IFRCGo / go-frontend

MIT License
21 stars 5 forks source link

[PROD] Nicaraguan Red Cross is showing in menu and has National Society data - but is not an active NS #2948

Open nanometrenat opened 6 months ago

nanometrenat commented 6 months ago

Issue

Nicaraguan Red Cross was dissolved in May 2023, and as such Nicaragua does not currently have a National Society and is not currently part of the International Federation.

However GO is still listing Nicaragua in the Americas region menu, and is also showing a bunch of NS data on the National Society Overview page on Country pages (without referring to the dissolution)

https://go.ifrc.org/countries/126/ns-overview/activities

image

Need to figure out a way to make clear that Nicaragua is not a National Society (either remove it completely, or clearly label) so that the information doesn't get misinterpreted.

Approach taken by other IFRC systems

ifrc.org directory shows name of NS but only a single data point - the comment "dissolved 9 May 2023". FDRS takes the approach that they show historic data but include the dissolution details within the NS name: "Nicaraguan Red Cross* dissolved 9 May 2023" so it's clear https://data.ifrc.org/fdrs/national-society/DNI001

GO considerations

GO needs to also either hide Nicaragua completely or clearly show the dissolution.

Of particular concern:

Note

This may have been discussed before - but I can't find another ticket so logging here.

nanometrenat commented 6 months ago

Eritrea also showing as an NS but is not.

batpad commented 6 months ago

Thanks for this ticket @nanometrenat !

This does seem like another edge-case to our Country table, cc @frozenhelium @geohacker :-( - where the country still exists, of course, but the NS needs to be "deprecated".

Let's discuss this on the dev call - cc @tovari