HearthSim / hs-bugs

Unofficial Hearthstone issue tracker
https://hearthsim.info
65 stars 3 forks source link

Tiger summoned by Spirit of Tigers always gains Divine Shield from Steward of Darkshire regardless of its stats #1089

Open Kybxd opened 5 years ago

Kybxd commented 5 years ago

See (4:55 to 6:20) https://www.bilibili.com/video/av38715045

Seems that it sets stats too late. Not sure what will happen with Sword of Justice/Crystal Core.

troggnostupidhs commented 5 years ago

Does not happen with Jades

edit: Just realized the message was in the way. But the rightmost minion was a 2/2 Jade.

hearthstone screenshot 12-25-18 00 55 19

Paladin AAEBAaToAgLtBcPqAg6zAdgB+wG0Ap8DkwThBNQF3Qq3bP+vAuLKAu3SAqbwAgA=

Druid AAEBAZICAu0F8A8OswHYAfsBtALhBLkGxAbmFrdsz7wC3b4C4soCntICpvACAA==

Kybxd commented 5 years ago

Spirit of the Lynx also works correctly with Spirit of Tigers (as for the final result). Play a 3-cost spell and the animation shows: 1.summon a 1/1 tiger 2.Lynx buffs the tiger to 2/2 3.tiger becomes a 4/4 correctly

Edit: I only mean the result is correct

ceceita commented 5 years ago

i think it's the same interaction https://us.forums.blizzard.com/en/hearthstone/t/steward-of-darkshire-underbelly-ooze/4756 Some minions are summoned in a "default" form and after they change the stats

Kybxd commented 5 years ago

@ceceita That's different. Steward of Darkshire only gives Divine Shield to minions whose Current Maximum Health is 1. Its interaction with Redemption arouse heated debate among players since the card was revealed, but it seems that game designers didn't regard this as a bug, or it would have been changed.

Jetz72 commented 5 years ago

Steward of Darkshire is kinda inconsistent with Star Aligner in that regard, which considers current effective health rather than maximum health. They use slightly different wording, though. On the fence about opening a may-be-intended report about that one.

Jetz72 commented 5 years ago

Related issues: Khadgar summons 1/1 Tigers. https://us.forums.blizzard.com/en/hearthstone/t/khadgar-and-spirit-of-the-tiger-bug/6546

I was just in a game where I used Conjurer’s Calling on a 4 cost card while Khadgar was on the board. I ended up with 2 Spirit of the Tiger and 2 Griftah. I then used Frost Nova to freeze the enemy. Then it summomed a 3/3 tiger and a 1/1 tiger. I assume khadgar copied the original 3/3 summon but the stats didn’t copy over.

The Underbelly makes all Tigers 1/1s. https://us.forums.blizzard.com/en/hearthstone/t/spirit-of-the-tiger-minions-always-1-1/8049

I was running a Heroic Dalaran Heist in The Sewers as Paladin. I had a Spirit of the Tiger on the board and played multiple spells (4-mana Orb of the Untold being one of them) but all of the Tigers that were generated with only 1 attack and 1 health.

Thanks for the report! I was able to reproduce this myself, but so far only while in The Underbelly (Chapter IV) as Jetz suspected. I’ve sent the issue up to be investigated further.

Considering refactoring this into a general issue for Spirit of the Tiger not updating stats until after the summon, and all the issues that causes.