Current Issues

[Heiss]

date 1.8. v1.0.12

• [ ] again labels bugged -.- multiple labels created sometimes.
  • [ ] because of a bug, tasks could be have the same labeltitle duplicated, so my current approach does not fix this
• [x] add a dedup labels command, so if it goes south next time, it can be fixed manually
• [ ] insufficient permissions not communicated to users
  • permissions are not checked previously, so if there are missing permissions, it is in console... see #6
  • preparations made in 31eee7f066f2729f35c0c49f2e952e99102df26a
  • todos added for further implementations
• [ ] preparation for multi-user usage
  • currently there is no date, where last sync was happened
  • with such a field, we can find out, if a task was newly created or removed. see #12
  • with the cache there is also a better way to handle changes, see #14
• [x] Command Reset instance cannot handle tasks without an id, so it fails, if there are mixed tasks, which are (not) synced. f6f28843b283504025c01c4c3bb4f83e2b06d448
• [x] there is a timerace between changes and dataview indexing, which results in outdated results in request dbf750745983864aa0daf7cf3b7f263917702a08

date 8.8. v1.0.14

• [x] skip tasks, if the updated value is the same, otherwise unneeded update requests are done - was already there
• [x] removing tasks in vikunja, if they are not present in obsidian does not work e552cc1ffafd81d1ce8a6881a85d0c12f4f15384
  • remove the correspondig setting, because with the cache we now know what task was deleted since last time, because a task is only in cache, if it got a taskId, so we can keep track
• [x] plugin does not get all tasks over the serverside limit 4cf8876629a8fd067ce2dc0216d027c7be5feda9
  • because of performance and request limits, it needs requests in batches.
• [x] at first sync, it creates some tasks multiple times in vault, which is clutter and maybe something is broken
  • maybe dataview returns the same task multiple times, if it has subpoints or subtasks?
• [x] add command to reindex the cache. a918fb3f561b2b07b29182ed2b81e7ff6bef0553
  • This will use the last modified date as updated field. But this is better then broken cache.

date 9.8. v1.0.16

• [x] buckets in vikunja are not respected, so if syncing, it overwrites the current bucket, mostly back to default one
  • so kanban etc. cannot be used
  • sync should overwrite task title, status, etc. but not bucket.
• [x] add a link to obsidian file in task description
  • there is an option now to enable it, but it is not currently supported, see https://github.com/go-vikunja/vikunja/issues/306

date 14.8. v.1.0.17

• [x] update on cursor movement does not work, if there is no id in the line found
  • it should create a new task and work exactly the same as sync, but for only one task
• [ ] sync of a preexisting vault does take some minutes
  • would be better with an option only to sync not completed tasks to vikunja instead of all

date 20.8. v.1.0.20

• [ ] add a notification, if cors configuration is wrong at serverside, see https://github.com/Heiss/obsidian-vikunja-plugin/issues/16#issuecomment-2295998460
• [x] if bucket got changed on vikunja, but there is a status change in vault, the bucket info gets lost
• [ ] add setup guide in readme and maybe a modal for first setup https://github.com/Heiss/obsidian-vikunja-plugin/issues/17#issue-2478274945

[3m0W33D]

Hi so after playing with it on my end I got some really weird workings on it. Let me give a few scenarios that better explain this weird behaviour I got.

Scenario 1:

1. Create Task A on Vikunja/Obsidian
2. Run Sync in Obsidian Task A added to Obsidian/Vikunja
3. Mark Task A as done on Vikunja
4. Run Sync again on Obsidian
5. Task A is shown to have completed in Obsidian

Scenario 2:

1. Create Task A and B on Vikunja/Obsidian
2. Run Sync in Obsidian Task A and B added to Obsidian/Vikunja
3. Mark Task A as done on Vikunja
4. Run Sync again on Obsidian
5. Task A becomes marked as not done on Vikunja

Scenario 3:

1. Create Task A and B on Vikunja/Obsidian
2. Run Sync in Obsidian Task A and B added to Obsidian/Vikunja
3. Mark Task A as done on Obsidian
4. Run Sync again on Obsidian
5. Task A becomes marked as done on Vikunja

Scenario 4:

1. Create Task A on Vikunja/Obsidian
2. Run Sync in Obsidian Task A and B added to Obsidian/Vikunja
3. Close Obsidan and Reopen(I have the sync on startup enabled)
4. Mark Task A as done on Vikunja
5. Run Sync again on Obsidian
6. Task A becomes marked as not done on Vikunja

While the caching works, I realise it only works for the latest task added and only one task can be added. Any more than that apparently it would prioritize obsidian and overwrite Vikunja which is weird. Save cache to disk frequency is set to 1 for the above scenario Also my local system, is set to same region as Vikunja (so the time should be in sync) System OS: Windows I cant seem to find a way for my Vikunja to sync changes down to obsidian when I haven't touch obsidian note at all(internally or externally). Hope my testing helps! Cheers!

[Heiss]

Okay after some investigations, i found a lot of errors. :) So, i releasing now a new version, which fixes issues in:

• sync with caching, should now handle your scenarios correctly @3m0W33D
• update on startUp is mostly the same as sync now
• sync task status on checkbox click
• save cache to disk asap after changes were made, but it can be configured when performance is an issue, so in settings you can switch between "ASAP" or "INTERVAL" for writing cache to disk
• update task on line change works now with cache

Most of your described issues comes from a problem with dataview and it's own index, which must be rebuilt after task changes, but it does not take effect immediatily, so my plugin needs to wait for this. In the meantime the plugin pulls tasks from vikunja and starts syncing ASAP after dataview index-rebuild is done.

[3m0W33D]

Thanks for helping to investigate, I checked notice another new weird corner case for me.

Scenario 5:

• Create Task A and B on Vikunja/Obsidian
• Run Sync in Obsidian, Task A and B added to Obsidian/Vikunja
• Mark Task A as done on Vikunja
• Run Sync again on Obsidian
• Task A becomes marked as done in Obsidian (yay! this works!)
• Mark Task B as done on Vikunja
• Run Sync again on Obsidian
• Task B becomes marked as not done in Vikunja

Scenario 6:

• Create Task A and B on Vikunja/Obsidian
• Run Sync in Obsidian, Task A and B added to Obsidian/Vikunja
• Mark Task A and B as done on Vikunja
• Run Sync again on Obsidian
• Task A and B becomes marked as done in Obsidian (yay! this works!)

I am not too clear but it seems that if tasks are done sequentially, after the first update of the markdown in obsidian, it will treat obsidian as the more updated one and overwrite any updates from vikunja. (This is just my theory)

[Heiss]

I cannot reproduce your scenario 5 on my side. If you want faster status sync, use the option in settings to do so. It is faster then a complete sync. :) I found an issue with getting all tasks from vikunja, but should now be fixed. Maybe this was the reason for your scenario?

edit: Okay, i found an issue, what could result in your scenario 5. I am trying to fix it ASAP.

edit2: should be fixed by now, but i will wait with releasing a new version. I want to fix the issue with duplicated labels once and for all.

[Heiss]

I pushed a new version, but had no time to fix duplicated labels.

[3m0W33D]

Weird I am still getting the same result as in this post

Thanks for helping to investigate, I checked notice another new weird corner case for me.

Scenario 5:

• Create Task A and B on Vikunja/Obsidian
• Run Sync in Obsidian, Task A and B added to Obsidian/Vikunja
• Mark Task A as done on Vikunja
• Run Sync again on Obsidian
• Task A becomes marked as done in Obsidian (yay! this works!)
• Mark Task B as done on Vikunja
• Run Sync again on Obsidian
• Task B becomes marked as not done in Vikunja

Scenario 6:

• Create Task A and B on Vikunja/Obsidian
• Run Sync in Obsidian, Task A and B added to Obsidian/Vikunja
• Mark Task A and B as done on Vikunja
• Run Sync again on Obsidian
• Task A and B becomes marked as done in Obsidian (yay! this works!)

I am not too clear but it seems that if tasks are done sequentially, after the first update of the markdown in obsidian, it will treat obsidian as the more updated one and overwrite any updates from vikunja. (This is just my theory)