If your minion attacks enemy hero and dies, enemy Frostmourne can revive it

HearthSim / hs-bugs

Unofficial Hearthstone issue tracker

https://hearthsim.info

65 stars 3 forks source link

If your minion attacks enemy hero and dies, enemy Frostmourne can revive it #1216

Open Kybxd opened 5 years ago

Kybxd commented 5 years ago

https://www.bilibili.com/video/av54918801 (2:18 to 3:08)

In this video, enemy has Frostmourne. Unseen Saboteur has opponent cast Heroic Strike. Your minions attack enemy hero and die. Then Ooze destroy Frostmourne. Its deathrattle revives all these minions.

There are also many ways to prove this bug:

Your minion attacks Oxana Demonslay and dies.
Opponent has Bear Trap + KJ, your minion attacks enemy hero and KJ kills it.
Opponent has Eye for an Eye, your Bolf attack enemy hero and dies for protecting your hero.

Jetz72 commented 5 years ago

The cases where it dies to another card as a consequence of a sequence of events seems weird. Determining if an effect kills a character has always been awkward on HS though, because of the death phase mechanics. Still, I wonder if the case of Heroic Strike should be considered a bug. Considering how weapons work, there isn't much technical difference between "killed by a weapon" and "killed by a hero holding that weapon". Maybe it should have to be unsheathed for it to count? Does Misdirection into Frostmourne count?

Kybxd commented 5 years ago

Case 2 and 3: https://www.bilibili.com/video/av55604882 (2:30 to 3:30)

In my opinion, Frostmourne shall only work when your weapon is unsheathed. Not sure about Misdirection.