Ret Paladin - incorrect order recommended

PettyPeterPettigrew commented 1 year ago

Before You Begin

[X] I confirm that I have downloaded the latest version of the addon.
[X] I am not playing on a private server.
[X] I checked for an existing, open ticket for this issue and was not able to find one.
[X] I edited the title of this issue (above) so that it describes the issue I am reporting.
[X] I am reporting an issue with the default priority included with the specialization (imported or edited priorities are not supported).

WoW Version

Retail (Dragonflight)

Describe the Issue

Hello

Ret is super close to perfect there are just two issues

1) We have a talent called Exorcism now (which will be the go to talent in dungeons). The talent spreads exorcism to all enemies in our consecration meaning correct order to cast would be Consecration > Exorcism, but the addon is recommending the opposite therefore exorcism is not spreading to additional enemies.

How to Reproduce

Play Ret
Chose Exorcism
Gather enemies and click Exorcism then Consecration (addon recommended)
See that additional enemies don't have the Exorcism DOT

Talent Loadout

BYEAwtJ2KpR8WbGzhz/jy2AP8AAAAAAAEAiSaJJSOAAppkwBalAAAAAAAIEJJplEkQBAloEA

Snapshot

fg

Raidbots Sim Report (Link)

No response

Additional Information

No response

Contact Information

No response

Hekili commented 1 year ago

Snapshots are required for recommendations tickets.

PettyPeterPettigrew commented 1 year ago

Retribution; Primary - Exorcism(0.00), Consecration(1.38), Crusader Strike(2.76)

royalplisk1 commented 1 year ago

I just did a +15 as Ret and final reckoning and divine toll were not recommended at all.

build: v10.0.0-05 level: 60 (60) class: PALADIN spec: retribution

talents: art_of_war ashes_to_ashes = 2/2 ashes_to_dust = 1/1 aspiration_of_divinity = 2/2 auras_of_swift_vengeance = 1/1 avenging_wrath = 1/1 blade_of_justice = 1/1 blade_of_wrath = 1/1 blessing_of_freedom = 1/1 blessing_of_sacrifice = 1/1 blinding_light = 1/1 cavalier = 1/1 cleanse_toxins = 1/1 consecrated_blade = 1/1 crusade = 1/1 divine_purpose = 1/1 divine_steed = 1/1 divine_storm = 1/1 empyrean_power = 1/1 exorcism = 1/1 final_reckoning = 1/1 fist_of_justice = 2/2 greater_judgment = 1/1 hallowed_ground = 1/1 hammer_of_wrath = 1/1 healing_hands = 1/1 highlords_judgment = 1/2 holy_aegis = 2/2 holy_blade = 1/1 holy_crusader = 1/1 improved_crusader_strike = 1/1 incandescence = 1/1 lay_on_hands = 1/1 of_dusk_and_dawn = 1/1 rebuke = 1/1 recompense = 1/1 sanctification = 1/1 sanctify = 1/1 seal_of_order = 1/1 seal_of_reprisal = 2/2 seasoned_warhorse = 1/1 shield_of_vengeance = 1/1 tempest_of_the_lightbringer = 1/1 unbreakable_spirit = 1/1 virtuous_command = 2/2 wake_of_ashes = 1/1 zeal = 1/1

pvptalents: none

covenant: kyrian

conduits: condensed_anima_sphere = 13 divine_call = 13 lights_barding = 13 ringing_clarity = 13 shielding_words = 13 truths_wake = 13

soulbinds: [forgelite_prime_mikanikos] brons_call_to_action = 1 effusive_anima_accelerator = 1 forgelite_filter = 1 hammer_of_genesis = 1 resilient_plumage = 1 soulglow_spectrometer = 1

sets: enforcers_stun_grenade = 1 ring_of_collapsing_futures = 1 soleahs_secret_technique = 1

gear: enforcers_stun_grenade = 1 luminous_chevaliers_casque = 1 luminous_chevaliers_epaulettes = 1 luminous_chevaliers_gauntlets = 1 luminous_chevaliers_plackart = 1 mountebanks_colorful_cloak = 1 ornately_engraved_amplifier = 1 overseers_final_word = 1 pyroclastic_greatboots = 1 ring_of_collapsing_futures = 1 shadowghast_greaves = 1 shadowghast_waistguard = 1 signet_of_collapsing_stars = 1 soleahs_secret_technique = 1 vambraces_of_verification = 1

legendaries: divine_resonance = 1 tempest_of_the_lightbringer = 1

itemIDs: 110017, 110051, 142173, 168972, 169064, 171416, 171418, 185813, 185815, 185842, 188928, 188929, 188932, 188933, 190958

settings: aoe = 3 buffPadding = 0 combatRefresh = 0.1 custom1Name = Custom 1 custom2Name = Custom 2 cycle = false cycle_min = 6 damage = true damageDots = false damageExpiration = 8 damageOnScreen = true damagePets = false damageRange = 0 debuffPadding = 0 enabled = true enhancedRecheck = false gcdSync = true maxTime = 10 nameplateRange = 8 nameplates = true noFeignedCooldown = false package = Retribution petbased = false potion = spectral_strength regularRefresh = 0.5 throttleRefresh = false throttleTime = false check_wake_range = false

toggles: cooldowns = false custom1 = false custom2 = false defensives = false essences = true interrupts = false mode = automatic potions = false

keybinds: arcane_torrent = CS2 [06] blade_of_justice = 3 [01] blessing_of_freedom = SX [06], 4 [10] blessing_of_protection = Z [05], C1 [09], 5 [10] blessing_of_sacrifice = C1 [02], R [10] blinding_light = C3 [05] cleanse_toxins = 3 [02], C [05] consecration = 5 [01] crusade = R [02], S3 [06], 2 [09] crusader_strike = 1 [01] divine_shield = Q [01], 1 [10] divine_steed = X [01], F [10] divine_storm = S2 [06] divine_toll = S4 [06], X [09] exorcism = SF [06] final_reckoning = SE [06], 4 [09] flash_of_light = S1 [06] gladiators_medallion = SR [06] hammer_of_justice = C1 [01], 3 [09] hammer_of_wrath = E [01] hand_of_hindrance = 4 [02], M3 [05] hand_of_reckoning = SM3 [05], Q [10] healthstone = C5 [05] intercession = S5 [06] judgment = 2 [01] lay_on_hands = SZ [05], R [09], 3 [10] potion = F [02] rebuke = C2 [01], Q [09] shield_of_vengeance = SQ [06], 2 [10] templars_verdict = 4 [01] wake_of_ashes = R [01], C2 [09] word_of_glory = F [01]

warnings: none

royalplisk1 commented 1 year ago

Actually, I think when I casted Final (without recommendation) it did recommend Divine Toll right after.

crashedorange commented 1 year ago

Hi, I don't have anything to contribute in coding, buuuuuuut I have discovered something that should work until the expansion is fully released...... do not have divine toll in the talent tree as that seems to be clashing with as that seems to be what is causing the duplicate suggetion in the addon.

Hekili commented 1 year ago

@royalplisk1 That still is not a snapshot, but you don't have your cooldowns toggle enabled.

toggles: cooldowns = false

@crashedorange I do not understand what you're saying, but if you are seeing incorrect recommendations, provide a snapshot and clear, specific details.

royalplisk1 commented 1 year ago

Per the previous poster - thanks cooldowns somehow turned off. Fixed that. Figured out what a snapshot is below - I believe that Final Reckoning should be within the first 8 spells for sure (and it just isn't coming up for me and neither is Divine Toll until I click Final Reckoning). I wonder if it has something to do with it being a target ground ability that I have macro'd to a cast on self - that being said it has come up in the past. Appreciate the support and this addon.

Retribution; Primary - Blade of Justice(0.00), Judgment(1.15), Crusader Strike(2.30), Crusade(2.30), Templar's Verdict(3.45), Hammer of Wrath(4.60), Templar's Verdict(5.75), Wake of Ashes(6.90)

Purehotty commented 1 year ago

I believe what the OP is trying to say is that it currently puts Exorcism before Consecration, which should be reversed as with the new talent when Consecration is down and you Exorcism a target inside of it the DOT effect is spread to other enemies also inside the Consecration which is a huge DPS increase on AOE packs. I was wondering the same how it could be possible to make sure Consecration is down before suggesting to Exorcism.

Jacii1121 commented 1 year ago

Snapshot that hopefully supports the ticket. Don't think the simc apl supports this however.

petewoolley commented 1 year ago

Agreed on the Exorcism point, shouldn't be prioritised ahead of consecrate unless single target.

PettyPeterPettigrew commented 1 year ago

Snapshot that hopefully supports the ticket. Don't think the simc apl supports this however. Thanks for posting. I've followed the instructions to create my own but its just giving me the thing I posted. Maybe because I'm not on level 60 dunno

Hekili commented 1 year ago

Snapshot that hopefully supports the ticket. Don't think the simc apl supports this however. Thanks for posting. I've followed the instructions to create my own but its just giving me the thing I posted. Maybe because I'm not on level 60 dunno

You have to CTRL+A in the textbox to select all the text, including the hidden text. Otherwise, you're just copying the first line.

Hekili commented 1 year ago

This morning's release will shift Exorcism vs. Consecration based on target counts, sort of. Sims will eventually shake out how long you'd hold Exorcism for Consecrate without losing DPS.

PettyPeterPettigrew commented 1 year ago

This morning's release will shift Exorcism vs. Consecration based on target counts, sort of. Sims will eventually shake out how long you'd hold Exorcism for Consecrate without losing DPS.

Thanks!

petewoolley commented 1 year ago

Noice.

Hekili / hekili