HopkinsIDD / cholera-mapping-pipeline

Formerly part of cholera-taxonomy. The map creation scripts, packages, and file structure
1 stars 3 forks source link

MLI 2011-15 #419

Open eclee25 opened 1 year ago

QLLZ commented 1 year ago

Data pull: HASH: 6772ea9da4f43ddc3da11c494a573af2ca3dd3c8 config

QLLZ commented 1 year ago

log file

QLLZ commented 1 year ago

rerun from data pull: data pull on dev: HASH c9a89d4ac5e4f63cb75fa5c006a900ece2839199

log file

javierps commented 1 year ago

@QLLZ could you see if pulling the output shapefiles manually with taxdat leads to an error. If not, this seems to be again something random. Would suggest re-launching.

QLLZ commented 1 year ago

preprocessed_data file was created manually by running the set_parameter R script to skip the error in get_country_admin_units.

HASH: c9a89d4ac5e4f63cb75fa5c006a900ece2839199

QLLZ commented 1 year ago

Model running: HASH 6772ea9da4f43ddc3da11c494a573af2ca3dd3c8

QLLZ commented 1 year ago

Country data report

javierps commented 1 year ago

All OK. Only point is the high rates in the pixels along the north border in the center of the country. This can probably be solved with higher sfrac thresh for borders.

Suggestion: Accept, and if time allows re-run with higher border sfrac value.

eclee25 commented 1 year ago

All okay except rate maps do not match GAM input maps very well.

Opinion: Temporary Approve. Low priority rerun with higher sfrac_thresh_border

QLLZ commented 1 year ago

Config

Data pull & Model run:

HASH: 211913e0eb7d570ed62c48bc1ae9ecd6671a6cbc

QLLZ commented 1 year ago

country data report

QLLZ commented 1 year ago

Rhat is slightly not converged. Other results look good.

Suggestion: accept.

eclee25 commented 1 year ago

Poor sd_w convergence and mild w convergence issues. Minimal subnational data and minimal population in northern part of country. High incidence rates in area with very small population.... Opinion: Rerun with do_sd_w_mixture: no

QLLZ commented 1 year ago

Updated config

QLLZ commented 1 year ago

Data pull & model run:

HASH: 211913e0eb7d570ed62c48bc1ae9ecd6671a6cbc

QLLZ commented 1 year ago

Updated country data report

eclee25 commented 1 year ago

I don’t think MLI looks too bad without the mixture sd_w prior — while there are Rhat issues, there really isn’t much non-zero subnational data to inform the model and the year with high subnational coverage (2013) only has 23 cases.

javierps commented 1 year ago

Agreed. I would suggest to accept.

eclee25 commented 1 year ago

ID-57 run is approved. For future runs, we need to have do_sd_w_mixture: no Approve ID-57

QLLZ commented 12 months ago

Data pull, model run:

HASH: 05f598b95b5d42ac0049963f8a0b7e04d6f1dbd7

javierps commented 12 months ago

Some issues with rho convergence, but overall w and std_w converged quite well. Only few obs with rhat above threshold but very reasonable values (1.06).

Suggestion: accept.

eclee25 commented 11 months ago

Approve - not sure we'll get much better than this for these data