HearthSim / hs-bugs

Unofficial Hearthstone issue tracker
https://hearthsim.info
65 stars 3 forks source link

Giants in your opening hand affects the parity of your deck (currently only for Baku) #956

Open troggnostupidhs opened 6 years ago

troggnostupidhs commented 6 years ago

https://www.reddit.com/r/hearthstone/comments/8lcm9a/bug_report_greymane_doesnt_activate_if_you_have/

EDIT : CLOCKWORK (12 mana) TRIGGERS BAKU (odd only) IF IT'S IN YOUR OPENING HAND

(the rest of my deck is odd cards, I put only 1 Clockwork)

I'm experimenting with an even Naga Giants deck (now that NSW is 8 mana).

After numerous testings against AI, it turns out that if you have clockwork giant in your opening hand (after mulligan phase), Greymane effect doesn't trigger. This happens regardless of who goes first (thus regardless of clockwork's mana cost in your hand).

Proofs : first player / second player / with another even deck

I just hope Blizz will fix it before NSW full refund period ends :(

image

image

image

image

10925 commented 6 years ago

Some other proof(in adventure) https://imgur.com/a/AOnwSU8 Since we got Dorothee, the sea giant in hand cost 1 less, which can be count as odd.

General Drakkisath's hero power change card in hand to 1, so DK warrior count as odd.

Jetz72 commented 6 years ago

When you fight General Drakkisath (Passive: All cards cost 1), Baku always triggers whatever other cards of your deck are.

That's an interesting inconsistency. Most card cost auras only affect the cards after they've entered the hand. Bringing odd-cost secrets to a game with Putricide will only prevent Baku from triggering if they're in your opening hand. Drakkisath is instead affecting the cards in the deck, too? Should test Prince Liam, Holy Wrath, and/or Hemet Jungle Hunter in this fight.

Kybxd commented 6 years ago

Sorry for mistake. Even cards must be drawn in your starting hand to trigger Baku when fighting Drakkisath. And Liam, Holy Wrath and Hemet resolves correctly (only transform cards costing 1 originally/ deal damage equal to original cost /only destroy cards costing 3 or less originally).

troggnostupidhs commented 6 years ago

https://playhearthstone.com/en-us/blog/21943493/hearthstone-update-11-4-july-10-the-boomsday-project-pre-purchase

Resolved an issue where Genn Greymane would not trigger in an even deck if Clockwork Giant was in the opening hand.

Kybxd commented 6 years ago

Half fixed. Baku still checks the current cost. qq 20180712183355

troggnostupidhs commented 5 years ago

Still happens

Blackrock Mountain, General Drakkistath

Get Tinyfin in your opening hand AAEBAaToAgaiCZ4Qt2y8vQLR0wKe+AIMjwnZDesP7Q+dFd7EAuPLAt3TAofoArLpAvb9AuOGAwA=

Jetz72 commented 4 years ago

Still affects Baku: https://www.reddit.com/r/hearthstone/comments/fwp955/baku_doesnt_work_with_demon_hunter_if_you_have_a/

Baku Doesn't Work with Demon Hunter if you have a 0-Mana Eye Beam In Your Opening Hand

I'm playing Odd Demon Hunter as well and I can confirm this.

Can confirm