Open Huggenguggen opened 1 year ago
Accepted, but this should be a DocumentationBug
. For our documentation, we were referring to the "parameters" of a role when we mentioned that "when a parameter is expected once, it will take the last instance of the parameter". We were not referring to the general "parameters" of a command.
Team chose [type.DocumentationBug
]
Originally [type.FunctionalityBug
]
Reason for disagreement: While you could differentiate between the "parameters" of a role vs the "parameters" of a command, I would find that pedantic and not intuitive as a user. As such, I still section this under a Functionality Bug. Going by the textbook,
I also think this qualifies as a Functionality Bug. As a developer myself, it should be possible to implement and accommodate the multiple parameter issue in commands like delete and edit.
Recreate:
delete 1 2 3
Expected: it will delete the third index Actual: it throws an error
The UG specifies if a parameter is expected only once in the command but you specified it multiple times, only the last occurrence of the parameter will be taken.
Fix: Either fix the behavior to be consistent with UG, or change the UG.