Closed zed-wong closed 2 weeks ago
The latest updates on your projects. Learn more about Vercel for Git โ๏ธ
Name | Status | Preview | Comments | Updated (UTC) |
---|---|---|---|---|
mr-market | โ Ready (Inspect) | Visit Preview | ๐ฌ Add feedback | Jun 19, 2024 5:23am |
๐ Previously deployed to Railway in the quiet-desk project. Environment has been deleted.
โฑ๏ธ Estimated effort to review [1-5] | 2 |
๐งช Relevant tests | No |
๐ Security concerns | No |
โก Key issues to review | None |
Failed to generate code suggestions for PR
Persistent review updated to latest commit https://github.com/Hu-Fi/Mr.Market/commit/e27ce2f1f77f1ba5248ffd82c9e9d16b746d5556
Category | Suggestion | Score |
Security |
Enhance security by abstracting API key management to a dedicated service with encryption and access controls___ **To ensure better security practices, consider abstracting the API key management to aseparate service or module that handles encryption and access controls, rather than directly loading and managing API keys within the service.** [server/src/modules/mixin/exchange/exchange.service.ts [89-91]](https://github.com/Hu-Fi/Mr.Market/pull/197/files#diff-b4d701c594440771180bbf709c88654f1d8a3806e45b2e035b3b36572ab3cda5R89-R91) ```diff import * as ccxt from 'ccxt'; import BigNumber from 'bignumber.js'; import { Cron } from '@nestjs/schedule'; +import { ApiKeyManagementService } from 'path/to/security'; ``` Suggestion importance[1-10]: 10Why: Abstracting API key management to a dedicated service with encryption and access controls is a critical security improvement, ensuring better protection of sensitive information. | 10 |
Performance |
Improve performance and reduce latency by using WebSocket connections for market data updates___ **For better performance and reduced latency, consider using WebSocket connections forwatching market data instead of polling methods if supported by the exchange APIs.** [server/src/modules/marketdata/marketdata.service.ts [63-65]](https://github.com/Hu-Fi/Mr.Market/pull/197/files#diff-0dd39c41f8551fc930baf35b0c2b376e2ac0d12e686a82d86d7cee070f4bf16aR63-R65) ```diff import * as ccxt from 'ccxt'; import { Cache } from 'cache-manager'; import { CACHE_MANAGER } from '@nestjs/cache-manager'; +import { WebSocket } from 'ws'; ``` Suggestion importance[1-10]: 9Why: Using WebSocket connections can greatly improve performance and reduce latency, which is crucial for real-time market data updates. | 9 |
Validation |
Enhance the reliability of withdrawal requests by adding input validation___ **For thecreateWithdrawal method, consider implementing input validation to ensure that the parameters meet expected formats and constraints before processing.** [server/src/modules/mixin/rebalance/bigone/bigone.service.ts [29]](https://github.com/Hu-Fi/Mr.Market/pull/197/files#diff-a3302c8c9bb13445d2bd14f68aef2841d4bf3a779d9033f5ed05f7014192b70bR29-R29) ```diff -createWithdrawal(symbol: string, targetAddress: string, amount: string, memo?: string, guid?: string, gatewayName?: string): Creates a new withdrawal request. +createWithdrawal(symbol: string, targetAddress: string, amount: string, memo?: string, guid?: string, gatewayName?: string): void { + if (!validateSymbol(symbol) || !validateAddress(targetAddress) || !validateAmount(amount)) { + throw new Error("Invalid input parameters"); + } + // existing implementation +} ``` Suggestion importance[1-10]: 9Why: Adding input validation significantly enhances the reliability and security of withdrawal requests, making it a crucial improvement. | 9 |
Error handling |
Enhance error handling by adding a retry mechanism with exponential backoff for API requests___ **To enhance error handling, consider implementing a retry mechanism with exponentialbackoff for API requests to CoinGecko. This can help manage transient network issues or API rate limits more gracefully.** [server/src/modules/coingecko/coingecko.service.ts [34-36]](https://github.com/Hu-Fi/Mr.Market/pull/197/files#diff-fc8069e1fb6be7ac5ca3b7e95e0de665542438306d2ea1ac330338bb91117b42R34-R36) ```diff import { Cache } from 'cache-manager'; import { CACHE_MANAGER } from '@nestjs/cache-manager'; import { Inject, Injectable } from '@nestjs/common'; +import { retryBackoff } from 'backoff-rxjs'; ``` Suggestion importance[1-10]: 8Why: Implementing a retry mechanism with exponential backoff is a significant improvement for error handling, especially for network-related issues and API rate limits. | 8 |
Enhance robustness by adding error handling within event processing methods___ **To enhance error handling, consider implementing try-catch blocks within thehandleReleaseTokenEvent method to catch and handle potential exceptions during the event processing.** [server/src/modules/mixin/listeners/mixin.listener.ts [22]](https://github.com/Hu-Fi/Mr.Market/pull/197/files#diff-a80b7fd33a110e4c518ad2bea7d776f38f62284e85057a7b409a1a496a05552eR22-R22) ```diff -handleReleaseTokenEvent(e: MixinReleaseTokenEvent): Handles the 'mixin.release' event. +handleReleaseTokenEvent(e: MixinReleaseTokenEvent): void { + try { + // existing implementation + } catch (error) { + // error handling logic + } +} ``` Suggestion importance[1-10]: 8Why: Implementing try-catch blocks enhances robustness by handling potential exceptions, which is important for maintaining reliability in event processing. | 8 | |
Best practice |
Encapsulate class methods using TypeScript access modifiers to enhance class API cleanliness and maintainability___ **Consider using TypeScript's access modifiers (private, protected, public) for methods inthe StrategyService class to encapsulate the class's internal behavior and expose only necessary methods to the outside. This can help in maintaining a clean API for the service class.** [server/src/modules/strategy/strategy.service.ts [26-32]](https://github.com/Hu-Fi/Mr.Market/pull/197/files#diff-413cb1b28e0d47a46768f97d10145a8e14d9e46b0a195768786127305916d944R26-R32) ```diff -- startArbitrageIfNotStarted(): Starts an arbitrage strategy if it is not already running. -- pauseStrategyIfNotPaused(): Pauses a strategy if it is not already paused. -- startArbitrageStrategyForUser(): Starts an arbitrage strategy for a user. -- stopStrategyForUser(): Stops a strategy for a user and cancels all active orders. +- private startArbitrageIfNotStarted(): Starts an arbitrage strategy if it is not already running. +- private pauseStrategyIfNotPaused(): Pauses a strategy if it is not already paused. +- public startArbitrageStrategyForUser(): Starts an arbitrage strategy for a user. +- public stopStrategyForUser(): Stops a strategy for a user and cancels all active orders. ``` Suggestion importance[1-10]: 8Why: Using access modifiers is a best practice in TypeScript to encapsulate internal behavior and maintain a clean API. This suggestion improves code maintainability and readability by clearly defining the visibility of each method. | 8 |
Improve type safety and readability by adding explicit return type annotations___ **Consider adding explicit type annotations to the parameters of thehandleMarketMakingCreate method to improve type safety and code readability.**
[server/src/modules/mixin/listeners/market_making.listener.ts [20]](https://github.com/Hu-Fi/Mr.Market/pull/197/files#diff-af2b696faff84be74534526cbd7bca07e7a0630c04ce6f07be1b846fc8424ebbR20-R20)
```diff
-handleMarketMakingCreate(details: MarketMakingMemoDetails, snapshot: SafeSnapshot): Handles the 'market_making.create' event.
+handleMarketMakingCreate(details: MarketMakingMemoDetails, snapshot: SafeSnapshot): void {
```
Suggestion importance[1-10]: 7Why: Adding explicit return type annotations improves type safety and code readability, which is a good practice, but it is not crucial for functionality. | 7 | |
Maintainability |
Improve testability and maintainability by using dependency injection for external dependencies___ **Consider using dependency injection forcreateHash and getUserMe to enhance testability and maintainability of the AuthService . This approach allows for easier mocking and testing of these dependencies.** [server/src/modules/auth/auth.service.ts [33-35]](https://github.com/Hu-Fi/Mr.Market/pull/197/files#diff-eab35d13c5ac358d201e1aa04e568c972b43247760dfb4928be546c494f46e6fR33-R35) ```diff import { JwtService } from '@nestjs/jwt'; -import { Injectable, UnauthorizedException } from '@nestjs/common'; +import { Injectable, UnauthorizedException, Inject } from '@nestjs/common'; +import { HashService, UserMeService } from 'path/to/services'; ``` Suggestion importance[1-10]: 7Why: The suggestion improves testability and maintainability by using dependency injection, which is a good practice. However, it is not addressing a critical issue. | 7 |
Improve readability and maintainability by refactoring the large comment block into smaller, method-specific comments___ **Refactor the large comment block into smaller, method-specific comments placed directlyabove each method. This improves readability and maintainability, making it easier to understand the purpose and functionality of individual methods without scrolling through a large block of text.** [server/src/modules/strategy/strategy.service.ts [1-74]](https://github.com/Hu-Fi/Mr.Market/pull/197/files#diff-413cb1b28e0d47a46768f97d10145a8e14d9e46b0a195768786127305916d944R1-R74) ```diff -/** - * StrategyService - * - * This service manages and executes trading strategies, including arbitrage and market making. - * It utilizes the CCXT library for interacting with cryptocurrency exchanges and provides functionality - * for starting, stopping, and managing strategies for users. - * ... - */ +// Individual method comments placed above each method ``` Suggestion importance[1-10]: 7Why: Breaking down the large comment block into method-specific comments enhances readability and maintainability. It allows developers to quickly understand the purpose of each method without having to scroll through a lengthy comment section. | 7 | |
Improve maintainability and testability by refactoring complex methods into smaller, focused methods___ **Refactor thehandleSpotOrderCreateEvent method to separate concerns, such as validation and event emission, into smaller, more focused methods. This can improve maintainability and testability.** [server/src/modules/mixin/listeners/spot.listener.ts [21]](https://github.com/Hu-Fi/Mr.Market/pull/197/files#diff-9b96aa45a591410a1dec754649c4667c171f120038542e25032efd39431ba67fR21-R21) ```diff -handleSpotOrderCreateEvent(event: SpotOrderCreateEvent): Handles the 'spot.create' event. +handleSpotOrderCreateEvent(event: SpotOrderCreateEvent): void { + validateEvent(event); + processEvent(event); + emitPlaceOrderEvent(event); +} ``` Suggestion importance[1-10]: 6Why: Refactoring to separate concerns improves maintainability and testability, but it is not addressing a critical issue, making it a moderate improvement. | 6 |
Persistent review updated to latest commit https://github.com/Hu-Fi/Mr.Market/commit/e27ce2f1f77f1ba5248ffd82c9e9d16b746d5556
Persistent review updated to latest commit https://github.com/Hu-Fi/Mr.Market/commit/e27ce2f1f77f1ba5248ffd82c9e9d16b746d5556
Failed to generate code suggestions for PR
Category | Suggestion | Score |
Enhancement |
Add error handling to the transaction method to enhance service robustness___ **Consider implementing error handling in thesendMixinTx method to manage exceptions and provide feedback on transaction failures, enhancing the robustness of the service.** [server/src/modules/mixin/snapshots/snapshots.service.ts [28]](https://github.com/Hu-Fi/Mr.Market/pull/197/files#diff-dd336e520fcec14b837cd72c0852b94e85fb8e130fc2a3431b49fef7e4d94c29R28-R28) ```diff -sendMixinTx(opponent_id: string, asset_id: string, amount: string): Sends a transaction on the Mixin network. +sendMixinTx(opponent_id: string, asset_id: string, amount: string): Promise Suggestion importance[1-10]: 10Why: Adding error handling is essential for robustness, especially in transaction-related methods where failures need to be managed and logged appropriately. | 10 |
Enhance error handling and user feedback in the
___
**Refactor the method | 8 | |
Improve type safety by using a more specific type for the snapshot parameter___ **Consider using a more specific type thanSafeSnapshot for the snapshot parameter in the handleMarketMakingCreate method. If SafeSnapshot is a general type that includes more data than necessary, defining a more specific type could improve type safety and make the function's requirements clearer.** [server/src/modules/mixin/listeners/market_making.listener.ts [20]](https://github.com/Hu-Fi/Mr.Market/pull/197/files#diff-af2b696faff84be74534526cbd7bca07e7a0630c04ce6f07be1b846fc8424ebbR20-R20) ```diff -handleMarketMakingCreate(details: MarketMakingMemoDetails, snapshot: SafeSnapshot): Handles the 'market_making.create' event. +handleMarketMakingCreate(details: MarketMakingMemoDetails, snapshot: MarketMakingSnapshot): Handles the 'market_making.create' event. ``` Suggestion importance[1-10]: 7Why: Using a more specific type can improve type safety and code clarity, but it is not critical unless `SafeSnapshot` is indeed too generic and includes unnecessary data. | 7 | |
Security |
Improve security by adding password complexity checks in the
___
**To improve security, consider validating the length and complexity of the | 9 |
Possible issue |
Use a numeric type for monetary values to prevent calculation errors___ **Replace the use ofstring type for the amount parameter in the createWithdrawal method with a numeric type or a specific class that handles monetary values to prevent potential issues with currency calculations.** [server/src/modules/mixin/rebalance/bigone/bigone.service.ts [29]](https://github.com/Hu-Fi/Mr.Market/pull/197/files#diff-a3302c8c9bb13445d2bd14f68aef2841d4bf3a779d9033f5ed05f7014192b70bR29-R29) ```diff -createWithdrawal(symbol: string, targetAddress: string, amount: string, memo?: string, guid?: string, gatewayName?: string): Creates a new withdrawal request. +createWithdrawal(symbol: string, targetAddress: string, amount: number, memo?: string, guid?: string, gatewayName?: string): Creates a new withdrawal request. ``` Suggestion importance[1-10]: 9Why: Using a numeric type for monetary values is crucial to prevent calculation errors, which can have significant consequences in financial applications. | 9 |
Error handling |
Add error handling in the
___
**Implement error handling in the | 8 |
Maintainability |
Refactor the method to separate concerns for better maintainability___ **Refactor thehandleReleaseTokenEvent method to separate concerns. Currently, it validates data, updates order states, and records history, which can be split into smaller, more focused functions. This will improve maintainability and testability.** [server/src/modules/mixin/listeners/mixin.listener.ts [22]](https://github.com/Hu-Fi/Mr.Market/pull/197/files#diff-a80b7fd33a110e4c518ad2bea7d776f38f62284e85057a7b409a1a496a05552eR22-R22) ```diff -handleReleaseTokenEvent(e: MixinReleaseTokenEvent): Handles the 'mixin.release' event. +handleReleaseTokenEvent(e: MixinReleaseTokenEvent): void { + validateReleaseTokenEvent(e); + updateOrderState(e); + recordReleaseHistory(e); +} ``` Suggestion importance[1-10]: 8Why: Separating concerns in the method will improve maintainability and testability, making the code easier to manage and understand. | 8 |
Best practice |
Enhance testability and decoupling by using dependency injection for cryptographic functions___ **Consider using dependency injection forcreateHash to enhance testability and decoupling from the Node.js crypto module. This approach allows easier mocking and testing of the AuthService, especially when dealing with cryptographic functions.** [server/src/modules/auth/auth.service.ts [32]](https://github.com/Hu-Fi/Mr.Market/pull/197/files#diff-eab35d13c5ac358d201e1aa04e568c972b43247760dfb4928be546c494f46e6fR32-R32) ```diff -import { createHash } from 'crypto'; +import { CryptoService } from './crypto.service'; // Assuming CryptoService wraps createHash functionality ``` Suggestion importance[1-10]: 7Why: This suggestion improves testability and decoupling, which are good practices. However, it requires significant refactoring and the creation of a new service, which may not be immediately necessary. | 7 |
Improve type safety and maintainability by defining TypeScript interfaces for DTOs___ **Consider using TypeScript interfaces or types to define the structure of the DTOs andother complex objects used in the service. This will enhance type safety and improve the maintainability of the code.** [server/src/modules/strategy/strategy.service.ts [13]](https://github.com/Hu-Fi/Mr.Market/pull/197/files#diff-413cb1b28e0d47a46768f97d10145a8e14d9e46b0a195768786127305916d944R13-R13) ```diff -- DTOs: ArbitrageStrategyDto and PureMarketMakingStrategyDto for handling strategy data transfer objects. +- DTOs: IArbitrageStrategyDto and IPureMarketMakingStrategyDto for handling strategy data transfer objects. ``` Suggestion importance[1-10]: 7Why: Using TypeScript interfaces or types for DTOs can enhance type safety and maintainability. However, the suggestion does not directly address any critical issues or bugs in the current implementation. | 7 | |
Performance |
Improve the efficiency of the
___
**To ensure that the | 7 |
Enhance performance by adding pagination support to the
___
**For the | 6 | |
Reduce API calls and enhance performance by adding caching to the
___
**Implement caching for the method | 6 |
User description
Description
Add comment for all service files in improve readability
Summary of changes
Added comment of 'what does this service do' on top of each service file
How to test the changes
Read
Related issues
https://github.com/Hu-Fi/Mr.Market/issues/195
PR Type
documentation
Description
Changes walkthrough ๐
20 files
auth.service.ts
Add detailed JSDoc comments to AuthService class
server/src/modules/auth/auth.service.ts
dependencies, methods, and error handling.
coingecko.service.ts
Add detailed JSDoc comments to CoingeckoProxyService class
server/src/modules/coingecko/coingecko.service.ts
class, its dependencies, methods, and error handling.
customConfig.service.ts
Add detailed JSDoc comments to CustomConfigService class
server/src/modules/customConfig/customConfig.service.ts
class, its dependencies, methods, and notes.
health.service.ts
Add detailed JSDoc comments to HealthService class
server/src/modules/health/health.service.ts
dependencies, methods, and error handling.
logger.service.ts
Add detailed JSDoc comments to CustomLogger class
server/src/modules/logger/logger.service.ts
dependencies, methods, and configuration.
marketdata.service.ts
Add detailed JSDoc comments to MarketdataService class
server/src/modules/marketdata/marketdata.service.ts
its dependencies, methods, and error handling.
exchange.service.ts
Add detailed JSDoc comments to ExchangeService class
server/src/modules/mixin/exchange/exchange.service.ts
its dependencies, methods, and error handling.
arbitrage.listener.ts
Add detailed JSDoc comments to ArbitrageListener class
server/src/modules/mixin/listeners/arbitrage.listener.ts
its dependencies, methods, and notes.
exchange.listener.ts
Add detailed JSDoc comments to ExchangeListener class
server/src/modules/mixin/listeners/exchange.listener.ts
its dependencies, methods, and notes.
market_making.listener.ts
Add detailed JSDoc comments to MarketMakingListener class
server/src/modules/mixin/listeners/market_making.listener.ts
class, its dependencies, methods, and notes.
mixin.listener.ts
Add detailed JSDoc comments to MixinListener class
server/src/modules/mixin/listeners/mixin.listener.ts
dependencies, methods, and notes.
spot.listener.ts
Add detailed JSDoc comments to SpotOrderListener class
server/src/modules/mixin/listeners/spot.listener.ts
its dependencies, methods, and notes.
message.service.ts
Add detailed JSDoc comments to MessageService class
server/src/modules/mixin/message/message.service.ts
dependencies, methods, and error handling.
bigone.service.ts
Add detailed JSDoc comments to BigoneService class
server/src/modules/mixin/rebalance/bigone/bigone.service.ts
dependencies, methods, and error handling.
rebalance.service.ts
Add detailed JSDoc comments to RebalanceService class
server/src/modules/mixin/rebalance/rebalance.service.ts
its dependencies, methods, and error handling.
snapshots.service.ts
Add detailed JSDoc comments to SnapshotsService class
server/src/modules/mixin/snapshots/snapshots.service.ts
its dependencies, methods, and error handling.
user.service.ts
Add detailed JSDoc comments to UserService class
server/src/modules/mixin/user/user.service.ts
dependencies, methods, and error handling.
performance.service.ts
Add detailed JSDoc comments to PerformanceService class
server/src/modules/performance/performance.service.ts
its dependencies, methods, and notes.
strategy.service.ts
Add detailed JSDoc comments to StrategyService class
server/src/modules/strategy/strategy.service.ts
its dependencies, methods, and error handling.
trade.service.ts
Add detailed JSDoc comments to TradeService class
server/src/modules/trade/trade.service.ts
dependencies, methods, and error handling.