IAMconsortium / common-definitions

Repository for definitions and mappings in model comparison projects
Creative Commons Zero v1.0 Universal
9 stars 18 forks source link

Harmonize country mappings #14

Closed danielhuppmann closed 11 months ago

danielhuppmann commented 11 months ago

This PR re-implements the region-clean-up (#13), ensuring consistency across R5, R9 and R10 country mappings.

The following design choices were made:

Of course, these mappings are only a guidance, because actual model implementations will only be an imperfect approximation to these mappings.

danielhuppmann commented 11 months ago

what about all the small countries that aren't listed...

As far as I can see, the only missing countries have less than 1 million inhabitants, mostly small island states. So I would not add them until necessary, in favor of having a concise list.

danielhuppmann commented 11 months ago

Per a discussion with @volker-krey, I added a clear indication that OECD membership is as of the year 1990, to explain why South Korea is not part of the OECD regions. Our preference is to not redefine the regions at this point.

danielhuppmann commented 11 months ago

Re @christophbertram:

PAC_OECD looks to basically be Oceania plus Japan.

Thanks for that observation, the small-island states are actually duplicated in "Other Asia (R10)" - so I removed them from "Pacific OECD".

China+ and India+:

The aim of the R10 regions, as far as I understood, was actually to have aggregrate-regions that are not directly identifiable as a specific country. This is to avoid too much focus on the country-level in IPCC assessments. Hence, I continue that logic (and make minimal changes to previous definitions).