search

HyperAgents / hmas

An ontology to describe Hypermedia Multi-Agent Systems, interactions, and organizations.
https://purl.org/hmas/
1 stars 0 forks source link

`:HypermediaMASPlatform` or `:MASPlatform` or `:Platform` #85

Closed gnardin closed 2 years ago

gnardin commented 2 years ago

Are we going to keep the label :HypermediaMASPlatform?

We could not find any issue that explain the change from :Platform to :HypermediaMASPlatform,

FabienGandon commented 2 years ago

did you check issue #46 ?

oboissier commented 2 years ago

Yes, this is why we raised this issue. We see the explanation about the suppress of 'H', but no reason about the use of :HypermediaMASPlatform. In all the text the used terms are Platform . The term :HypermediaMASPlatform is in the ontology. Do we keep it?

andreiciortea commented 2 years ago

@gnardin @oboissier the issue that discusses the evolution from :Platform to :HypermediaMASPlatform is here: https://github.com/HyperAgents/ns.hyperagents.org/issues/20

In short: :Platform was the initial proposal but concluded to be ambiguous, the intermediate proposal was :MASPlatform, which was concluded to be ambiguous still, so the name of this concept then morphed into the more specific :HypermediaMASPlatform.

We should update any remaining references to Platform. We can also reopen the issue to consider new proposals.

DrLeturc commented 2 years ago

I don't think it is necessary to reopen the #46.

According to the title of the issue, it refers only to the use of the term :HypermediaMASPlatform and not :HAgent nor :HArtifact. For :HypermediaMASPlatform the reason was to disambiguate from :(MAS)Platform that wouldn't have the basic requirements for Hypermedia.

For the use of :(H)Agent we decided to not consider the (H) to keep the ontology as simple as possible. It seems that we actually don't need to make such distinction.

oboissier commented 2 years ago

Ok. Thanks for your replies. The point was not on issue #46 but as Andrei answered, it was about #20. Given your explanation and content of #20, I agree to keep the :HypermediaMASPlatform term.

gnardin commented 2 years ago

Thank you for the clarifications. I had missed the explanation in #20.