Add Shelter type quest

[mcliquid]

@Helium314 I'm bringing here my old shelter_type quest. See: Old PR: https://github.com/streetcomplete/StreetComplete/pull/4428 Old Issue: https://github.com/streetcomplete/StreetComplete/issues/4418

The reason for rejection at that time was that an ordinary SC user could hardly distinguish the images. I hope this is different in SCEE. What do you think?

[mcliquid]

Damn, I should probably not update branches in between. Is it bad that the last three commits don't belong?

[HolgerJeromin]

Is it bad that the last three commits don't belong?

With git rebase -i HEAD~5 you can drop them.

[mcliquid]

Does it work?

[Helium314]

In some cases it's not so clear. The difference between gazebo and picnic shelter is just whether some sort of (picnic) table is inside? The lean-to wouldn't be clear to me without reading the wiki. I would have tagged some of the examples from the wiki as weather shelter when just looking at the images. Possibly some short text mentioning the 3 walls would help. Weather shelter seems to be some sort of generic type that may fit for most other types. Not sure, but maybe it should only be selectable via other answers to discourage users from tagging everything as weather shelter.

[Helium314]

Does it work?

No, there are still other changes in the PR. I don't know enough about git to tell you how to properly sort this out...

[mcliquid]

I've looked around in JOSM and iD which options they will give you with naming in english / german:

iD (via search)

In general, iD will call a amenity=shelter without sub-tag a "Shelter / Wetterschutz"

• public_transport (Transit Shelter / Überdachter Wartebereich)
• picnic_shelter (Picnic Shelter / Überdachte Picknickmöglichkeit)
• lean_to (Lean-To / offene Schutzhütte)
• gazebo (Gazebo / Aussichtspavillon)

JOSM Preset / Translations

• basic_hut (Basic Hut / Biwakschachtel / Einfache Hütte)
• gazebo (Gazbo / Aussichtstürmchen (Gazebo) / Aussichtspavillon)
• lean_to (Lean-To / offene Schutzhütte / Schutzhütte mit typischerweise drei Wänden)
• picnic_shelter (Picnic Shelter / Picknickhütte/ Picknickplatzdach)
• public_transport (Öffentlicher Nahverkehr)
• weather_shelter (Weather Shelter / Wetterschutz)
• wildlife_hide (Wildtierschutz)
• sun_shelter (Sun Shelter / Sonnenschutz)
• rock_shelter (Rock Shelter / Felsvorsprung)
• field_shelter (Field Shelter / Weidezelt)
• animal_shelter (Animal Shelter / Tierheim)

Learnings

• Neither JOSM nor iD use pavilion as a value
• lean_to is really just a minimal roofing, which is specifically designed for overnight stays, but compared to the Basic Hut, it is not completely enclosed
• For the rest, I would say it is a matter of taste which value you take. But in case of doubt I would leave the power to the people to handle respectfully with SCEE right?

[mcliquid]

I've added a individual warning message:

I tried to enlarge the titles but than it's to long and you can't read the text properly / can't see the image. I could rebuild the whole quest (like smoothness) so you could add a description too, but with 10 values that's quite a lot to scroll / read. What do you think?

[Helium314]

I think it's ok, let's keep the current style.

Could you move the weather shelter into an other answer? It really seems to be a rather generic type, and I don't want users to choose this over more specific types.

Then there is the issue with the unrelated commits... that should be sorted out.

[mcliquid]

I've tried but failed 😢

[Helium314]

You could revert those commits, so at least the changes are not part of this PR.

[mcliquid]

@Helium314 Reverting seems to work. And removed pavilion assets because unused.

[Helium314]

I added the weather_shelter as an other answer, in a simpler way as suggested above, I hope you're ok with that.

Could you re-check the additions in authors.txt? Several link go to different images. Also the weather shelter image could be removed.

[mcliquid]

Thanks! All done 👍

[Helium314]

Thanks 👍