Add an example for an image in annotation

[lpoujade]

Follow up of https://github.com/IIIF/cookbook-recipes/issues/377 , opened a pull request to generate the preview, which is accessible here

It probably miss something cause I don't see my recipe on this page

Also, I don't know what to put in the Restrictions part

[thehabes]

Your preview did build! It is at https://preview.iiif.io/cookbook/377-image-in-annotation/recipe/377-image-in-annotation/

[glenrobson]

Sorry @lpoujade I forgot to paste out comments into this pull request but we had a look at your recipe in the call last week and noted the following:

Use case

• Expand the use case with a particle example of how you want to do this e.g. I might have a picture of a person named in the manuscript or something else…
• It might be useful to show (with a small screenshot or partial screenshot) what you expect this to look like in a viewer. What do you do with large or small images.

Implementation note

• It would be useful to talk about how this recipe differs from the layers recipe? A different example may help as two versions of the same images could be done as a layer. Maybe a text based object and a related image might be clearer.
• Add to implementation notes other IIIF ways to achieve similar aims

Restrictions

• We couldn't come up with any restrictions.

Example

• Group likes the way you've done it with two bodies
• Viewers only include the one that works and note there is an issue with Annona which is fixed in #394
• Mirador also dosen’t show the image part of the annotation so not supported.

Also could you add a link to this recipe in the following file: https://github.com/IIIF/cookbook-recipes/blob/377-image-in-annotation/index.md and also in the links.md (note the number is the issue id so 00377 in this case).

[lpoujade]

Thank you @glenrobson ! I have seen the comments on the google doc but didn't had enough time to update my pr. I'll try to do it before the next cookbook call

About the layer recipe, I assume you are talking about this one ?

[lpoujade]

Hi, I updated my PR but got some questions:

• about how to render an image in a viewer, I was thinking to something like this (taken from this PR for Mirador), also the way Annona render it is really nice. But I don't have a clear idea in mind, I was thinking this could be at the discretion of the viewer. I could add thoses screenshots to the recipe, but i'm not sure if you wanted them here or in the recipe ?
• about the layer recipe I don't really see the similarity, my proposal is only about associating a picture with a small part of the main data, not an alternate representation of this data. I added some example use cases, does is clear the confusion ?

And about the different ways this can be done in IIIF, I'll have to search a bit !

[dnoneill]

This works in Annona for any id field now. Also the caption and attribution fields are description and attribution in the annotation. I think I got this based on an in the wild example but I have fixed Annona so it should not create undefined values if they don't exist in the annotation. Thanks for adding this, I only had one example to work from before and it was v2.

[lpoujade]

Cool! Glad it could help :) I updated the PR

[glenrobson]

The cookbook editors have reviewed your recipe and requested the following changes:

• Could you add an 's' to annotations in the title: "Image in annotations" (this is to match the HTML in annotations recipe)
• Patrick is going to leave notes on the pull request regarding a few small language issues in the use case
• Could you remove the !!! marks from the Tagging with an external resource link in the related recipes.
• Could you remove the sub bullets in the related recipes and move the text next to the link so it looks similar to the related recipes in: https://iiif.io/api/cookbook/recipe/0019-html-in-annotations/

With the above changes the editors are happy for it to go to the TRC for final review. Would you be able to make the above changes by next Wednesday?

Thanks

[lpoujade]

Yes I can update my PR next week

Le 27 avril 2023 15:48:07 GMT+02:00, Glen Robson @.***> a écrit :

The cookbook editors have reviewed your recipe and requested the following changes:

• Could you add an 's' to annotations in the title: "Image in annotations" (this is to match the HTML in annotations recipe)
• Patrick is going to leave notes on the pull request regarding a few small language issues in the use case
• Could you remove the !!! marks from the Tagging with an external resource link in the related recipes.
• Could you remove the sub bullets in the related recipes and move the text next to the link so it looks similar to the related recipes in: https://iiif.io/api/cookbook/recipe/0019-html-in-annotations/

With the above changes the editors are happy for it to go to the TRC for final review. Would you be able to make the above changes by next Wednesday?

Thanks

-- Reply to this email directly or view it on GitHub: https://github.com/IIIF/cookbook-recipes/pull/392#issuecomment-1525727553 You are receiving this because you were mentioned.

Message ID: @.***>