HumanCellAtlas / ontology

3 stars 1 forks source link

Add term for surgeon and microsurgeon roles #36

Closed willrockout closed 5 years ago

willrockout commented 5 years ago

For new term requests

1. Surgeon

Preferred term label

surgeon

Synonyms

None

Textual definition

A physician who performs surgical operations.

Suggested parent term

Organization role

Use case

A project may add a contributor that is a surgeon. Currently, have a dataset with this role for a contributor.

1. Microsurgeon

Preferred term label

microsurgeon

Synonyms

None

Textual definition

A physician who performs surgery requiring an operating microscope.

Suggested parent term

Child of the above proposed new surgeon term as this is a subtype of surgeon.

Use case

A project may add a contributor that is a surgeon. Currently, have a dataset with this role for a contributor.

daniwelter commented 5 years ago

Would this use case not be covered by the existing clinician term?

willrockout commented 5 years ago

Yeah, that's what I was leaning towards but I thought it wasn't specific enough. You have a better idea on these than me so if you think it works I will use clinician.

daniwelter commented 5 years ago

Assuming this is for the contacts tab, unless there's a really compelling argument why users must know that this contributor is specifically a (micro)surgeon rather than a clinician in general (as opposed to an experimental scientist, computational scientist or PI), I don't think we need to capture this level of detail. I'd rather not set a precedent of becoming too detailed this early on or we may end up with submitters jumping up and down, insisting on very specific job titles.

If you're happy with that, please close the ticket :)

willrockout commented 5 years ago

Works for me!