LaunchApp2 -> "XF86Calculator" LaunchAssistant -> "NoSymbol" LaunchControlPanel -> "NoSymbol" LaunchMail -> "XF86Mail" LaunchScreenSaver -> "NoSymbol" MailForward -> "XF86MailForward" MailReply -> "XF86Reply" MailSend -> "XF86Send" MediaFastForward -> "XF86AudioForward" MediaPlay -> "XF86AudioPlay" MediaPlayPause -> "XF86AudioPlay" MediaRecord -> "XF86AudioRecord" MediaRewind -> "XF86AudioRewind" MediaSelect -> "XF86Tools" MediaStop -> "XF86AudioStop" MediaTrackNext -> "XF86AudioNext" MediaTrackPrevious -> "XF86AudioPrev" MetaLeft -> "Super_L" MetaRight -> "Super_R" Minus -> "bracketleft" NonConvert -> "Muhenkan" NumLock -> "Num_Lock" Numpad0 -> "KP_Insert" Numpad1 -> "KP_End" Numpad2 -> "KP_Down" Numpad3 -> "KP_Next" Numpad4 -> "KP_Left" Numpad5 -> "KP_Begin" Numpad6 -> "KP_Right" Numpad7 -> "KP_Home" Numpad8 -> "KP_Up" Numpad9 -> "KP_Prior" NumpadAdd -> "KP_Add" NumpadBackspace -> "NumpadBackspace" NumpadClear -> "NumpadClear" NumpadClearEntry -> "NumpadClearEntry" NumpadComma -> "KP_Decimal" NumpadDecimal -> "KP_Delete" NumpadDivide -> "KP_Divide" NumpadEnter -> "KP_Enter" NumpadEqual -> "KP_Equal" NumpadMemoryAdd -> "NumpadMemoryAdd" NumpadMemoryClear -> "NumpadMemoryClear" NumpadMemoryRecall -> "NumpadMemoryRecall" NumpadMemoryStore -> "NumpadMemoryStore" NumpadMemorySubtract -> "NumpadMemorySubtract" NumpadMultiply -> "KP_Multiply" NumpadParenLeft -> "parenleft" NumpadParenRight -> "parenright" NumpadSubtract -> "KP_Subtract" Open -> "XF86Open" PageDown -> "Next" PageUp -> "Prior" Paste -> "XF86Paste" Pause -> "Pause" Period -> "V" Power -> "XF86PowerOff" PrintScreen -> "Multi_key" Props -> "Props" Quote -> "minus" Resume -> "Resume" ScrollLock -> "Scroll_Lock" Select -> "SunFront" SelectTask -> "NoSymbol" Semicolon -> "S" ShiftLeft -> "Shift_L" ShiftRight -> "Shift_R" ShowAllWindows -> "XF86LaunchA" Slash -> "Z" Sleep -> "XF86Sleep" Space -> "space" Super -> "Super" Suspend -> "Suspend" Tab -> "Tab" Turbo -> "Turbo" Undo -> "Undo" WakeUp -> "XF86WakeUp" ZoomToggle -> "NoSymbol" Modifiers: Ctrl + Shift + Alt + Super + ```

With querty layout

``` Finished dev [unoptimized + debuginfo] target(s) in 0.04s Running `target/debug/examples/all_keys` Abort -> "Abort" Again -> "Redo" AltLeft -> "Alt_L" AltRight -> "ISO_Level3_Shift" ArrowDown -> "Down" ArrowLeft -> "Left" ArrowRight -> "Right" ArrowUp -> "Up" AudioVolumeDown -> "XF86AudioLowerVolume" AudioVolumeMute -> "XF86AudioMute" AudioVolumeUp -> "XF86AudioRaiseVolume" Backquote -> "grave" Backslash -> "numbersign" Backspace -> "BackSpace" BracketLeft -> "bracketleft" BracketRight -> "bracketright" BrightnessDown -> "XF86MonBrightnessDown" BrightnessUp -> "XF86MonBrightnessUp" BrowserBack -> "XF86Back" BrowserFavorites -> "XF86Favorites" BrowserForward -> "XF86Forward" BrowserHome -> "XF86HomePage" BrowserRefresh -> "XF86Reload" BrowserSearch -> "XF86Search" BrowserStop -> "Cancel" CapsLock -> "Escape" Comma -> "comma" ContextMenu -> "Menu" ControlLeft -> "Control_L" ControlRight -> "Control_R" Convert -> "Henkan_Mode" Copy -> "XF86Copy" Cut -> "XF86Cut" Delete -> "Delete" Digit0 -> "0" Digit1 -> "1" Digit2 -> "2" Digit3 -> "3" Digit4 -> "4" Digit5 -> "5" Digit6 -> "6" Digit7 -> "7" Digit8 -> "8" Digit9 -> "9" DisplayToggleIntExt -> "XF86Display" Eject -> "XF86Eject" End -> "End" Enter -> "Return" Equal -> "equal" Escape -> "Escape" F1 -> "F1" F10 -> "F10" F11 -> "F11" F12 -> "F12" F13 -> "XF86Tools" F14 -> "XF86Launch5" F15 -> "XF86Launch6" F16 -> "XF86Launch7" F17 -> "XF86Launch8" F18 -> "XF86Launch9" F19 -> "NoSymbol" F2 -> "F2" F20 -> "XF86AudioMicMute" F21 -> "XF86TouchpadToggle" F22 -> "XF86TouchpadOn" F23 -> "XF86TouchpadOff" F24 -> "NoSymbol" F3 -> "F3" F4 -> "F4" F5 -> "F5" F6 -> "F6" F7 -> "F7" F8 -> "F8" F9 -> "F9" Find -> "Find" Fn -> "Fn" FnLock -> "FnLock" Help -> "Help" Home -> "Home" Hyper -> "Hyper" Insert -> "Insert" IntlBackslash -> "backslash" IntlHash -> "IntlHash" IntlRo -> "NoSymbol" IntlYen -> "NoSymbol" KanaMode -> "Hiragana_Katakana" KeyA -> "A" KeyB -> "B" KeyC -> "C" KeyD -> "D" KeyE -> "E" KeyF -> "F" KeyG -> "G" KeyH -> "H" KeyI -> "I" KeyJ -> "J" KeyK -> "K" KeyL -> "L" KeyM -> "M" KeyN -> "N" KeyO -> "O" KeyP -> "P" KeyQ -> "Q" KeyR -> "R" KeyS -> "S" KeyT -> "T" KeyU -> "U" KeyV -> "V" KeyW -> "W" KeyX -> "X" KeyY -> "Y" KeyZ -> "Z" KeyboardLayoutSelect -> "NoSymbol" Lang1 -> "Hangul" Lang2 -> "Hangul_Hanja" Lang3 -> "Katakana" Lang4 -> "Hiragana" Lang5 -> "NoSymbol" LaunchApp1 -> "XF86Explorer" LaunchApp2 -> "XF86Calculator" LaunchAssistant -> "NoSymbol" LaunchControlPanel -> "NoSymbol" LaunchMail -> "XF86Mail" LaunchScreenSaver -> "NoSymbol" MailForward -> "XF86MailForward" MailReply -> "XF86Reply" MailSend -> "XF86Send" MediaFastForward -> "XF86AudioForward" MediaPlay -> "XF86AudioPlay" MediaPlayPause -> "XF86AudioPlay" MediaRecord -> "XF86AudioRecord" MediaRewind -> "XF86AudioRewind" MediaSelect -> "XF86Tools" MediaStop -> "XF86AudioStop" MediaTrackNext -> "XF86AudioNext" MediaTrackPrevious -> "XF86AudioPrev" MetaLeft -> "Super_L" MetaRight -> "Super_R" Minus -> "minus" NonConvert -> "Muhenkan" NumLock -> "Num_Lock" Numpad0 -> "KP_Insert" Numpad1 -> "KP_End" Numpad2 -> "KP_Down" Numpad3 -> "KP_Next" Numpad4 -> "KP_Left" Numpad5 -> "KP_Begin" Numpad6 -> "KP_Right" Numpad7 -> "KP_Home" Numpad8 -> "KP_Up" Numpad9 -> "KP_Prior" NumpadAdd -> "KP_Add" NumpadBackspace -> "NumpadBackspace" NumpadClear -> "NumpadClear" NumpadClearEntry -> "NumpadClearEntry" NumpadComma -> "KP_Decimal" NumpadDecimal -> "KP_Delete" NumpadDivide -> "KP_Divide" NumpadEnter -> "KP_Enter" NumpadEqual -> "KP_Equal" NumpadMemoryAdd -> "NumpadMemoryAdd" NumpadMemoryClear -> "NumpadMemoryClear" NumpadMemoryRecall -> "NumpadMemoryRecall" NumpadMemoryStore -> "NumpadMemoryStore" NumpadMemorySubtract -> "NumpadMemorySubtract" NumpadMultiply -> "KP_Multiply" NumpadParenLeft -> "parenleft" NumpadParenRight -> "parenright" NumpadSubtract -> "KP_Subtract" Open -> "XF86Open" PageDown -> "Next" PageUp -> "Prior" Paste -> "XF86Paste" Pause -> "Pause" Period -> "period" Power -> "XF86PowerOff" PrintScreen -> "Print" Props -> "Props" Quote -> "apostrophe" Resume -> "Resume" ScrollLock -> "Scroll_Lock" Select -> "SunFront" SelectTask -> "NoSymbol" Semicolon -> "semicolon" ShiftLeft -> "Shift_L" ShiftRight -> "Shift_R" ShowAllWindows -> "XF86LaunchA" Slash -> "slash" Sleep -> "XF86Sleep" Space -> "space" Super -> "Super" Suspend -> "Suspend" Tab -> "Tab" Turbo -> "Turbo" Undo -> "Undo" WakeUp -> "XF86WakeUp" ZoomToggle -> "NoSymbol" Modifiers: Ctrl + Shift + Alt + Super + ```

With quertz layout

``` Finished dev [unoptimized + debuginfo] target(s) in 0.05s Running `target/debug/examples/all_keys` Abort -> "Abort" Again -> "Redo" AltLeft -> "Alt_L" AltRight -> "ISO_Level3_Shift" ArrowDown -> "Down" ArrowLeft -> "Left" ArrowRight -> "Right" ArrowUp -> "Up" AudioVolumeDown -> "XF86AudioLowerVolume" AudioVolumeMute -> "XF86AudioMute" AudioVolumeUp -> "XF86AudioRaiseVolume" Backquote -> "dead_circumflex" Backslash -> "numbersign" Backspace -> "BackSpace" BracketLeft -> "udiaeresis" BracketRight -> "plus" BrightnessDown -> "XF86MonBrightnessDown" BrightnessUp -> "XF86MonBrightnessUp" BrowserBack -> "XF86Back" BrowserFavorites -> "XF86Favorites" BrowserForward -> "XF86Forward" BrowserHome -> "XF86HomePage" BrowserRefresh -> "XF86Reload" BrowserSearch -> "XF86Search" BrowserStop -> "Cancel" CapsLock -> "Caps_Lock" Comma -> "comma" ContextMenu -> "Menu" ControlLeft -> "Control_L" ControlRight -> "Control_R" Convert -> "Henkan_Mode" Copy -> "XF86Copy" Cut -> "XF86Cut" Delete -> "Delete" Digit0 -> "0" Digit1 -> "1" Digit2 -> "2" Digit3 -> "3" Digit4 -> "4" Digit5 -> "5" Digit6 -> "6" Digit7 -> "7" Digit8 -> "8" Digit9 -> "9" DisplayToggleIntExt -> "XF86Display" Eject -> "XF86Eject" End -> "End" Enter -> "Return" Equal -> "dead_acute" Escape -> "Escape" F1 -> "F1" F10 -> "F10" F11 -> "F11" F12 -> "F12" F13 -> "XF86Tools" F14 -> "XF86Launch5" F15 -> "XF86Launch6" F16 -> "XF86Launch7" F17 -> "XF86Launch8" F18 -> "XF86Launch9" F19 -> "NoSymbol" F2 -> "F2" F20 -> "XF86AudioMicMute" F21 -> "XF86TouchpadToggle" F22 -> "XF86TouchpadOn" F23 -> "XF86TouchpadOff" F24 -> "NoSymbol" F3 -> "F3" F4 -> "F4" F5 -> "F5" F6 -> "F6" F7 -> "F7" F8 -> "F8" F9 -> "F9" Find -> "Find" Fn -> "Fn" FnLock -> "FnLock" Help -> "Help" Home -> "Home" Hyper -> "Hyper" Insert -> "Insert" IntlBackslash -> "less" IntlHash -> "IntlHash" IntlRo -> "NoSymbol" IntlYen -> "NoSymbol" KanaMode -> "Hiragana_Katakana" KeyA -> "A" KeyB -> "B" KeyC -> "C" KeyD -> "D" KeyE -> "E" KeyF -> "F" KeyG -> "G" KeyH -> "H" KeyI -> "I" KeyJ -> "J" KeyK -> "K" KeyL -> "L" KeyM -> "M" KeyN -> "N" KeyO -> "O" KeyP -> "P" KeyQ -> "Q" KeyR -> "R" KeyS -> "S" KeyT -> "T" KeyU -> "U" KeyV -> "V" KeyW -> "W" KeyX -> "X" KeyY -> "Z" KeyZ -> "Y" KeyboardLayoutSelect -> "NoSymbol" Lang1 -> "Hangul" Lang2 -> "Hangul_Hanja" Lang3 -> "Katakana" Lang4 -> "Hiragana" Lang5 -> "NoSymbol" LaunchApp1 -> "XF86Explorer" LaunchApp2 -> "XF86Calculator" LaunchAssistant -> "NoSymbol" LaunchControlPanel -> "NoSymbol" LaunchMail -> "XF86Mail" LaunchScreenSaver -> "NoSymbol" MailForward -> "XF86MailForward" MailReply -> "XF86Reply" MailSend -> "XF86Send" MediaFastForward -> "XF86AudioForward" MediaPlay -> "XF86AudioPlay" MediaPlayPause -> "XF86AudioPlay" MediaRecord -> "XF86AudioRecord" MediaRewind -> "XF86AudioRewind" MediaSelect -> "XF86Tools" MediaStop -> "XF86AudioStop" MediaTrackNext -> "XF86AudioNext" MediaTrackPrevious -> "XF86AudioPrev" MetaLeft -> "Super_L" MetaRight -> "Super_R" Minus -> "ssharp" NonConvert -> "Muhenkan" NumLock -> "Num_Lock" Numpad0 -> "KP_Insert" Numpad1 -> "KP_End" Numpad2 -> "KP_Down" Numpad3 -> "KP_Next" Numpad4 -> "KP_Left" Numpad5 -> "KP_Begin" Numpad6 -> "KP_Right" Numpad7 -> "KP_Home" Numpad8 -> "KP_Up" Numpad9 -> "KP_Prior" NumpadAdd -> "KP_Add" NumpadBackspace -> "NumpadBackspace" NumpadClear -> "NumpadClear" NumpadClearEntry -> "NumpadClearEntry" NumpadComma -> "KP_Decimal" NumpadDecimal -> "KP_Delete" NumpadDivide -> "KP_Divide" NumpadEnter -> "KP_Enter" NumpadEqual -> "KP_Equal" NumpadMemoryAdd -> "NumpadMemoryAdd" NumpadMemoryClear -> "NumpadMemoryClear" NumpadMemoryRecall -> "NumpadMemoryRecall" NumpadMemoryStore -> "NumpadMemoryStore" NumpadMemorySubtract -> "NumpadMemorySubtract" NumpadMultiply -> "KP_Multiply" NumpadParenLeft -> "parenleft" NumpadParenRight -> "parenright" NumpadSubtract -> "KP_Subtract" Open -> "XF86Open" PageDown -> "Next" PageUp -> "Prior" Paste -> "XF86Paste" Pause -> "Pause" Period -> "period" Power -> "XF86PowerOff" PrintScreen -> "Print" Props -> "Props" Quote -> "adiaeresis" Resume -> "Resume" ScrollLock -> "Scroll_Lock" Select -> "SunFront" SelectTask -> "NoSymbol" Semicolon -> "odiaeresis" ShiftLeft -> "Shift_L" ShiftRight -> "Shift_R" ShowAllWindows -> "XF86LaunchA" Slash -> "minus" Sleep -> "XF86Sleep" Space -> "space" Super -> "Super" Suspend -> "Suspend" Tab -> "Tab" Turbo -> "Turbo" Undo -> "Undo" WakeUp -> "XF86WakeUp" ZoomToggle -> "NoSymbol" Modifiers: Ctrl + Shift + Alt + Super + ```

However, when I tried it with Hyperspeedcube (which is where I originally encountered this bug. If I should open a separate issue over there, do tell me), while with v1.3.0 it seems to do the right things but showing me the wrong lables, with v1.2.0 it shows me the right things (according to the selected keyboard layout on startup) it "presses" (according to the keybinds reference showing them) the opposite garbled key.

E.g.: With v1.3.0: I press U (Dvorak = F Querty), it shows it in the correct place, does the right thing (select R face with Default Keybinds), but displays L. With v1.2.0: I press U (Dvorak = F Querty), it shows it in the place of L (Dvorak = P Querty), and also does the thing that is at that position ("yx", rotate in z axis), but correctly displays U.

HactarCE commented 1 year ago

Thank you so much for investigating further! There's a few things going on here:

key-names is able to convert between keysym and scancode only for XKB scancodes.
winit (where Hyperspeedcube gets it key events from) gives evdev scancodes.
The old version of key-names used xkb keycodes, which is why it says the right thing but garbles your keypresses.
The new version of key-names uses evdev keycodes, which is why it handles your keypresses correctly (for puzzle keybinds at least) but says the wrong thing -- it messes up the mapping between keysym and scancode.

There are two solutions I can think of:

Find a way to query the keyboard mapping using evdev scancodes. This would be ideal.
Hard-code a mapping between evdev scancodes and XKB scancodes. This is ugly, but would definitely work.

I don't have a Linux install to test this on nor the time to devote to it, but if you want to open a PR doing either of those I would be happy to merge it and include it in the next release of HSC. If not, that's totally understandable.

HactarCE / key-names

Mapping assumes XKB scancodes, but is supposed to use evdev scancodes #5