Closed GHSTSHP closed 1 year ago
benkimball
commented
1 year ago In the last few days I have also noticed that following Hekili recommendations no longer triggers Blessing of Dawn. It maintains Blessing of Dusk, but it won't build to 5 holy power.
Hekili
commented
1 year ago Thanks for adding to the thread. Could you post a snapshot to Pastebin where a HoPo spender is recommended without reaching 5 HoPo when playing as Protection. I'm assuming this is the recent priority update that uses SotR more, but I'd like confirmation before I turn that logic off if ODTD is not talented.
Hekili
commented
1 year ago For the sake of time, I'll go ahead and make adjustments based on my own assumptions and we'll see how it goes.
benkimball
commented
1 year ago Here's a snapshot where Hekili is recommending SotR when I have 3 HoPo, blessing of the dusk is active, and blessing of the dawn is not active. https://pastebin.com/FJSyXQPj
And here's a quick sim of my character: https://www.raidbots.com/simbot/report/tcqCAS4hwy9C1L4ffKopXj
Hope they help!
Before You Begin
Describe the Issue
I'm curious if it's possible to add blessing of dawn and dusk to the simc priority. Admittedly, I am not smart enough to edit that data in any meaningful or accurate way.
Thank you!
How to Reproduce
I don't see the spell in the priority list and the default priority never seems to want me to bank five holy power.
Snapshot (Link)
Protection Paladin; Interrupts - N/A build: v10.0.5-1.0.20 level: 70 (70) class: PALADIN spec: protection talents: ardent_defender = 1/1 aspiration_of_divinity = 2/2 auras_of_the_resolute = 1/1 avengers_shield = 1/1 avenging_wrath = 1/1 avenging_wrath_might = 1/1 bastion_of_light = 1/1 blessed_hammer = 1/1 blessing_of_freedom = 1/1 blessing_of_protection = 1/1 blessing_of_sacrifice = 1/1 bulwark_of_order = 2/2 bulwark_of_righteous_fury = 1/1 cavalier = 1/1 consecration_in_flame = 1/1 crusaders_judgment = 1/1 crusaders_resolve = 1/1 divine_resonance = 1/1 divine_steed = 1/1 divine_toll = 1/1 eye_of_tyr = 1/1 ferren_marcuss_fervor = 2/2 fist_of_justice = 2/2 golden_path = 1/1 grand_crusader = 1/1 greater_judgment = 1/1 guardian_of_ancient_kings = 1/1 hallowed_ground = 1/1 hammer_of_wrath = 1/1 holy_aegis = 2/2 holy_shield = 1/1 incandescence = 1/1 judgment_of_light = 1/1 lay_on_hands = 1/1 moment_of_glory = 1/1 of_dusk_and_dawn = 1/1 rebuke = 1/1 redoubt = 1/1 relentless_inquisitor = 1/1 righteous_protector = 2/2 sacrifice_of_the_just = 1/1 sanctified_wrath = 1/1 seal_of_might = 2/2 seal_of_order = 1/1 seal_of_reprisal = 1/2 seal_of_the_crusader = 2/2 seasoned_warhorse = 1/1 shining_light = 1/1 soaring_shield = 1/1 strength_of_conviction = 2/2 tyrs_enforcer = 2/2 unbreakable_spirit = 1/1 zealots_paragon = 1/1 pvptalents: none covenant: none conduits: none soulbinds: [] sets: decoration_of_flame = 1 tier29 = 4 gear: alacritous_alchemist_stone = 1 broodsworn_legionnaires_pavise = 1 decoration_of_flame = 1 elemental_lariat = 1 frostfire_legguards_of_preparation = 1 goldsteel_bindings = 1 illusion_breakers_waistguard = 1 seal_of_filial_duty = 1 shield = 1 signet_of_titanic_insight = 1 strike_twice = 1 tabard_of_the_lightbringer = 1 tier29 = 4 undisputed_champions_shirt = 1 valkyra_protector_greatboots = 1 vibrant_wildercloth_shawl = 1 virtuous_silver_breastplate = 1 virtuous_silver_gauntlets = 1 virtuous_silver_heaume = 1 virtuous_silver_pauldrons = 1 legendaries: none itemIDs: 109878, 136772, 190523, 191492, 192999, 193001, 193511, 193650, 193700, 194299, 195520, 195526, 200414, 200416, 200417, 200419, 52252, 98082 settings: aoe = 2 buffPadding = 0 combatRefresh = 0.1 custom1Name = Custom 1 custom2Name = Custom 2 cycle = false cycle_min = 6 damage = true damageDots = false damageExpiration = 8 damageOnScreen = true damagePets = false damageRange = 0 debuffPadding = 0 enabled = true enhancedRecheck = false gcdSync = true maxTime = 10 nameplateRange = 8 nameplates = true noFeignedCooldown = false package = Protection Paladin petbased = false potion = phantom_fire regularRefresh = 0.5 throttleRefresh = false throttleTime = false ds_damage = 100 goak_damage = 50 wog_health = 0 toggles: cooldowns = true custom1 = false custom2 = false defensives = false essences = true [overridden] interrupts = true [separate] mode = automatic potions = false keybinds: ardent_defender = N3 [01] avengers_shield = R [05] avenging_wrath = N1 [05] bastion_of_light = N4 [05] blessed_hammer = T [05] blessing_of_freedom = N5 [06] blessing_of_protection = N+ [01] blessing_of_sacrifice = N8 [06] cleanse_toxins = 6 [06] consecration = Q [05] decoration_of_flame = S [03] divine_shield = N0 [05] divine_steed = N2 [06] divine_toll = 9 [06] eye_of_tyr = 8 [06] flash_of_light = 1 [01] guardian_of_ancient_kings = N6 [01] hammer_of_justice = 7 [06] hammer_of_wrath = E [05] hand_of_reckoning = A [03] healthstone = 2 [01] intercession = N- [06] judgment = W [05] lay_on_hands = N7 [05] moment_of_glory = N9 [01] rebuke = 0 [06] shield_of_the_righteous = F [03] will_to_survive = 5 [01] word_of_glory = D [03] warnings: [#1] Auditor removed an aura 383843 from Creature-0-4232-2444-2632-193385-000002BA2E after exiting combat. [#2] Auditor removed an aura 31935 from Creature-0-4232-2444-2632-193385-000002BA2E after exiting combat. [#3] Auditor removed an aura 385723 from Creature-0-4232-2444-2632-193385-000002BA2E after exiting combat. [#4] Auditor removed an aura 196941 from Creature-0-4232-2444-2632-193385-000002BA2E after exiting combat. [#5] Auditor removed an aura 197277 from Creature-0-4232-2444-2632-193385-000002BA2E after exiting combat. [#6] Auditor removed an aura 383843 from Creature-0-4232-2444-2632-193145-000002BD30 after exiting combat. [#7] Auditor removed an aura 31935 from Creature-0-4232-2444-2632-193145-000002BD30 after exiting combat. [#8] Auditor removed an aura 196941 from Creature-0-4232-2444-2632-193145-000002BD30 after exiting combat. [#9] Auditor removed an aura 197277 from Creature-0-4232-2444-2632-193145-000002BD30 after exiting combat. [#10] Auditor removed an aura 383843 from Creature-0-4232-2444-2632-193394-000002BAED after exiting combat. [#11] Auditor removed an aura 31935 from Creature-0-4232-2444-2632-193394-000002BAED after exiting combat. [#12] Auditor removed an aura 383843 from Creature-0-4232-2444-2632-194570-000082BDEC after exiting combat. [#13] Auditor removed an aura 383843 from Creature-0-4232-2444-2632-194570-000002BDEC after exiting combat. [#14] Auditor removed an aura 385723 from Creature-0-4232-2444-2632-194570-000002BDEC after exiting combat. [#15] Auditor removed an aura 204301 from Creature-0-4232-2444-2632-194570-000082BDEC after exiting combat. [#16] Auditor removed an aura 204301 from Creature-0-4232-2444-2632-194570-000002BDEC after exiting combat. [#17] Auditor removed an aura 196941 from Creature-0-4232-2444-2632-194570-000002BDEC after exiting combat. [#18] Auditor removed an aura 197277 from Creature-0-4232-2444-2632-194570-000002BDEC after exiting combat. [#19] Auditor removed an aura 204242 from Creature-0-4232-2444-2632-191553-000282BBE6 after exiting combat. [#20] Auditor removed an aura 204242 from Creature-0-4232-2444-2632-194570-000082BDEC after exiting combat. [#21] Auditor removed an aura 204242 from Creature-0-4232-2444-2632-194570-000002BDEC after exiting combat. [#22] Auditor removed an aura 383843 from Creature-0-4232-2444-2632-191553-000102BBE6 after exiting combat. [#23] Auditor removed an aura 196941 from Creature-0-4232-2444-2632-191553-000102BBE6 after exiting combat. [#24] Auditor removed an aura 197277 from Creature-0-4232-2444-2632-191553-000102BBE6 after exiting combat. [#25] Auditor removed an aura 383843 from Creature-0-4232-2444-2632-194624-000002BDFC after exiting combat. [#26] Auditor removed an aura 196941 from Creature-0-4232-2444-2632-194624-000002BDFC after exiting combat. [#27] Auditor removed an aura 197277 from Creature-0-4232-2444-2632-194624-000002BDFC after exiting combat. [#28] Auditor removed an aura 204242 from Creature-0-4232-2444-2632-195712-000002413A after exiting combat. [#29] Auditor removed an aura 204242 from Creature-0-4232-2444-2632-195712-00000240E7 after exiting combat. [#30] Auditor removed an aura 196941 from Creature-0-4232-2444-2632-195712-00000240E7 after exiting combat. [#31] Auditor removed an aura 196941 from Creature-0-4232-2444-2632-195712-000002413A after exiting combat. [#32] Auditor removed an aura 197277 from Creature-0-4232-2444-2632-195712-00000240E7 after exiting combat. [#33] Auditor removed an aura 197277 from Creature-0-4232-2444-2632-195712-000002413A after exiting combat. [#34] Auditor removed an aura 204301 from Creature-0-4232-2444-2632-195712-000002413A after exiting combat. targets: nameplate2 - 0 - Creature-0-4232-2444-2632-195762-000002C418 - 300.00 - 0 - Mossy Gulper player_buffs: 465 - devotion_aura - 1 - 3600.00 368901 - cliffside_wylderdrake - 1 - 3600.00 383169 - lucky_horseshoe - 1 - 3600.00 186406 - sign_of_the_critter - 1 - 3600.00 384235 - vantus_rune_broodkeeper_diurna - 1 - 297685.53 225788 - sign_of_the_emissary - 1 - 3600.00 386984 - wind_friend - 1 - 1640.66 297871 - *anglers_water_striders - 1 - 3600.00 player_debuffs: target_auras: target does not exist New Recommendations for [ Interrupts ] requested at 22:18:33 ( 685575.99 ); using built-in ( Protection Paladin ) priority. START OF NEW DISPLAY: Interrupts RECOMMENDATION #1 ( Offset: 0.00, GCD: 0.00, Casting: 0.00 ). Resources: holy_power[ 0.00 / 5.00 ], mana[ 50000.00 / 50000.00 ] Checking if I'm casting ( No ) and if it is a channel ( No ). No whitelist. Processing precombat action list [ Protection Paladin - precombat ]. Current recommendation was NO ACTION at +10.00s. 1. devotion_aura ( precombat - 1 ) - ability disabled ( display ) Time spent on this action: 0.05ms TimeData:Protection Paladin-precombat-1:devotion_aura:0.05:Ability Known, Enabled(0.05) 2. lights_judgment ( precombat - 2 ) - ability unknown Time spent on this action: 0.30ms TimeData:Protection Paladin-precombat-2:lights_judgment:0.30:Ability Known, Enabled(0.30) 3. arcane_torrent ( precombat - 3 ) - ability unknown Time spent on this action: 0.07ms TimeData:Protection Paladin-precombat-3:arcane_torrent:0.07:Ability Known, Enabled(0.07) 4. consecration ( precombat - 4 ) - ability disabled ( display ) Time spent on this action: 0.03ms TimeData:Protection Paladin-precombat-4:consecration:0.03:Ability Known, Enabled(0.03) Exiting precombat with recommendation of NO ACTION at +10.00s. Completed precombat action list [ Protection Paladin - precombat ]. Processing default action list [ Protection Paladin - default ]. Current recommendation was NO ACTION at +10.00s. 5. rebuke ( default - 1 ) The action is not ready ( 3600.00 ) before our maximum delay window ( 10.00 ) for this query. Time spent on this action: 0.03ms TimeData:Protection Paladin-default-1:rebuke:0.03:Ability Known, Enabled(0.03) 6. cleanse_toxins ( default - 2 ) - talent [ cleanse_toxins ] missing Time spent on this action: 0.03ms TimeData:Protection Paladin-default-2:cleanse_toxins:0.03:Ability Known, Enabled(0.03) 7. call_action_list:cooldowns ( default - 3 ) There is no criteria for cooldowns. Action list (cooldowns) was found. + cooldowns Current recommendation was NO ACTION at +10.00s. 8. seraphim ( cooldowns - 1 ) - talent [ seraphim ] missing Time spent on this action: 0.03ms TimeData:Protection Paladin-cooldowns-1:seraphim:0.03:Ability Known, Enabled(0.03) 9. avenging_wrath ( cooldowns - 2 ) - ability disabled ( display ) Time spent on this action: 0.07ms TimeData:Protection Paladin-cooldowns-2:avenging_wrath:0.07:Ability Known, Enabled(0.07) 10. avenging_wrath ( cooldowns - 3 ) - ability disabled ( display ) Time spent on this action: 0.07ms TimeData:Protection Paladin-cooldowns-3:avenging_wrath:0.07:Ability Known, Enabled(0.07) 11. potion ( cooldowns - 4 ) - ability disabled ( toggle a ) Time spent on this action: 0.66ms TimeData:Protection Paladin-cooldowns-4:potion:0.66:Ability Known, Enabled(0.66) 12. moment_of_glory ( cooldowns - 5 ) - ability disabled ( display ) Time spent on this action: 0.07ms TimeData:Protection Paladin-cooldowns-5:moment_of_glory:0.07:Ability Known, Enabled(0.07) 13. holy_avenger ( cooldowns - 6 ) - talent [ holy_avenger ] missing Time spent on this action: 0.06ms TimeData:Protection Paladin-cooldowns-6:holy_avenger:0.06:Ability Known, Enabled(0.06) 14. bastion_of_light ( cooldowns - 7 ) - ability disabled ( display ) Time spent on this action: 0.07ms TimeData:Protection Paladin-cooldowns-7:bastion_of_light:0.07:Ability Known, Enabled(0.07) Exiting cooldowns with recommendation of NO ACTION at +10.00s. Returned from list (cooldowns), current recommendation is NO ACTION (+10.00). - cooldowns 15. call_action_list:mitigation ( default - 4 ) There is no criteria for mitigation. Action list (mitigation) was found. + mitigation Current recommendation was NO ACTION at +10.00s. 16. shield_of_the_righteous ( mitigation - 1 ) - ability disabled ( display ) Time spent on this action: 0.03ms TimeData:Protection Paladin-mitigation-1:shield_of_the_righteous:0.03:Ability Known, Enabled(0.03) 17. word_of_glory ( mitigation - 2 ) - ability disabled ( display ) Time spent on this action: 0.03ms TimeData:Protection Paladin-mitigation-2:word_of_glory:0.03:Ability Known, Enabled(0.03) 18. guardian_of_ancient_kings ( mitigation - 3 ) - ability disabled ( toggle a ) Time spent on this action: 0.03ms TimeData:Protection Paladin-mitigation-3:guardian_of_ancient_kings:0.03:Ability Known, Enabled(0.03) 19. divine_shield ( mitigation - 4 ) - ability disabled ( toggle a ) Time spent on this action: 0.03ms TimeData:Protection Paladin-mitigation-4:divine_shield:0.03:Ability Known, Enabled(0.03) 20. ardent_defender ( mitigation - 5 ) - ability disabled ( toggle a ) Time spent on this action: 0.03ms TimeData:Protection Paladin-mitigation-5:ardent_defender:0.03:Ability Known, Enabled(0.03) 21. lay_on_hands ( mitigation - 6 ) - ability disabled ( toggle a ) Time spent on this action: 0.03ms TimeData:Protection Paladin-mitigation-6:lay_on_hands:0.03:Ability Known, Enabled(0.03) Exiting mitigation with recommendation of NO ACTION at +10.00s. Returned from list (mitigation), current recommendation is NO ACTION (+10.00). - mitigation 22. call_action_list:trinkets ( default - 5 ) There is no criteria for trinkets. Action list (trinkets) was found. + trinkets Current recommendation was NO ACTION at +10.00s. 23. variable ( trinkets - 1 ) - variable.trinket_1_sync will check this script entry ( Protection Paladin:trinkets:1 ) 1 Time spent on this action: 0.04ms TimeData:Protection Paladin-trinkets-1:variable:0.04:Ability Known, Enabled(0.02):Post-TTR and Essential(0.02) 24. variable ( trinkets - 2 ) - variable.trinket_2_sync will check this script entry ( Protection Paladin:trinkets:2 ) 1 Time spent on this action: 0.03ms TimeData:Protection Paladin-trinkets-2:variable:0.03:Ability Known, Enabled(0.02):Post-TTR and Essential(0.01) 25. variable ( trinkets - 3 ) - variable.trinket_priority will check this script entry ( Protection Paladin:trinkets:3 ) 2 Time spent on this action: 0.03ms TimeData:Protection Paladin-trinkets-3:variable:0.03:Ability Known, Enabled(0.02):Post-TTR and Essential(0.01) 26. variable ( trinkets - 4 ) - variable.trinket_1_buffs will check this script entry ( Protection Paladin:trinkets:4 ) trinket.t1.has_use_buff[false] | trinket.t1.has_use_buff[false] | trinket.t1.has_use_buff[false] | trinket.t1.has_use_buff[false] | trinket.t1.has_use_buff[false] Time spent on this action: 0.03ms TimeData:Protection Paladin-trinkets-4:variable:0.03:Ability Known, Enabled(0.02):Post-TTR and Essential(0.01) 27. variable ( trinkets - 5 ) - variable.trinket_2_buffs will check this script entry ( Protection Paladin:trinkets:5 ) trinket.t2.has_use_buff[false] | trinket.t2.has_use_buff[false] | trinket.t2.has_use_buff[false] | trinket.t2.has_use_buff[false] | trinket.t2.has_use_buff[false] Time spent on this action: 0.03ms TimeData:Protection Paladin-trinkets-5:variable:0.03:Ability Known, Enabled(0.02):Post-TTR and Essential(0.01) Bypassing 'trinket1' action because the equipped trinket #1 is not usable. 28. trinket1 ( trinkets - 6 ) Time spent on this action: 0.03ms TimeData:Protection Paladin-trinkets-6:trinket1:0.03:Ability Known, Enabled(0.03) Substituting decoration_of_flame for Trinket #2 action; it is otherwise not included in the priority. 29. decoration_of_flame ( trinkets - 7 ) - ability disabled ( display ) Time spent on this action: 0.31ms TimeData:Protection Paladin-trinkets-7:decoration_of_flame:0.31:Ability Known, Enabled(0.31) Bypassing 'trinket1' action because the equipped trinket #1 is not usable. 30. trinket1 ( trinkets - 8 ) Time spent on this action: 0.03ms TimeData:Protection Paladin-trinkets-8:trinket1:0.03:Ability Known, Enabled(0.03) Substituting decoration_of_flame for Trinket #2 action; it is otherwise not included in the priority. 31. decoration_of_flame ( trinkets - 9 ) - ability disabled ( display ) Time spent on this action: 0.28ms TimeData:Protection Paladin-trinkets-9:decoration_of_flame:0.28:Ability Known, Enabled(0.28) 32. use_items ( trinkets - 10 ) There is no criteria for Use Items. + trinkets, items Current recommendation was NO ACTION at +10.00s. Exiting items with recommendation of NO ACTION at +10.00s. Returned from Use Items; current recommendation is NO ACTION (+10.00). - items Exiting trinkets with recommendation of NO ACTION at +10.00s. Returned from list (trinkets), current recommendation is NO ACTION (+10.00). - trinkets 33. call_action_list:standard ( default - 6 ) There is no criteria for standard. Action list (standard) was found. + standard Current recommendation was NO ACTION at +10.00s. 34. shield_of_the_righteous ( standard - 1 ) - ability disabled ( display ) Time spent on this action: 0.03ms TimeData:Protection Paladin-standard-1:shield_of_the_righteous:0.03:Ability Known, Enabled(0.03) 35. shield_of_the_righteous ( standard - 2 ) - ability disabled ( display ) Time spent on this action: 0.03ms TimeData:Protection Paladin-standard-2:shield_of_the_righteous:0.03:Ability Known, Enabled(0.03) 36. avengers_shield ( standard - 3 ) - ability disabled ( display ) Time spent on this action: 0.03ms TimeData:Protection Paladin-standard-3:avengers_shield:0.03:Ability Known, Enabled(0.03) 37. hammer_of_wrath ( standard - 4 ) - ability disabled ( display ) Time spent on this action: 0.03ms TimeData:Protection Paladin-standard-4:hammer_of_wrath:0.03:Ability Known, Enabled(0.03) 38. judgment ( standard - 5 ) - ability disabled ( display ) Time spent on this action: 0.03ms TimeData:Protection Paladin-standard-5:judgment:0.03:Ability Known, Enabled(0.03) 39. divine_toll ( standard - 6 ) - ability disabled ( display ) Time spent on this action: 0.07ms TimeData:Protection Paladin-standard-6:divine_toll:0.07:Ability Known, Enabled(0.07) 40. avengers_shield ( standard - 7 ) - ability disabled ( display ) Time spent on this action: 0.03ms TimeData:Protection Paladin-standard-7:avengers_shield:0.03:Ability Known, Enabled(0.03) 41. hammer_of_wrath ( standard - 8 ) - ability disabled ( display ) Time spent on this action: 0.03ms TimeData:Protection Paladin-standard-8:hammer_of_wrath:0.03:Ability Known, Enabled(0.03) 42. judgment ( standard - 9 ) - ability disabled ( display ) Time spent on this action: 0.03ms TimeData:Protection Paladin-standard-9:judgment:0.03:Ability Known, Enabled(0.03) 43. consecration ( standard - 10 ) - ability disabled ( display ) Time spent on this action: 0.03ms TimeData:Protection Paladin-standard-10:consecration:0.03:Ability Known, Enabled(0.03) 44. eye_of_tyr ( standard - 11 ) - ability disabled ( toggle a ) Time spent on this action: 0.03ms TimeData:Protection Paladin-standard-11:eye_of_tyr:0.03:Ability Known, Enabled(0.03) 45. blessed_hammer ( standard - 12 ) - ability disabled ( display ) Time spent on this action: 0.03ms TimeData:Protection Paladin-standard-12:blessed_hammer:0.03:Ability Known, Enabled(0.03) 46. hammer_of_the_righteous ( standard - 13 ) - talent [ hammer_of_the_righteous ] missing Time spent on this action: 0.03ms TimeData:Protection Paladin-standard-13:hammer_of_the_righteous:0.03:Ability Known, Enabled(0.03) 47. crusader_strike ( standard - 14 ) - talent [ blessed_hammer ] disallowed Time spent on this action: 0.03ms TimeData:Protection Paladin-standard-14:crusader_strike:0.03:Ability Known, Enabled(0.03) 48. word_of_glory ( standard - 15 ) - ability disabled ( display ) Time spent on this action: 0.03ms TimeData:Protection Paladin-standard-15:word_of_glory:0.03:Ability Known, Enabled(0.03) 49. consecration ( standard - 16 ) - ability disabled ( display ) Time spent on this action: 0.03ms TimeData:Protection Paladin-standard-16:consecration:0.03:Ability Known, Enabled(0.03) Exiting standard with recommendation of NO ACTION at +10.00s. Returned from list (standard), current recommendation is NO ACTION (+10.00). - standard Exiting default with recommendation of NO ACTION at +10.00s. Completed default action list [ Protection Paladin - default ]. Recommendation is NO ACTION at 0.00 + 10.00. Recommendation #1 is NO ACTION at 10.00s (10.00s). Resources: Resources: holy_power[ 0.00 / 5.00 | 0.00 @ [1 - actual] 0.00 ], mana[ 50000.00 / 50000.00 | 50000.00 @ [1 - actual] 0.00 ] Time spent generating recommendations: 4.50ms
Raidbots Sim Report (Link)
No response
Additional Information
No response
Contact Information
No response