search

HumanRightsMeasurementInitiative / hrmi-dataportal

https://rightstracker.org
Other
4 stars 8 forks source link

Explain missing 'People' data on QoL tab #124

Closed annemariebrook closed 4 years ago

annemariebrook commented 4 years ago

On the Quality of Life tab at the very bottom we have the People at Risk section. For non-survey countries we have no data. @tmfrnz, can we please add a line of text to explain?

Here is some place-holder text (we might edit it).

“Information on people at risk comes from our annual expert survey. No data on this is currently available for {Samoa}"

I think this solution is preferable to removing the "People at risk" section from the Tab, as it lets people know what could be available (in the case of Samoa very soon!).

tmfrnz commented 4 years ago

Yes will add

annemariebrook commented 4 years ago

Thanks. Here's the updated text we've decided to go with. "'Information on which people are at extra risk of rights violations comes from our annual expert survey, and is not yet available for {Samoa}"

tmfrnz commented 4 years ago

This has now been added. Also, I added a translation task to #128.

Further I removed the sentence as it is mostly redundant with the metric selector above (duplicate text in bold):

"We asked human rights experts to choose from a list of options which people were particularly at risk of having this right violated. The images below show their answers."

Metric selector text:

"Which people in Australia were identified by human rights experts to be particularly at risk of having their Right to education violated?"

The sentence is however still used in the country at risk tab.

If you think additional information is required I suggest adding this to the metric selector text field: hrmi.components.ChartSettingMetrics.people

tmfrnz commented 4 years ago

Here the previous version with the redundant information image

tmfrnz commented 4 years ago

Related to this: we do not currently offer the at-risk tab for countries that do not have at-risk data, but we do offer the 2 CPR tabs even if we do not show any data.

Would probably be good to treat this tabs consistently, either by also always showing the at-risk tab (with the no data hint when data is missing) or not offer the 2 CPR tabs if CPR data is missing. What do you think?

annemariebrook commented 4 years ago

Thanks @tmfrnz. We are happy to add back the at-risk tab for all countries (with the no data hint when data is missing).

We'd also like to add the relevant empty table to each of the 2 CPR tabs. In addition to the table we'd like to keep the existing text as well.

tmfrnz commented 4 years ago

We are happy to add back the at-risk tab for all countries (with the no data hint when data is missing).

Please refer to new issue https://github.com/HumanRightsMeasurementInitiative/hrmi-dataportal/issues/167