"What is the width of the opening" allows a maximum of 9.99 meter, not enough

[ratti]

The question "What is the width of the opening" allows a maximum of 9.99 meter, which is not enough for industrial entrances, flood protection gates etc.

How to Reproduce Find that question somewhere, try to answer i.e. "18". Higest number I can type is 9.99 , not 10.

Expected Behavior While some validation is useful, hangars or flood gates should be possible.

Does it happen in normal StreetComplete? It looks like SCEE merged this feature from a SC alpha I can't test.

Versions affected SCEE 58.22 SC: I can see people discussing this in threads related to 59.0-alpha, but I run 58.2 and don't have that feature.

[mnalis]

Can you give an example object where that happens (i.e. where you needed to tag more 9.99m)?

SC: I can see people discussing this in threads related to 59.0-alpha, but I run 58.2 and don't have that feature.

Yes, the quest is present only in StreetComplete v59.0-alpha1 and newer.

So it would be best if you @ratti could report the issue there (and only if it won't be resolved there ask for it here). Any code change that can be made upstream in vanilla StreetComplete, makes a life of SCEE maintainers much easier, especially in the long run!

While some validation is useful, hangars or flood gates should be possible.

How are those even tagged in OpenStreetMap? Is the quest being asked on them, i.e.:

https://github.com/Helium314/SCEE/blob/a0804440a2f858b5300b9f2d0a8962542d7e729a/app/src/main/java/de/westnordost/streetcomplete/quests/barrier_opening/AddBarrierOpening.kt#L24-L25

[ratti]

Hello,

Can you give an example object where that happens (i.e. where you needed to tag more 9.99m)?

I guess we can skip the part where I search for specific nodes, by just giving some examples where I had that issue. I was mapping in the Hamburg industrial port area, and I got asked that question on…:

• Stormflood barriers going across multiple road lanes
• Entrances to heavy industrial companies
• Airport hangar doors for jumbo jets
• I didn't come across that, but I guess at the ocean coast there even might be “gates“ wider than 100 meters, wild guess.

This is a photo I made some time ago:

That's the flood protection barrier for Hamburg Neumühlen, and it's a “small“ one ;-)

To be honest, I found it a bit irritating to get that question asked with a wheelchair symbol refering to the main entrance of a steel factory.

[EDIT]: Yes, I'll make a ticket with SC.

[mnalis]

Thanks, fixed upstream in https://github.com/streetcomplete/StreetComplete/commit/ef4d703029ca7b327eedcb50a16a652066a882be - next release should have it!