search

HearthSim / hs-bugs

Unofficial Hearthstone issue tracker
https://hearthsim.info
65 stars 3 forks source link

Holomancer doesn't check if the minion survived at trigger time, inconsistent with other "After" triggers #1218

Open troggnostupidhs opened 5 years ago

troggnostupidhs commented 5 years ago

According to the card text, it should be an 'after' trigger.

[Holomancer][BOT_280][48415] [5 Mana, 3/3 Epic Minion] After your opponent plays a minion, summon a 1/1_copy of it.

Holomancer summons a copy of a magnetic minion

https://youtu.be/fOT5LUWk19o?t=162

A Blademaster that dies with Brann

img000

Jaraxxus

img001

And it summons a post transformed faceless. Shows it is 'after', but with no trigger condition.

img000

Knife Juggler does not trigger with magnetic (see history bar for these)

img000

Does not trigger for a killed Blademaster

img000

Does not trigger for Jaraxxus

img001

Deck AAEBAfqUAwTtBYkGhReftwMN+wGcArQChQOTBLkGsQjECNUI8tACpvACn/UCn/oCAA==

Kybxd commented 5 years ago

We tested all relevant "leave play" effects in 13.X and confirmed that Holomancer and Ixlid never consider if the minion is still in play, including death, mortally wounded / pending destroy, returned to hand, dormant, magnetic, Jaraxxus.