search

HelpAPaw / Android

9 stars 2 forks source link

Not logged in user > My Signals > Log in form > Navigate back > User is able to see the menu #70

Open pezekieva opened 2 years ago

pezekieva commented 2 years ago

Description

Minor issue in case a user is not logged in and tries to open My Signals menu, then they are redirected to the Login page, but instead of logging in, they navigate back - they are redirected to the 'My Signals' menu, which is supposed to not be accessible.

Steps to reproduce

  1. Open the application and do not log in
  2. Go to the side menu > Select 'My Signals' -> A pop-up is displayed informing the user that this page is restricted to registered users
  3. On the pop-up, click on 'OK" -> User is redirected to Login page
  4. Do not log in
  5. Instead, use the Android navigation to go back to the previous page

Expected result The user is redirected back to the previous page and is still not able to open 'My Signals' menu, as they're still not logged in.

Actual result The user is redirected to 'My Signals' menu. As a user, I would consider this not ideal, although it's not a big issue. Please see a video of the described behavior.

Test Data version - 5.1.0(82) device - Android 11, OxygenOS 11.1.2.2 for OnePlus 6

Polina1985 commented 2 years ago

Здравей, доколкото знам, само регистрирани useri могат да ползват приложението и да логват сигнали и коментират.

medeaohm commented 2 years ago

Да, тук наистина е малко странно, но трябва да помислим как би било по-добре да се държи. Очакваме ли при натискаме на back бутона да се върнем на My Signals и отново да ни изкара pop-up-a? Аз честно казано като user не съм сигурна как бих предпочела да се държи, може би за сега не си заслужава да го променяме?

BurningAXE commented 2 years ago

Реално потребителят вижда празен екран, което е очаквано след като е видял съобщението и умишлено не се е логнал. Не мисля, че си заслужава да отделяме време за това.